Phalloplasty: understanding the chaos

Abstract

Wide variation in overall strategies and surgical specifics for masculinizing genital surgery has created a “phalloplasty chaos” that is confusing to both surgeons and patients seeking gender confirming surgery. The purpose of this article is to review masculinizing genital confirming surgery, or “phalloplasty”, focusing on specific goals and categorizing each component of the surgical process. Experienced surgeons from several high-volume centers review and categorize the commonly employed strategies and techniques for gender confirming phalloplasty, including the permutations of approaches to cutaneous flap for phallic construction, the sequence and staging of procedures, and strategies for urethral construction. There is no clear advantage or reduction in complications associated with particular sequences of urethral and phallic reconstruction. Because no single technique or staging strategy has proven superior for gender confirming genital surgery, it is paramount that surgeons are knowledgeable of all available options and the associated advantages, disadvantages, and risks.

Keywords

Transgender / phalloplasty / FtM / gender dysphoria / gender reassignment / transmasculine / gender confirmation surgery / gender confirming surgery / gender affirming surgery / transgender genital surgery

References

[1] van de Grift TC,Cerwenka SC,De Cuypere G.Effects of medical interventions on gender dysphoria and body image: a follow-up study..Psychosom Med2017;79:815-23 PMCID:PMC5580378

[2] Wernick JA,Matouk K,Janssen A.A systematic review of the psychological benefits of gender-affirming surgery..Urol Clin North Am2019;46:475-86

[3] Manieri C,Crespi C,Dell’aquila C.Medical treatment of subjects with gender identity disorder: the experience in an italian public health center..Int J Transgend2014;15:53-65

[4] Byne W,Coleman E,Green R.Report of the American psychiatric association task force on treatment of gender identity disorder..Arch Sex Behav2012;41:759-96

[5] Davy Z.The DSM-5 and the politics of diagnosing transpeople..Arch Sex Behav2015;44:1165-76

[6] Weissler JM,Carney MJ,Messa CA4th.Gender-affirming surgery in persons with gender dysphoria..Plast Reconstr Surg2018;141:388-96e

[7] World Professional Association for Transgender HealthStandards of care for transsexual, transgender, and gender nonconforming people..Int J Transgend2012;13:165-232

[8] Riggs DW,Pfeffer CA,White F.Transnormativity in the psy disciplines: constructing pathology in the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders and standards of care..Am Psychol2019;74:912-24

[9] Budge SL.Psychotherapists as gatekeepers: an evidence-based case study highlighting the role and process of letter writing for transgender clients..Psychotherapy (Chic)2015;52:287-97

[10] Puckett JA,Rossman K,Mustanski B.Barriers to gender-affirming care for transgender and gender nonconforming individuals..Sex Res Social Policy2018;15:48-59 PMCID:PMC5842950

[11] Selvaggi G,Ceulemans P,De Cuypere G.Genital sensitivity after sex reassignment surgery in transsexual patients..Ann Plast Surg2007;58:427-33

[12] Abern L.Fertility preservation among transgender individuals..Fertil Steril2018;110:e281

[13] Jeftovic M,Bizic M,Kisic J.Hysterectomy with bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy in female-to-male gender affirmation surgery: comparison of two methods..Biomed Res Int2018;2018:3472471 PMCID:PMC5964534

[14] Hougen HY,Berli JU.Outcomes of transperineal gender-affirming vaginectomy and colpocleisis..Female Pelvic Med Reconstr Surg2020;

[15] Massie JP,Wilson SC,Chen ML.Phalloplasty with urethral lengthening: addition of a vascularized bulbospongiosus flap from vaginectomy reduces postoperative urethral complications..Plast Reconstr Surg2017;140:551-8e

[16] Nikkels C,Huirne J,de Leeuw R.Vaginal colpectomy in transgender men: a retrospective cohort study on surgical procedure and outcomes..J Sex Med2019;16:924-33

[17] Groenman F,Huirne J,Trum H.Robot-assisted laparoscopic colpectomy in female-to-male transgender patients; technique and outcomes of a prospective cohort study..Surg Endosc2017;31:3363-9 PMCID:PMC5501901

[18] Dy GW,Granieri MA.Reconstructive management pearls for the transgender patient..Curr Urol Rep2018;19:36

[19] Chen ML.Single-stage phalloplasty..Urol Clin North Am2019;46:567-80

[20] Zhang YF,Qu CY,Liu AT.Is vaginal mucosal graft the excellent substitute material for urethral reconstruction in female-to-male transsexuals?.World J Urol2015;33:2115-23

[21] Medina CA,Salgado CJ.Total vaginectomy and urethral lengthening at time of neourethral prelamination in transgender men..Int Urogynecol J2018;29:1463-8

[22] Morrison SD,Dellon AL.Genital sensibility in the neophallus: getting a sense of the current literature and techniques..J Reconstr Microsurg2019;35:129-37

[23] Safa B,Salim AM,Poh MM.Current concepts in masculinizing gender surgery..Plast Reconstr Surg2019;143:857-71e

[24] Hadj-Moussa M,Ohl DA.Masculinizing genital gender confirmation surgery..Sex Med Rev2019;7:141-55

[25] Vukadinovic V,Majstorovic M.The role of clitoral anatomy in female to male sex reassignment surgery..ScientificWorldJournal2014;2014:437378 PMCID:PMC4005052

[26] Morrison SD,Vyas KS,Crane CN.Phalloplasty: a review of techniques and outcomes..Plast Reconstr Surg2016;138:594-615

[27] Monstrey S,Selvaggi G,Van Landuyt K.Penile reconstruction: is the radial forearm flap really the standard technique?.Plast Reconstr Surg2009;124:510-8

[28] Chang TS.Forearm flap in one-stage reconstruction of the penis..Plast Reconstr Surg1984;74:251-8

[29] Garcia MM,De Luca F,Ralph DJ.Overall satisfaction, sexual function, and the durability of neophallus dimensions following staged female to male genital gender confirming surgery: the Institute of Urology, London U.K. experience..Transl Androl Urol2014;3:156-62 PMCID:PMC4708164

[30] Frey JD,Chiodo MV.A systematic review of metoidioplasty and radial forearm flap phalloplasty in female-to-male transgender genital reconstruction: is the “ideal” neophallus an achievable goal?.Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2016;4:e1131 PMCID:PMC5222645

[31] Heston AL,Dugi DD3rd.Phalloplasty: techniques and outcomes..Transl Androl Urol2019;8:254-65 PMCID:PMC6626313

[32] Djordjevic ML,Kojovic V,Bizic M.Musculocutaneous latissimus dorsi flap for phalloplasty in female to male gender affirmation surgery..World J Urol2019;37:631-7

[33] Vesely J,Ranno R,Monni N.New technique of total phalloplasty with reinnervated latissimus dorsi myocutaneous free flap in female-to-male transsexuals..Ann Plast Surg2007;58:544-50

[34] Veerman H,Al-Tamimi M,Mullender MG.Functional outcomes and urological complications after genital gender affirming surgery with urethral lengthening in transgender men..J Urol2020;204:104-9

[35] Koshima I,Nagai A,Sato T.Penile reconstruction with bilateral superficial circumflex iliac artery perforator (SCIP) flaps..J Reconstr Microsurg2006;22:137-42

[36] Sengezer M,Deveci M.Long-term follow-up of total penile reconstruction with sensate osteocutaneous free fibula flap in 18 biological male patients..Plast Reconstr Surg2004;114:439-50discussion 451-2

[37] Mcroberts JW.Zderic SA,Carr MC.Penile reconstruction with a free sensate osteocutaneous fibula flap in the surgical management of the intersex patient..Pediatric gender assignment.2002;BostonSpringer US283-8

[38] Dabernig J.Pedicled pubic phalloplasty in females with gender dysphoria..BJU Int2005;96:1422-3

[39] Djordjevic ML.Novel surgical techniques in female to male gender confirming surgery..Transl Androl Urol2018;7:628-38 PMCID:PMC6127556

[40] Colebunders B,D’Arpa S,Monstrey S.An update on the surgical treatment for transgender patients..Sex Med Rev2017;5:103-9

[41] Selvaggi G,Hoebeke P,Van Landuyt K.Donor-site morbidity of the radial forearm free flap after 125 phalloplasties in gender identity disorder..Plast Reconstr Surg2006;118:1171-7

[42] Kovar A,Iorio ML.Donor site morbidity in phalloplasty reconstructions: outcomes of the radial forearm free flap..Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2019;7:e2442 PMCID:PMC6908408

[43] Garaffa G,Ralph DJ.Total phallic reconstruction in female-to-male transsexuals..Eur Urol2010;57:715-22

[44] Tran BNN,Singhal D,Tobias AM.Gender affirmation surgery: a synopsis using American College of Surgeons National Surgery Quality Improvement Program and National Inpatient Sample databases..Ann Plast Surg2018;80:S229-35

[45] Felici N.A new phalloplasty technique: the free anterolateral thigh flap phalloplasty..J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg2006;59:153-7

[46] Xu KY.The pedicled anterolateral thigh phalloplasty..Clin Plast Surg2018;45:399-406

[47] Mardini S,Wei FC.Wei FC.Anterolateral and anteromedial thigh flaps..Flaps and reconstructive surgery.2016;2nd edElsevier700-16.e5

[48] D’Arpa S,Stillaert F.Pre-expanded anterolateral thigh perforator flap for phalloplasty..Clin Plast Surg2017;44:129-41

[49] Esmonde N,Berli JU.Phalloplasty flap-related complication..Clin Plast Surg2018;45:415-24

[50] Bajpai M.“Bird-Wing” abdominal phalloplasty: a novel surgical technique for penile reconstruction..J Indian Assoc Pediatr Surg2013;18:49-52 PMCID:PMC3687145

[51] Hage J,de Graaf F.Construction of the neophallus in female-to-male transsexuals: the Amsterdam experience..J Urol1993;149:1463-8

[52] Hage JJ,Bloem JJ.Phalloplasty in female-to-male transsexuals: what do our patients ask for?.Ann Plast Surg1993;30:323-6

[53] Ma S,Liu Y.A new surgical procedure for penile reconstruction by combined free radial forearm flap and dorsalis pedis flap..Urology2016;97:232-7

[54] Moon DG,Cho HY,Park HS.Augmentation of glans penis using injectable hyaluronic acid gel..Int J Impot Res2003;15:456-60

[55] Sommeling CE,Salim A,Opsomer D.A new technique for coronaplasty in penile reconstruction..J Sex Med2018;15:920-3

[56] Besteiro J,Ishida L.Microsurgical phalloplasty..J Reconstr Microsurg2006;22:

[57] Dubin BJ,Laub DR.Results of phalloplasty..Plast Reconstr Surg1979;64:163-70

[58] Al-Tamimi M,van der Sluis WB,Mullender MG.Colpectomy significantly reduces the risk of urethral fistula formation after urethral lengthening in transgender men undergoing genital gender affirming surgery..J Urol2018;200:1315-22

[59] Selvaggi G.Gender reassignment surgery: an overview..Nat Rev Urol2011;8:274-82

[60] Djordjevic ML,Stanojevic D,Kojovic V.Urethral lengthening in metoidioplasty (female-to-male sex reassignment surgery) by combined buccal mucosa graft and labia minora flap..Urology2009;74:349-53

[61] Djordjevic ML.Comparison of two different methods for urethral lengthening in female to male (metoidioplasty) surgery..J Sex Med2013;10:1431-8

[62] Chen ML,Poh MM.Overview of surgical techniques in gender-affirming genital surgery..Transl Androl Urol2019;8:191-208 PMCID:PMC6626317

[63] Wilson SC,Khurana K,Levine JP.Fasciocutaneous flap reinforcement of ventral onlay buccal mucosa grafts enables neophallus revision urethroplasty..Ther Adv Urol2016;8:331-7 PMCID:PMC5117170

[64] Chauhan A,Chee J.Microsurgical urethroplasty for complex bulbar urethral strictures using the radial forearm free flap prelaminated with buccal mucosa..J Reconstr Microsurg2016;32:378-85

[65] Hage JJ.Metaidoioplasty: an alternative phalloplasty technique in transsexuals..Plast Reconstr Surg1996;97:161-7

[66] Kim SK,Heo J,Lee KC.A new method of urethroplasty for prevention of fistula in female-to-male gender reassignment surgery..Ann Plast Surg2010;64:759-64

[67] Cohen O,Zhao L,Bluebond-Langner R.Use of a split pedicled gracilis muscle flap in robotically assisted vaginectomy and urethral lengthening for phalloplasty: a novel technique for female-to-male genital reconstruction..Plast Reconstr Surg2020;145:1512-5

[68] Safa B. “Phalloplasty.” Presented for American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Virtual Grand Rounds. April 2020. Available from: https://ednet.plasticsurgery.org/diweb/catalog/item/id/5085154/pid/5037869. [Last accessed on 17 Sep 2020]

[69] Morrison SD,Song J,Kirby J.Modification of the tube-in-tube pedicled anterolateral thigh flap for total phalloplasty: the mushroom flap..Ann Plast Surg.2014;72 Suppl 1:S22-6

[70] Al-Tamimi M,Ronkes B,van de Grift TC.The first experience of using the pedicled labia minora flap for urethral lengthening in transgender men undergoing anterolateral thigh and superficial circumflex iliac artery perforator flap phalloplasty: a multicenter study on clinical outcomes..Urology2020;138:179-87

[71] van der Sluis WB,Pigot GLS,Winters HAH.Double flap phalloplasty in transgender men: surgical technique and outcome of pedicled anterolateral thigh flap phalloplasty combined with radial forearm free flap urethral reconstruction..Microsurgery2017;37:917-23 PMCID:PMC5697604

[72] D’Arpa S,Lumen N,Hoebeke P.Urethral reconstruction in anterolateral thigh flap phalloplasty: a 93-case experience..Plast Reconstr Surg2019;143:382-92e

[73] Liu CY,Jiang H,Zhang YF.Preconstruction of the pars pendulans urethrae for phalloplasty with digestive mucosa using a prefabricated anterolateral thigh flap in a one-arm patient..Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2013;1:e53 PMCID:PMC4174055

[74] Salgado CJ,Chim J,Demaso S.Prelamination of neourethra with uterine mucosa in radial forearm osteocutaneous free flap phalloplasty in the female-to-male transgender patient..Case Rep Urol2016;2016:8742531 PMCID:PMC4812281

[75] Danker S,Berli JU.“Staging” in Phalloplasty..Urol Clin North Am2019;46:581-90

[76] Kang A,Cohen AJ,Pariser JJ.Techniques and considerations of prosthetic surgery after phalloplasty in the transgender male..Transl Androl Urol2019;8:273-82 PMCID:PMC6626310

[77] Kocjancic E.Penile prostheses..Clin Plast Surg2018;45:407-14

[78] Lane M,Sluiter EC,Yao TH.Trends in gender-affirming surgery in insured patients in the United States..Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open2018;6:e1738 PMCID:PMC5977951