First recognition of the extinct eudicot genus Palibinia in North America: Leaves and fruits of Palibinia comptonifolia (R.W.Br.) comb. nov. from the Eocene of Utah and Colorado, USA

Abstract

Newly investigated leafy twigs bearing axillary fruits from the Eocene Parachute Creek Member of the Green River Formation in eastern Utah, USA, have provided more information on the species previously attributed to the Proteaceae as Banksia comptonifolia R.W.Br. The leaves are simple, estipulate with short petioles, and elongate laminae with prominent angular nonglandular teeth. The laminae have a thick midvein and pinnate craspedodromous secondaries, and are distinctive in the presence of a thick, often coalified, marginal rim. Vegetative and reproductive buds occur in the axils of the leaves. These features indicate that the species belongs to Palibinia Korovin—an extinct Eudicot genus previously known only from the Paleogene of Asia and Europe. Small pedicellate ovoid fruits 1.5–2.2 mm wide are borne in fascicles of three and are seen to be capsules with four apical valves. Despite the specific epithet referring to similarity of the foliage to that of Comptonia (Myricaceae), the fasciculate inflorescence organization with axillary flowers is quite distinct from the catkins characteristic of that family. Assignment to Banksia or other Proteaceae with complex inflorescences and follicular fruits is also problematic. Additionally, MacGinitie′s transfer of the species to Vauquelinia of the Rosaceae is contradicted by the lack of stipule scars on the twig and by differences in leaf venation and floral morphology. We transfer the species to Palibinia comptonifolia (R.W.Br.) comb. nov., but its familial affinity within the Pentapetalae remains uncertain. This new occurrence augments records from the Paleogene of Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan, China, England, and Germany.

Keywords

Bonanza / Utah / extinct angiosperm / fossil fruits / fossil leaves / Parachute Creek Member

References

1	MA Akhmetiev. 2010. Paleocene and Eocene floristic and climatic change in Russia and northern Kazakhstan. Bulletin of Geosciences 85(1): 77–94.
2	MA Akhmetiev, NI Zaporozhets. 2014. Paleogene events in Central Eurasia: their role in the flora and vegetation cover evolution, migration of phytochore boundaries, and climate changes. Stratigraphy and Geological Correlation 22: 312–335.
3	SE Allen. 2015. Fossil palm flowers from the Eocene of the Rocky Mountain Region with affinities of Phoenix L. (Arecaceae: Coryphoideae). International Journal of Plant Sciences 176(6): 586–596.
4	EW Berry. 1906. Living and fossil species of Comptonia. American Naturalist 40(475): 485–524.
5	RW Brown. 1934. The recognizable species of the Green River flora. US Geological Survey Professional Paper 185-C: 44–77.
6	LD Boucher, SR Manchester, WS Judd. 2003. An extinct genus of Salicaceae based on twigs with attached flowers, fruits, and foliage from the Eocene Green River Formation of Utah and Colorado, USA. American Journal of Botany 90(9): 1389–1399.
7	LY Budantsev. 1963. Genus Palibinia E. Korovin, 1932. In: Takhtajan AL ed. The basis of Paleontology. Moscow: State Scientific and Technical Publishing House. 15: 639. (in Russian)
8	VB Call, DL Dilcher. 1994. Parvileguminophyllum coloradensis, a new combination for Mimosites coloradensis Knowlton, Green River Formation of Utah and Colorado. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 80(3–4): 305–310.
9	VB Call, DL Dilcher. 1997. The fossil record of Eucommia (Eucommiaceae) in North America. American Journal of Botany 84(6): 798–814.
10	I Chen, SR Manchester. 2007. Seed morphology of modern and fossil Ampelocissus (Vitaceae) and implications for phytogeography. American Journal of Botany 94(9): 1534–1553.
11	M-H Chen, Z-C Kong, Ye Chen. 1983. On the discovery of Palaeogene flora from the western Sichuan Plateau and its significance in phytogeography. Acta Botanica Sinica 25(5): 482–491.
12	TD Cockerell. 1925. Plant and insect fossils from the Green River Eocene of Colorado. Proceedings of the US National Museum 66(19): 1–13.
13	SL Corbett, SR Manchester. 2004. Phytogeography and fossil history of Ailanthus (Simaroubaceae). International Journal of Plant Sciences 165(4): 671–690.
14	JE Correa-Narvaez, SE Allen, IB Huegele, SR Manchester. 2023. Fossil leaves and fruits of Tetramelaceae (Curcurbitales) from the Eocene of the Rocky Mountain region, USA, and their biogeographic significance. International Journal of Plant Sciences 184(3): 177–200.
15	T Denk, JM Bouchal, HT Güner, M Coiro, R Butzmann, KB Pigg, BH Tiffney. 2023. Cenozoic migration of a desert plant lineage across the North Atlantic. New Phytologist 238(6): 2668–2684.
16	AB Doweld. 2017. On the nomenclature of fossil Aspleniopteris, Carpinicarpus, Comptonia, Comptoniphyllum and Dryandrophyllum (Myricaceae). Acta Palaeobotanica 57(2): 223–232.
17	S-X Guo. 1979. Late Cretaceous and Early Tertiary floras from the southern Guangdong and Guangxi with their stratigraphic significance. In: Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology and Nanjing Institute of Geology and Paleontology, Academia Sinica ed. Mesozoic and Cenozoic red beds of South China. Beijing: Science Press. 223–231. (in Chinese)
18	S-X Guo. 1986. Floral character of Eocene Relu Formation and history of Eucalyptus from Litang of Sichuan. In: Team of Comprehensive Scientific Expedition to the Qinghai–Xizang Plateau, Chinese Academy of Sciences eds. Exploration of Hengduan Mountain area (II). Beijing: Beijing Publishing House of Sciences and Technology. 69–73.
19	M Han, SR Manchester, Q-Y Fu, J-H Jin, C Quan. 2018. Paleogene fossil fruits of Stephania (Menispermaceae) from North America and East Asia. Journal of Systematics and Evolution 56: 81–91.
20	M Han, XK Wu, M Tu, TM Kodrul, JH Jin. 2020. Diversity of Menispermaceae from the Paleocene and Eocene of South China. Journal of Systematics and Evolution 58: 354–366.
21	O Heer. 1853. Übersicht der Tertiär-Flora der Schweiz. Mittheilungen der Naturforschenden Gesellschaft in Zürich 3: 131–146.
22	LJ Hickey, JA Wolfe. 1975. The bases of angiosperm phylogeny: Vegetative morphology. Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 62(3): 538–589.
23	FH Knowlton. 1923. Revision of the flora of the Green River Formation: With descriptions of new species. US Geological Survey Professional Paper 131F: 133–182.
24	EP Korovin. 1932. A new Tertiary type of the Proteaceae family from Middle Asia. Botanicheskii Zhurnal 7: 506–522.
25	Z Kvaček. 1995. Limnobiophyllum Krassilov—A fossil link between the Araceae and the Lemnaceae. Aquatic Botany 50: 49–61.
26	CK Li, SY Ting. 1983. The Paleogene mammals of China. Bulletin of Carnegie Museum of Natural History 21: 1–98.
27	HM Li. 1965. Palaeogene plant remains from Chashanao of Hengyang basin in Hunan. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 13(3): 540–547.
28	HM Li. 1979. Some fossil plants of Myricaceae from China and its stratigraphic significance. In: Institute of Vertebrate Palaeontology and Palaeoanthropology and Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Academia Sinica eds. Mesozoic and Cenozoic red beds of South China. Beijing: Science Press. 232–239.
29	HM Li, Q-S Chen. 2002. Palibinia from the Eocene of Jiangxi, China—With remarks on the dry climate mechanism of northern hemisphere in Paleogene. Acta Palaeontogica Sinica 41(1): 119–129.
30	WT Li, GW Liu, DR Braman, YB Li, WS Cao, D Brinkman, J Shen, QB Chen. 2014. A potential stratotype for the regional lowermost stage of the continental Paleocene in China. Science China: Earth Sciences 57: 1109–1116.
31	Y-A Liu, Z-C Kong. 1978. Plant fossils of late Eocene from Wucheng, Henan and their significance in botany and paleoclimatology. Journal of Integrative Plant Biology 20(1): 59–64.
32	TA Lott, SR Manchester, DL Dilcher. 1998. A unique and complete polemoniaceous plant from the middle Eocene of Utah, USA. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 104: 39–49.
33	HD MacGinitie. 1969. The Eocene Green River flora of northwestern Colorado and northeastern Utah. University of California Publications in Geological Science 83: 1–140.
34	DH Mai. 1995. Tertiäre Vegetationsgeschichte Europas. Methoden und Ergebnisse. Stuttgart: Gustav Fischer. 691.
35	SR Manchester. 1986. Vegetative and reproductive morphology of an extinct plane tree (Platanaceae) from the Eocene of western North America. Botanical Gazette 147(2): 200–226.
36	SR Manchester. 1987a. The fossil history of Juglandaceae. Missouri Botanical Garden Monographs 21: 1–137.
37	SR Manchester. 1987b. Extinct ulmaceous fruits from the Tertiary of Europe and western North America. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 52: 119–129.
38	SR Manchester, WS Judd. 2022. Loxopteroides weeksae gen. et sp. nov. (Anacardiaceae) samaras and associated foliage from the Eocene of western North America. Acta Palaeobotanica 62(1): 1–10.
39	SR Manchester, TA Lott. 2019. Bonanzacarpum sprungerorum sp. nov.—A bizarre fruit from the Eocene Green River Formation in Utah, USA. Fossil Imprint 75(1): 281–288.
40	SR Manchester, EL O'Leary. 2010. Phylogenetic distribution and identification of fin-winged fruits. Botanical Review 76: 1–82.
41	SR Manchester, DL Dilcher, SL Wing. 1998. Attached leaves and fruits of myrtaceous affinity from the Middle Eocene of Colorado. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 102: 153–163.
42	SR Manchester, WS Judd, B Handley. 2006. Foliage and fruits of early poplars (Salicaceae: Populus) from the Eocene of Utah, Colorado, and Wyoming. International Journal of Plant Sciences 167(4): 897–908.
43	C Quan, ZH Liu, T Utescher, JH Jin, JW Shu, YX Li, YS Liu. 2014. Revisiting the Paleogene climate pattern of East Asia: A synthetic review. Earth-Science Reviews 139: 213–230.
44	EM Reid, MEJ Chandler. 1926. The Bembridge flora. Catalogue of Cainozoic plants in the development of geology. Vol. 1. British Museum (Natural History). London: Oxford University Press.
45	ME Smith, AR Carroll, BS Singer. 2008. Synoptic reconstruction of a major ancient lake system: Eocene Green River Formation, western United States. Geological Society of America Bulletin 120(1–2): 54–84.
46	D Soltis, P Soltis, P Endress, M Chase, SR Manchester, W Judd, L Majure, E Mavrodiev. 2018. Phylogeny and evolution of the angiosperms. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 580.
47	Sternberg Kvon. 1820–1838. Versuch einer Geognostisch-Botanischen Darstellung der Flora der Vorwelt: Kommission im Deutschen Museum. Prague: Fleischer in Leipzig.
48	JR Tao. 1965. A late Eocene florula from the district Weinan of Central Shensi. Acta Botanica Sinica 13(3): 272–282. (in Chinese with English summary)
49	JR Tao. 1983. Discovery of Palibinia from Puyang of Henan, and its paleoclimatic significance. Chinese Bulletin of Botany 1(1): 50–52. (in Chinese)
50	BH Tiffney, SR Manchester. 2001. The use of geological and paleontological evidence in evaluating plant phylogeographic hypotheses in the Northern Hemisphere Tertiary. International Journal of Plant Sciences 162(6, supplement): S3–S17.
51	M Vásquez-Cruz, AP Vovides, V Sosa. 2017. Disentangling species limits in the Vauquelinia corymbosa complex (Pyreae, Rosaceae). Systematic Botany 42(4): 835–847.
52	ND Vassilevskaja. 1957. Eocene flora from Badkhyz in Turkmenia. In: Dorofeev PI ed. Memorial collection to AN Kryshtofovich, M—L. Moscow and Leningrad: Academy of Sciences USSR Press. 103–117. (in Russian)
53	YQ Wang, Q Li, B Bai, X Jin, FY Mao, J Meng. 2019. Paleogene integrative stratigraphy and timescale of China. Science China Earth Sciences 62: 287–309.
54	YC Wang, HY Lu, HZ Lyu, DX Cai, XK Qiang, YX Li, XY Wang, W Lai, Y Wang, HZ Zhang, KX Wang, ZH Huang, XC Yu, SL Hu. 2023. East Asian hydroclimate responses to the Eocene-Oligocene transition in the Weihe Basin, central China. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 615: 111436.
55	H Weyland. 1943. Beiträge zur Kenntnis der rheinischen Tertiärflora: VI. Palaeontographica Abteilung B 87: 94–136.
56	Writing Group of Cenozoic Plants of China. 1978. Cenozoic plants from China. Fossil plants of China. Beijing: Science Press. 3: 232.
57	Yulong Xie, Wu Fuli, Xiaomin Fang, Jiazuo Song, Niu Zhichao. 2002. Late Eocene onset of the East Asian Monsoon in the Qingjiang Basin of Central Jiangxi Province (Southeast China) revealed by a major vegetation transition from desert to forest. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 602: 111179.
58	SG Zhilin. 1980. Notes on systematics of fossil plants. Myricaceae. In: Zhilin SG ed. Systematics and evolution of higher plants. Leningrad: Nauka. 9–20. (in Russian)
59	SG Zhilin. 1989. History of the development of the temperate forest flora in Kazakhstan, U.S.S.R. from the Oligocene to the Early Miocene. Botanical Review 55(4): 205–330.
60	SG Zhilin. 1991. Methodological problems of paleofloristics (by the example Kazakhstan Paleogene and Neogene flora). In: Zhilin SG ed. Development of the flora in Kazakhstan and Russian Plain from the Eocene to the Miocene. Leningrad: Komarov Botanical Institute, Academia scientiarum USSR. 57–88. (in Russian)
61	SG Zhilin. 2005. On the diversity of the flora emerged by the end of the late Eocene in Kazakhstan. In: Akhmetiev MA, Herman AB, eds. Modern problems of palaeofloristics, palaeophytogeography and phytostratigraphy. Transaction of the International Palaeobotanical Conference, May 17–18, 2005. Moscow: GEOS. 1: 90–96. (in Russian)