To the problem of medical-forensic procedure of remote examination of living persons: a scientific review

Abstract

This article describes the aspects of conducting a remote medical examination. The norms of the criminal procedure legislation of Kazakhstan and foreign countries regulating the procedure for conducting medical examinations, remote investigative actions, and scientific publications of researchers in the field of medicine are considered. A literature review on the study topic revealed studies of scientists on aspects of conducting medical examinations, problems arising during their production, and a description of individual medical cases conducted remotely and noted the lack of comprehensive holistic studies, including an algorithm of actions, the legal basis for conducting a medical examination in a remote format, and the practical advantages of their production.

Considering the generalization of scientific works and analysis of domestic and foreign legislation on the subject, the authors propose an algorithm for conducting medical examinations in an online format. In the present work, a SWOT analysis of remote medical examinations was performed, and the positive and negative aspects of the introduction of remote medical examinations were determined. The trends and risks of their implementation in practice are considered.

Based on the analysis of the national mechanism for conducting medical examinations and research and adaptation of the norms of foreign legislation on the issue under consideration, proposals have been formulated to improve the steps of medical examinations. The proposed algorithm for conducting remote medical examinations will allow solving some practical problems, which will significantly increase the efficiency of their production.

Keywords

remote medical examination / remote interrogation / persons with disabilities / medical examination / digitalization

References

[1] Baev OYa. Tactics of investigative actions: textbook. Voronezh: Voronezh State University; 2012. 440 p. (In Russ).

[2] Баев О.Я. Тактика следственных действий: учебное пособие. Воронеж: Воронежский госуниверситет, 2012. 440 с.

[3] Baev OYa. Tactics of investigative actions: textbook. Voronezh: Voronezh State University; 2012. 440 p. (In Russ).

[4] Kushkhov RH. Tactical and psychological features of participation of victims of crimes of physical persons in the course of preliminary investigation: on the materials of the Kabardino-Balkarian Republic [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Volgograd Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. Nalchik; 2007. 26 р. (In Russ).

[5] Кушхов Р.Х. Тактико-психологические особенности участия потерпевших от преступлений физических лиц в ходе предварительного расследования: по материалам Кабардино-Балкарской Республики: Автореф. дис. … канд. юр. наук: 12.00.09. Место защиты: Волгогр. акад. МВД России. Нальчик, 2007. 26 с.

[6] Kushkhov RH. Tactical and psychological features of participation of victims of crimes of physical persons in the course of preliminary investigation: on the materials of the Kabardino-Balkarian Republic [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Volgograd Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation. Nalchik; 2007. 26 р. (In Russ).

[7] Strogovich MS. Criminal process. Textbook. Moscow: Yuridicheskoe izdatel'stvo Ministerstva Yustitsii SSSR; 1946. P. 244. (In Russ).

[8] Строгович М.С. Уголовный процесс. Учебник. Москва: Юрид. изд-во МЮ СССР, 1946. С. 244.

[9] Strogovich MS. Criminal process. Textbook. Moscow: Yuridicheskoe izdatel'stvo Ministerstva Yustitsii SSSR; 1946. P. 244. (In Russ).

[10] Sementsov VA. Investigative actions: textbook. Ekaterinburg: Ural State Law Academy; 2003. 44 p. (In Russ).

[11] Семенцов В.А. Следственные действия: учебное пособие. Екатеринбург: УРГЮА, 2003. С. 44.

[12] Sementsov VA. Investigative actions: textbook. Ekaterinburg: Ural State Law Academy; 2003. 44 p. (In Russ).

[13] Torbin YuG, Baranov EV. Examination of the suspect at the preliminary investigation: textbook. Ed. by G.G. Zuikov. Kiev: Kievskaya vysshaya shkola Ministerstva vnutrennikh del SSSR; 1981. P. 10. (In Russ).

[14] Торбин Ю.Г., Баранов Е.В. Освидетельствование подозреваемого на предварительном следствии: учебное пособие / под ред. Г.Г. Зуйкова. Киев: КВШ МВД СССР, 1981. С. 10.

[15] Torbin YuG, Baranov EV. Examination of the suspect at the preliminary investigation: textbook. Ed. by G.G. Zuikov. Kiev: Kievskaya vysshaya shkola Ministerstva vnutrennikh del SSSR; 1981. P. 10. (In Russ).

[16] Voevodkin DV, Rustemova GR, Begaliev EN, et al. Identifying fake conclusions of forensic medical examinations using an artificial intelligence technology based on the experience in the Republic of Kazakhstan: A review. Russ J Forensic Med. 2023;9(3):287-298. EDN: EFNJIE doi: 10.17816/fm8270

[17] Воеводкин Д.В., Рустемова Г.Р., Бегалиев Е.Н., и др. К вопросу выявления поддельных заключений судебно-медицинских экспертиз посредством применения технологии искусственного интеллекта по опыту Республики Казахстан: научный обзор // Судебная медицина. 2023. Т. 9, № 3. С. 287-298. EDN: EFNJIE doi: 10.17816/fm8270

[18] Voevodkin DV, Rustemova GR, Begaliev EN, et al. Identifying fake conclusions of forensic medical examinations using an artificial intelligence technology based on the experience in the Republic of Kazakhstan: A review. Russ J Forensic Med. 2023;9(3):287-298. EDN: EFNJIE doi: 10.17816/fm8270

[19] Tarasov AA. New in legal forms of using special knowledge in proving criminal cases. Pravovaya politika i pravovaya zhizn'. 2004;(4):79-87. (In Russ).

[20] Тарасов А.А. Новое в правовых формах использования специальных знаний в доказывании по уголовным делам // Правовая политика и правовая жизнь. 2004. № 4. С. 79-87.

[21] Tarasov AA. New in legal forms of using special knowledge in proving criminal cases. Pravovaya politika i pravovaya zhizn'. 2004;(4):79-87. (In Russ).

[22] Zhogin NV, Fatkullin FN. Preliminary investigation in the Soviet criminal process. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura; 1965. Р. 142. (In Russ).

[23] Жогин Н.В., Фаткуллин Ф.Н. Предварительное следствие в советском уголовном процессе. Москва: Юридическая литература, 1965. С. 142.

[24] Zhogin NV, Fatkullin FN. Preliminary investigation in the Soviet criminal process. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura; 1965. Р. 142. (In Russ).

[25] Torbin YG. Theoretical and applied problems of detection and use in criminal proceedings of traces and special marks on living persons [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Research Institute of Problems of Strengthening Law and Order under the General Prosecutor's Office of the Russian Federation. Moscow; 2004. 52 р. (In Russ).

[26] Торбин Ю.Г. Теоретические и прикладные проблемы обнаружения и использования в уголовном судопроизводстве следов и особых примет на живых лицах: Автореф. дис. … д-ра юр. наук: 12.00.09. Место защиты: Науч.-исслед. ин-т проблем укрепления законности и правопорядка при Генеральной прокуратуре РФ. Москва, 2004. 52 с.

[27] Torbin YG. Theoretical and applied problems of detection and use in criminal proceedings of traces and special marks on living persons [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Research Institute of Problems of Strengthening Law and Order under the General Prosecutor's Office of the Russian Federation. Moscow; 2004. 52 р. (In Russ).

[28] Popov VL. Theoretical bases of forensic medicine. Saint Petersburg; 2000. 172 р. (In Russ).

[29] Попов В.Л. Теоретические основы судебной медицины. Санкт-Петербург, 2000. 172 с.

[30] Popov VL. Theoretical bases of forensic medicine. Saint Petersburg; 2000. 172 р. (In Russ).

[31] Kharzinova VM, Nebratenko GG. Problems of production survey. Yurist"-pravoved". 2015;(5):111-116. EDN: VIDMDH

[32] Харзинова В.М., Небратенко Г.Г. Проблемы производства освидетельствования // Юристъ-правоведъ. 2015. № 5. С. 111-116. EDN: VIDMDH

[33] Kharzinova VM, Nebratenko GG. Problems of production survey. Yurist"-pravoved". 2015;(5):111-116. EDN: VIDMDH

[34] Kokorev RA. Use of medical knowledge in the investigation of offences against the person [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.12. Place of defence: Peoples' Friendship University of Russia. Moscow; 2018. 25 р. (In Russ). EDN: UYCVWU

[35] Кокорев Р.А. Использование медицинских знаний в расследовании преступлений против личности: Автореф. дис ... канд. юр. наук: 12.00.12. Место защиты: Российский университет дружбы народов. Москва, 2018. 25 с. EDN: UYCVWU

[36] Kokorev RA. Use of medical knowledge in the investigation of offences against the person [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.12. Place of defence: Peoples' Friendship University of Russia. Moscow; 2018. 25 р. (In Russ). EDN: UYCVWU

[37] Polovinka VS, Sviridova TB, Demyankov KB, Lototsky MM. Remote monitoring systems for the health of workers. the state of the problem and prospects for development. Sovremennye problemy zdravookhraneniya i meditsinskoi statistiki. 2018;(2):113-122. EDN: UTBXVU

[38] Половинка В.С., Свиридова Т.Б., Демьянков К.Б., Лотоцкий М.М. Системы дистанционного мониторинга за состоянием здоровья работников. Состояние проблемы и перспективы развития // Современные проблемы здравоохранения и медицинской статистики. 2018. № 2. С. 113-122. EDN: UTBXVU

[39] Polovinka VS, Sviridova TB, Demyankov KB, Lototsky MM. Remote monitoring systems for the health of workers. the state of the problem and prospects for development. Sovremennye problemy zdravookhraneniya i meditsinskoi statistiki. 2018;(2):113-122. EDN: UTBXVU

[40] Golovnenkov P, Spitsa N. Criminal Procedure Code of the Federal Republic of Germany--Strafprozessordnung (StPO): Scientific and practical commentary and translation of the text of the law with an introductory article by Professor Uwe Hellmann "Introduction to the Criminal Procedure Law of the Federal Republic of Germany". Potsdam: University of Potsdam; 2012. 404 р. (In Russ).

[41] Головненков П., Спица Н. Уголовно-процессуальный кодекс Федеративной Республики Германия ― Strafprozessordnung (StPO): научно-практический комментарий и перевод текста закона со вступительной статьей профессора Уве Хелльманна «Введение в уголовно-процессуальное право ФРГ. Потдсдам: Университет Потсдама, 2012. 404 с.

[42] Golovnenkov P, Spitsa N. Criminal Procedure Code of the Federal Republic of Germany--Strafprozessordnung (StPO): Scientific and practical commentary and translation of the text of the law with an introductory article by Professor Uwe Hellmann "Introduction to the Criminal Procedure Law of the Federal Republic of Germany". Potsdam: University of Potsdam; 2012. 404 р. (In Russ).

[43] Sokolov YuN. Technological adaptability: Characteristic of criminal proceedings. Nauchnyi ezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava Ural'skogo otdeleniya Rossiiskoi akademii nauk. 2015;15(1):125-140. EDN: TWNBSL

[44] Соколов Ю.Н. Технологичность ― свойство уголовного судопроизводства // Научный ежегодник института философии и права уральского отделения Российской академии наук. 2015. Т. 15, № 1. С. 125-140. EDN: TWNBSL

[45] Sokolov YuN. Technological adaptability: Characteristic of criminal proceedings. Nauchnyi ezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava Ural'skogo otdeleniya Rossiiskoi akademii nauk. 2015;15(1):125-140. EDN: TWNBSL

[46] Galym FG. Organisation of production of investigative actions with participation of foreign citizens [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Beisenov Karaganda Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Karaganda; 2009. 30 р. (In Russ).

[47] Галым Ф.Г. Организация производства следственных действий с участием иностранных граждан: Автореф. дис. … канд. юр. наук: 12.00.09. Место защиты: Карагандинский юридический ин-т МВД РК им. Б. Бейсенова. Караганда, 2009. 30 c.

[48] Galym FG. Organisation of production of investigative actions with participation of foreign citizens [dissertation abstract]: 12.00.09. Place of defence: Beisenov Karaganda Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Karaganda; 2009. 30 р. (In Russ).

[49] Badanova AN. Prospects of remote investigative actions in law enforcement (based on the materials of the Republic of Kazakhstan). Crimitan investigation: problems and ways of their solution. 2022;(2):146-154. EDN: ARNNTI doi: 10.54217/2411-1627.2022.36.2.018

[50] Баданова А.Н. Перспективы дистанционных следственных действий в правоохранительной деятельности (по материалам Республики Казахстан) // Расследование преступлений: проблемы и пути их решения. 2022. № 2. С. 146-154. EDN: ARNNTI doi: 10.54217/2411-1627.2022.36.2.018

[51] Badanova AN. Prospects of remote investigative actions in law enforcement (based on the materials of the Republic of Kazakhstan). Crimitan investigation: problems and ways of their solution. 2022;(2):146-154. EDN: ARNNTI doi: 10.54217/2411-1627.2022.36.2.018

[52] Orakbayev AB, Kurmangali ZhK, Begaliyev YeN, et al. On the issue of using the results of a virtual autopsy in criminal investigation: A review. Russ J Forensic Med. 2023;9(2):183-192. EDN: OEERGD doi: 10.17816/fm774

[53] Оракбаев А.Б., Курмангали Ж.К., Бегалиев Е.Н., и др. К вопросу об использовании результатов виртуальной аутопсии (виртопсии) в ходе расследования преступлений: научный обзор // Судебная медицина. 2023. Т. 9, № 2. С. 183-192. EDN: OEERGD doi: 10.17816/fm774

[54] Orakbayev AB, Kurmangali ZhK, Begaliyev YeN, et al. On the issue of using the results of a virtual autopsy in criminal investigation: A review. Russ J Forensic Med. 2023;9(2):183-192. EDN: OEERGD doi: 10.17816/fm774

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Eco-Vector