Changes in organic mental disorders features in persons who have repeatedly committed socially dangerous acts

Abstract

Aim. Comparative analysis of the changes in clinical manifestations of organic mental disorders in persons who have repeatedly committed socially dangerous acts, and in patients without recurrence of misconduct.

Methods. 93 patients with organic mental disorders who have committed socially dangerous acts and were declared as mentally insane and in whom compulsory medical measures assigned to them by the court were used were examined. Patients who have committed repeated socially dangerous acts after treatment were included in the main group (30 persons), patients who does not commit repeated socially dangerous acts were allocated to the comparison group (63 persons).

Results. In the main group, patients with organic delusional disorder (F06.2, 20% vs 11.1%) dominated. In the control group, the share of patients with dementia of mixed origin (F02) was 22.2%, and in the main group - only 3.3%. In the main group, the prevalence of patients with psychotic conditions within the organic mental disorder was 43.3% versus 30.2% in the comparison group. At that, the rate of progression varied only slightly. The proportion of patients with no previously recorded episodes of decompensation was higher in the control group - 46.0% versus 13.3% in the study group. A few patients in both groups (10%) were supervised and regularly visited a psychiatrist. The number of patients who were not supervised or who attended psychiatrist rare was almost the same (46.7 and 47.6% in the study group and control group, respectively). At that, in the control group 12.7% of patients were not supervised due to the short disease duration (patients with dementia). There were a few more patients with a disease duration of more than 10 years in the comparison group - 54.0%, whereas in the study group - 43.3%.

Conclusion. There is a number of differences in clinical manifestations of organic mental disorder and their changes over time, affecting the criminogenic risk of this population; an integrated approach to disease prevention, which can lead to an improvement in the criminal forecast, is needed.

Keywords

psychiatry / organic mental disorders / socially dangerous acts

References

[1] Вандыш В.В. Органическое психическое расстройство: функциональный диагноз // Судеб. психиатр. Актуал. пробл. - 2012. - №9. - С. 29-41.

[2] Гиленко М.В. Судебно-психиатрические аспекты коморбидности органических психических расстройств и зависимости от ПАВ // Судеб. психиатр. Актуал. пробл. - 2012. - №9. - С. 42-51.

[3] Мальцева М.М., Котов В.П. Опасные действия психически больных (психопатологические механизмы и профилактика). - М.: Медицина, 1995. - 256 с.

[4] Попов С.Н., Винникова И.Н. Клинико-криминологическая характеристика лиц с органическими психическими расстройствами, совершивших общественно опасные деяния // Казанский мед. ж. - 2014. - Т. 95. №1. - С. 49-54.

[5] Ткаченко А.А. Руководство по судебной психиатрии. - М: Юрайт, 2012. - 960 с.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Popov S.N., Vinnikova I.N.