Comparison between the efficacy plant and synthetic origin dental products in the treatment of chronic catarrhal gingivitis.

Abstract

Aim. Comparative clinical study of hygienic dental product of plant origin based α-mangostin [1,3,6-Trihydroxy-7-methoxy-2,8-bis(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-9H-xanthen-9-one], a xanthone from mangosteen fruit, having antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory activity in the treatment of chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis.

Methods. The study included 319 patients aged 22 to 45 years. All patients were divided into two groups: the control group — 20 people (males — 40%, females — 60%), average age 34.8±8.00 years; the comparison group — 20 people (males — 45%, females — 55%), average age 35.0±7.10 year; the main group — 20 people (males — 40%, females — 60%), average age 34.9±7.86 years. There were no statistically significant differences between all groups (p <0.05). The nosological form of the disease in the studied patients is chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis (K05.1). Treatment in all groups was carried out using the standard regimen of complex therapy of chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis. Therapy of the main group patients was supplemented by the use of the hygienic gel containing 1% α-mangostin [1,3,6-Trihydroxy-7-methoxy-2,8-bis(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-9H-xanthen-9-one], whereas treatment of the comparison group patients was supplemented by the complex preparation containing 1% metronidazole and 0.25% chlorhexidine digluconate. The dental examination included a questionnaire with the registration of subjective data (patient complaints) and objective data on the state of the tissues of the mouth (index score) before and after therapy, as well as the dynamics of the indicators fixing during the entire treatment.

Results. The performing a comparative study of the treatment effectiveness of chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis, using a dental hygienic gel containing 1% α-mangostin [1,3,6-Trihydroxy-7-methoxy-2,8-bis(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-9H-xanthen-9-one] as a part of complex therapy in comparison with the standard complex treatment regi­men supplemented by dental product containing 1% metronidazole and 0.25% chlorhexidine digluconate, showed a marked improvement in subjective quality of life of patients. Pain during individual oral hygiene and food intake (decrease to 0%, p1 <0.05, p2 <0.05), a feeling of “bursting” in the gum (decrease to 0%, p1 <0.05, p2 <0.05), bad breath (decrease to 0%, p1 <0.05, p2 <0.05) and bleeding gums (decrease to 0%, p1 <0.05, p2 <0.05) were completely eliminated. Compared to the control group, OHI-S index of the main group decreased by 79% (from 1.9 to 0.4, p1 <0.001, p2 <0.001), PI index decreased by 80.6% (from 3.1 to 0.6, p1 <0.001, p2 <0.001) and SBI index decreased by 100% (from 3 to 0, p1 <0.001, p2 <0.001). During the course of treatment of patients with chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis, a decrease in the average values of the PMA index was observed. In the group of patients using hygienic gel as a supplement to treatment, the decrease in this index was 85% (from 65±1.53 to 10±0.82%; p1 <0.001, p2 <0.05), and when using a complex drug containing 1% metronidazole and 0.25% chlorhexidine digluconate, the value of the PMA index decreased by 51% (from 61±1.17 to 30±1.4%; p1 <0.001), in the control group, the index value decreased by 28% (from 67±1.67 to 48±1.26%; p1 <0.001).

Conclusion. In assessing of the subjective quality of life and index indicators of the periodontal status in the treatment of chronic generalized catarrhal gingivitis, the best results were observed in the group using a dental hygiene gel based on α-mangostin [1,3,6-Trihydroxy-7-methoxy-2,8-bis(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-9H-xanthen-9-one], a xanthone from mangosteen fruit, compared with the control group and the group using a complex drug (1% metronidazole and 0.25% chlorhexidine digluconate).

Keywords

generalized catarrhal gingivitis / 1% α-mangostin [1,3,6-Trihydroxy-7-methoxy-2,8-bis(3-methyl-2-butenyl)-9H-xanthen-9-one] / index estimation

References

[1] Bondarenko O.S., Risovannaya O.N., Bondarenko A.N. Efficiency estimation of chro­nic catarrhal gingivitis cases therapy by an index estimation of results of various treatment methods. Kubanskiy nauchnyy meditsinskiy vestnik. 2010; (7): 27–29. (In Russ.)

[2] Бондаренко О.С., Рисованная О.Н., Бондаренко А.Н. Оценка эффективности терапии хронического катарального гингивита по индексной оценке результатов различных методов лечения. Кубанский науч. мед. вестн. 2010; (7): 27–29.

[3] Sukhorukova M.V., Edelstein M.V., Skleenova E.Yu. et al. Antimicrobial resistance of nosocomial Acinetobacter spp. isolates in Russia: results of multicenter epidemiological study “­MARATHON” 2013–2014. Klinicheskaya mikrobiologiya i antimikrobnaya khimioterapiya. 2017; 19 (1): 42–48. (In Russ.)

[4] Сухорукова М.В., Эйдельштейн М.В., Склеенова Е.Ю. и др. Антибиотикорезистентность нозокомиальных штаммов Acinetobacter spp. в стационарах России: результаты многоцентрового эпидемиологического исследования «МАРАФОН» 2013–2014. Клин. микробиол. и антимикробная химиотерап. 2017; 19 (1): 42–48.

[5] Tapalsky D.V., Tapalsky F.D. Antibacterial effects of her­bal extracts and their combinations with antibiotics in relation to extensively antibiotic-resistant microorganisms. Kurskiy nauchno-prakticheskiy vestnik “Chelovek i ego zdorov'e”. 2018; (1): 78–83. (In Russ.)

[6] Тапальский Д.В., Тапальский Ф.Д. Антибактериальные свойства растительных экстрактов и их комбинаций с антибиотиками в отношении экстремально-антибиотикорезистентных микроорганизмов. Курский науч.-практич. вестн. «Человек и его здоровье». 2018; (1): 78–83. DOI: 10.21626/vestnik/2018-1/12.

[7] Fedorova Yu.S., Sukhih A.S., Kuznecov P.V. Key biologically active substances of phytopreparations on the basis of plants of a sort of Kopeechnik. Sorbcionnye i hromatograficheskie processy. 2011; 11 (5): 708–713. (In Russ.)

[8] Фёдорова Ю.С., Сухих А.С., Кузнецов П.В. Ключевые биологически активные вещества фитопрепаратов на основе растений рода Копеечник. Краткие сообщения. Сорбционные и хроматографические процессы. 2011; 11 (5): 708–713.

[9] Fedorova Yu.S., Kuznetsov P.V., Gerasimova R.N. On the comparative assessment of the microbiological acti­vity of phytopreparations from some species of plants of the genus Hedysarum (this. Fabaceae). Vestnik RAEN (ZSO). 2009; 57–60. (In Russ.)

[10] Фёдорова Ю.С., Кузнецов П.В., Герасимова Р.Н. О сравнительной оценке микробиологической активности фитопрепаратов из некоторых видов растений рода Hedysarum (сем. Fabaceae). Вестн. РАЕН (ЗСО). 2009; 57–60.

[11] Fedorova Yu.S., Kuznetsov P.V., Sukhih A.S. Comparative analysis by gas-liquid mass spectrometry of volatile components of phytopreparations from three types of hedysarum (H. neglectum, H. theinum, H. alpinum). Polzunovskij vestnik. 2010; (3): 213. (In Russ.)

[12] Фёдорова Ю.С., Кузнецов П.В., Сухих А.С. Сравнительный анализ методом газожидкостной масс-спектрометрии летучих компонентов фитопрепаратов из трёх видов копеечника (H. neglectum, H. theinum, H. alpinum). Ползуновский вестн. 2010; (3): 213.

[13] Fedo­rova Yu.S., Kuznetsov P.V., Sukhih A.S., Minaev K.M. To the phenomenon of comparative study by the HPLC method of some types of biologically active substances in herbal medicines of H. neglectum, H. theinum, H. аlpinum herbal preparations. Polzunovskiy vestnik. 2010; (3): 215–217. (In Russ.)

[14] Фёдорова Ю.С., Кузнецов П.В., Сухих А.С., Минаев К.М. К феномену сравнительного изучения методом ВЭЖХ некоторых типов биологически активных веществ в фитопрепаратах копеечников H. neglectum, H. theinum, H. аlpinum. Ползуновский вестн. 2010; (3): 215–217.

[15] Guclu E., Genc H., Zengin M., Karabay O. Antibacterial activity of Lythrum salicaria against multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Ann. Res. Rev. Biol. 2014; 4 (7): 1099–1105. DOI: 10.9734/ARRB/2014/7357.

[16] Fedorova Yu.S., Kuznetsov P.V., Su­khih A.S. et al. comparative estimation of antibacterial activity fitopreparat from some kinds of plants sort Hedysarum (fam. Fabaceae). Fundamentalʹnye issledovaniâ. 2011; (3): 210–214. (In Russ.)

[17] Фёдорова Ю.С., Кузнецов П.В., Сухих А.С. и др. Сравнительная оценка антибактериальной активности фитопрепаратов из некоторых видов растений рода Hedysarum (сем. Fabaceae). Фундаментал. исслед. 2011; (3): 210–214.

[18] Kulʹpin P.V., Fedorova Yu.S. Current perspectives in the chemical-pharmaceutical research of biologically active substances plant Garcinia mangostana L. Fundamentalʹnaya i klinicheskaya meditsina. 2016; 1 (1): 85–92. (In Russ.)

[19] Кульпин П.В., Фёдорова Ю.С. Современные перспективы в химико-фармацевтическом исследовании биологически активных веществ растения Garcinia mangostana L. Фундаментал. и клин. мед. 2016; 1 (1): 85–92.

[20] Lya­min E.S., Fedorova Yu.S., Kulpin P.V. Comparative study of the activity of antibacterial means used in dental practice. Vestnik nauki i obrazovaniya. 2018; 1 (7): 97–100. (In Russ.)

[21] Лямин Е.С., Фёдорова Ю.С., Кульпин П.В. Сравнительное исследование активности антибактериальных средств, используемых в стоматологической практике. Вестн. науки и образования. 2018; 1 (7): 97–100.

[22] Miladiyah I., Rachmawaty F.J. Potency of Xanthone Derivatives as antibacterial agent against Methicillin-­Resistant Staphylococcus Aureus (MRSA). Indonesian JKKI. 2017; 8 (2): 124–135. DOI: 10.20885/JKKI.Vol8.Iss2.art8.

[23] Fisyunov A.D., Chkrnyavsky Yu.P. The results of the use of the drug “Holisal” in outpatient dental practice. Bulletin of VSMU. 2012; 11 (2): 165–170.

[24] Фисюнов А.Д., Чeрнявский Ю.П. Результаты применения препарата «Холисал» в амбулаторной стоматологической практике. Вестн. ВГМУ. 2012; 11 (2): 165–170.

[25] Borovskiy E.V. Terapevticheskaya stomatolo­giya. Uchebnik dlya studentov meditsinskikh vuzov. (Therapeutic dentistry. A textbook for medical students). M.: MIA. 2007; 840 р. (In Russ.)

[26] Боровский Е.В. Терапевтическая стоматология. Учебник для студентов медицинских вузов. М.: МИА. 2007; 840 с.

[27] Trezubov V.N., Arutyunov S.D., Mishnev L.M. Klinicheskaya stomatologiya. Uchebnik. (Clinical Dentistry. A textbook.) M.: Prakticheskaya meditsina. 2015; 788 р. (In Russ.)

[28] Трезубов В.Н., Арутюнов С.Д., Мишнев Л.М. Клиническая стоматология. Учебник. М.: Практическая медицина. 2015; 788 с.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Lyamin Y.S., Fedorova Y.S., Kulpin P.V., Suslov N.I., Kucheryavyi D.V.