A casuistic case of ignoring an expert opinion by the court conclusions about the absence of drug use disorder diagnosis

Abstract

The article cites the case of Dmitry A., who was detained by the police on the street on suspicion of using cannabinoids and sent for a medical examination for intoxication, which he refused. The judge found Dmitry guilty and ordered him to be examined at a drug treatment clinic. Based on the results of an inpatient examination, despite the absence of mental disorders, somatic consequences of episodic cannabinoid use and the absence of pathological changes according to laboratory tests, he was diagnosed with "harmful use of cannabinoids". Dmitry was placed under preventive observation. During the court-ordered forensic psychiatric examination at the Serbsky Center (Moscow), the drug diagnosis was not confirmed. However, the expert opinion was ignored at the court hearing. The author analyzes the frequency and validity of the diagnosis of "harmful use of psychoactive substances" and concludes that the case of Dmitry A. may become a precedent.

Keywords

diagnosis of drug (addiction) disorders / harmful use of psychoactive substances / forensic psychiatric examination

References

[1] Mendelevich VD. Giperdiagnostika shizofrenii kak kognitivnoe iskazhenie processa poznaniya klinicheskoj real'nosti. Nevrologicheskij vestnik. 2023;(1):5–14. doi: 10.17816/nb160308 (In Russ.)

[2] Менделевич В.Д. Гипердиагностика шизофрении как когнитивное искажение процесса познания клинической реальности // Неврологический вестник. 2023. №1. С. 5–14. doi: 10.17816/nb160308

[3] Mendelevich VD. Terminologicheskie osnovy fenomenologicheskoj diagnostiki v psihiatrii. M.: Gorodec; 2016. 128 p. (In Russ.)

[4] Менделевич В.Д. Терминологические основы феноменологической диагностики в психиатрии. М.: Городец; 2016. 128 с.

[5] Argunova YuN. Osparivanie psihiatricheskogo diagnoza v sudebnom poryadke. Nezavisimyj psihiatricheskij zhurnal. 2019;(3):51–59. (In Russ.)

[6] Аргунова Ю.Н. Оспаривание психиатрического диагноза в судебном порядке // Независимый психиатрический журнал. 2019. №3. С. 51–59.

[7] Klinicheskie rekomendacii. Psihicheskie i povedencheskie rasstrojstva, vyzvannye upotrebleniem psihoaktivnyh veshchestv. Pagubnoe (s vrednymi posledstviyami) upotreblenie. http://gbuzrkkrnd.ru/f/3_4.pdf (access date: 12.11.2023). (In Russ.)

[8] Клинические рекомендации. Психические и поведенческие расстройства, вызванные употреблением психоактивных веществ. Пагубное (с вредными последствиями) употребление. http://gbuzrkkrnd.ru/f/3_4.pdf (дата обращения: 12.11.2023).

[9] Zdravoohranenie v Rossii. 2021: Statisticheskij sbornik. Rosstat. M.; 2021. 171 р. (In Russ.)

[10] Здравоохранение в России. 2021: Статистический сборник. Росстат. М.; 2021. 171 с.

[11] Gahr M, Ziller J, Keller F et al. Incidence of inpatient cases with mental disorders due to use of cannabinoids in Germany: A nationwide evaluation. European Journal of Public Health. 2022;32(2):239–245.

[12] Gahr M., Ziller J., Keller F. et al. Incidence of inpatient cases with mental disorders due to use of cannabinoids in Germany: A nationwide evaluation // European Journal of Public Health. 2022. Vol. 32. N. 2. Р. 239–245.

[13] Kuznecov VV. Pagubnoe upotreblenie PAV s vrednymi posledstviyami — fejk-diagnoz. Nevrologicheskij vestnik. 2019;(1): 47–51. (In Russ.)

[14] Кузнецов В.В. Пагубное употребление ПАВ с вредными последствиями — фейк-диагноз // Неврологический вестник. 2019. №1. С. 47–51.

[15] Archie SR, Cucullo L. Harmful effects of smoking cannabis: A cerebrovascular and neurological perspective. Front Pharmacol. 2019;10:1481. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2019.01481

[16] Archie S.R., Cucullo L. Harmful effects of smoking cannabis: A cerebrovascular and neurological perspective // Front. Pharmacol. 2019. Vol. 10. Р. 1481. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2019.01481

[17] Solmi M, De Toffol M, Kim JY et al. Balancing risks and benefits of cannabis use: Umbrella review of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials and observational studies. BMJ. 2023;382:e072348. doi: 10.1136/bmj-2022-072348

[18] Solmi M., De Toffol M., Kim J.Y. et al. Balancing risks and benefits of cannabis use: Umbrella review of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials and observational studies // BMJ. 2023. Vol. 382. P. e072348. doi: 10.1136/bmj-2022-072348

[19] Klassifikaciya addikcij v MKB-10. Rossijskoe obshchestvo psihiatrov. https://psychiatr.ru/education/slide/238 (access date: 12.11.2023). (In Russ.)

[20] Классификация аддикций в МКБ-10. Российское общество психиатров. https://psychiatr.ru/education/slide/238 (дата обращения: 12.11.2023).

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Eco-Vector