Effects of site preparation methods on soil physical properties and outplanting success of coniferous seedlings in boreal forests

Abstract

This study assessed the effect of patch scarification and mounding on the physical properties of the root layer and the success of tree planting in various types of forests. This study was conducted on 12 forest sites in taiga forests of the European part of Russia. A total of 54 plots were set up to assess seedling survival; root collar diameter, height, and heigh increment were measured for 240 seedlings to assess growth. In the rooting layer, 240 soil samples were taken to determine physical properties. The study showed that soil treatment methods had no effect on bulk density and total porosity in Cladina sites. However, reduced soil moisture was noted, particularly in mounds, resulting in increased aeration. In Myrtillus sites, there were increased bulk density, reduced soil moisture, and total porosity in the mounds. Mounding treatment in Polytrichum sites resulted in reduced soil moisture and increased aeration porosity. In the Myrtillus and Polytrichum sites, patch scarification had no effects on physical properties. In Polytrichum sites, survival rates, heights, and heigh increments of bareroot Norway spruce seedlings in mounds were higher than in patches; however, the same did not apply to diameter. In Cladina and Myrtillus sites, there was no difference in growth for bareroot and containerised seedlings with different soil treatments. Growing conditions and soil types should be considered when applying different soil treatment methods to ensure high survival rates and successful seedling growth.

References

Babich NA, Sungurov RV, Sungurova NR (2006) Forest crops in the northern taiga subzone: monograph. Solombal'skaya tipografiya, Arkhangelsk, p 144

BartenevIM. On the question of creation of forest cultures by PMCR planting. For Eng J, 2013, 2: 123-130

BurtonP, BedfordL, GoldsteinM, OsbergM. Effects of disk trench orientation and planting spot position on the ten-year performance of lodgepole pine. New for, 2000, 20(1): 23-44

CardosoJC, BurtonPJ, ElkinCM. A disturbance ecology perspective on silvicultural site preparation. Forests, 2020, 11(12): 1278

CelmaS, BlateK, LazdiņaD, DūmiņšK, NeimaneS, ŠtālsTA, ŠtikāneK. Effect of soil preparation method on root development of P. sylvestris and P. abies saplings in commercial forest stands. New for, 2019, 50: 283-290

de ChantalM, LeinonenK, IlvesniemiH, WestmanCJ. Combined effects of site preparation, soil properties, and sowing date on the establishment of Pinus sylvestris and Picea abies from seeds. Can J for Res, 2003, 33(5): 931-945

DebkovNM. Experience in the creation of forest plantations using container seedlings. Russ for J, 2021, 5: 192-200

DuanJ, AbduwaliD. Basic theory and methods of afforestation, 2021 London Intechopen

DuminsK, LazdinaD. Forest regeneration quality—factors affecting first year survival of planted trees. Res Rural Dev, 2018, 1: 53-58

DymovAA, LaptevaEM. Changes in podzolic soils on bilayered deposits under the influence of felling. Russ J for Sci, 2006, 3: 42-49

GladinovAN, KonovalovaEV, SodboevaSCh. Results of a comparative analysis of the use of Scots pine seedlings with open and closed root system under artificial forest recovery in the conditions of Western Transbaikalie. Adv Curr Nat Sci, 2021, 11: 7-12

HäggströmB, DomevscikM, ÖhlundJ, NordinA. Survival and growth of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) seedlings in north Sweden: effects of planting position and arginine phosphate addition. Scand J for Res, 2021, 36(6): 423-433

HallsbyG, ÖrlanderGA. Comparison of mounding and inverting to establish Norway spruce on podzolic soils in Sweden. Forestry, 2004, 77(2): 107-117

HattoriD, TanakaK, IrinoKO, KendawangJJ, NinomiyaI, SakuraiK. Effects of soil compaction on the growth and mortality of planted dipterocarp seedlings in a logged-over tropical rainforest in Sarawak Malaysia. For Ecol Manag, 2013, 310: 770-776

HébertSS, SerneelsL, ToliaA, CraessaertsK, DerksC, FilippovMA, MüllerU, De StrooperB. Regulated intramembrane proteolysis of amyloid precursor protein and regulation of expression of putative target genes. EMBO Rep, 2006, 7(7): 739-745

HolmströmE, GålnanderH, PeterssonM. Within-site variation in seedling survival in Norway spruce plantations. Forests, 2019, 10(2): 181

IlintsevA, BogdanovA, NakvasinaE, AmosovaI, KoptevS, TretyakovS. The natural recovery of disturbed soil, plant cover and trees after clear-cutting in the Boreal Forests. Russia Iforest, 2020, 13: 531-540

IUSS Working Group WRB (2015) World reference base for soil resources. International soil classification system for naming soils and creating legends for soil maps. In: World Soil Resources Reports no. 106, FAO, Rome, Italy, p 181

JääratsA, TullusA. The effect of planting stock and soil scarification on forest regeneration. For Stud, 2018, 69(1): 75-85

KarpechkoAYu. Changes in density and root mass in soils under the influence of harvesting machines in spruce forests of Southern Karelia. Russ J for Sci, 2008, 5: 66-70

KikeevaAV, NovichonokEV, KharitonovVA, Kryshen’ AM, . Features of the root system development in Picea Abies (L.) H. Karst. seedlings planted under shelterwood in a moist bilberry spruce forest depending on soil preparation methods. Trans KarRC RAS, 2022, 3: 28-41

KnappBO, WangGG, WalkerJL. Relating the survival and growth of planted longleaf pine seedlings to microsite conditions altered by site preparation treatments. For Ecol Manag, 2008, 255(11): 3768-3777

KošuličO, ProcházkaJ, TufIH, MichalkoR. Intensive site preparation for reforestation wastes multi-trophic biodiversity potential in commercial oak woodlands. J Environ Manage, 2021, 300

KozlowskiTT. Soil aeration, flooding and tree growth. J of Arboric, 1985, 11: 85-96

LöfM, DeyDC, NavarroRM, JacobsDF. Mechanical site preparation for forest restoration. New for, 2012, 43: 825-848

LuoranenJ, ViiriH. Deep planting decreases risk of drought damage and increases growth of Norway spruce container seedlings. New for, 2016, 47: 701-714

Mc CarthyR, RytterL, HjelmK. Effects of soil preparation methods and plant types on the establishment of poplars on forest land. Ann for Sci, 2017, 74: 47

Merzlenko MD, Babich NA (2002) Theory and practice of growing pine and spruce in crops. Publishing House Arhang.gos.tekhn. un–ta, Arkhangelsk, p 220

MochalovBA. Soil cultivation and selection planting site attached to pine artificial stands creation from containerized seedlings. Russ for J, 2014, 4: 9-18

MochalovBA, SenkovAO. Growth of bare-root and containerized pine seedlings in cultures of taiga zone. Russ for J, 2007, 4: 145-147

MorozovAE, BaturinSV. Efficiency of forest recovery on continuous felling after application of complexes multi-operation forestry machines in the conditions of Bead forestry of the Perm region. For Russ Econ, 2020, 2(73): 50-57

NilssonU, LuoranenJ, KolströmT, ÖrlanderG, PuttonenP. Reforestation with planting in northern Europe. Scand J for Res, 2010, 25(4): 283-294

NilssonO, HjelmK, NilssonU. Early growth of planted Norway spruce and Scots pine after site preparation in Sweden. Scand J for Res, 2019, 34: 678-688

NovichonokEV, GalibinaNA, KharitonovVA, KikeevaAV, NikerovaKM, SofronovaIN, RumyantsevAS. Effect of site preparation under shelterwood on Norway spruce seedlings. Scand J for Res, 2020, 35(8): 523-531

NzokouP, CreggBM. Morphology and foliar chemistry of containerized Abies fraseri (Pursh) Poir. Seedlings as affected by water availability and nutrition. Ann for Sci, 2010, 67: 602

OsmanKT. Forest soils: properties and management, 2013 Switzerland Springer 217

Page-DumroeseDS, HarveyAE, JurgensenMF, AmaranthusMP. Impacts of soil compaction and tree stump removal on soil properties and outplanted seedlings in northern Idaho, USA. Can J Forest Res, 1998, 78: 29-34

PallR, MohseninNN. A soil air pycnometer for determination of porosity and particle density. Trans Am Soc Agric Eng, 1980, 23: 735-741

ParshevnikovAL. On soils on the eluvia of red-colored marl. Eurasian Soil Sci, 1966, 5: 28-34

PerumalM, WasliME, YingHS, LatJ, SaniH. Soil morphological and physicochemical properties at reforestation sites after enrichment planting of shorea macrophylla in sampadi forest reserve, sarawak. Malays Borneo J Resour Sci Technol, 2015, 5(2): 28-43

SaksaT, HeiskanenJ, MiinaJ, TuomolaJ, KolstromT. Multilevel modelling of height growth in young Norway spruce plantations in southern Finland. Silva Fenn, 2005, 39(1): 143-153

SheinEV. Course of soil physics, 2005 Moscow MSU Publ 432

SikströmU, HjelmK, Holt HanssenK, SaksaT, WallertzK. Influence of mechanical site preparation on regeneration success of planted conifers in clearcuts Fennoscandia—a review. Silva Fenn, 2020, 54(2): 1-35

SklyarovGA, SharovaAS. The soils of the North European forests, 1970 Moscow Nauka 268

Sokolov AI (2006) Reforestation in the clearcuts of the North-West of Russia. KarRC RAS, Petrozavodsk, p 215

SukachevVN. Fundamentals of forest biogeocenology, 1964 Moskow Nauka 571

SuttonRF. Mounding site preparation: a review of European and North American experience. New for, 1993, 7(2): 151-192

TsyribkoVB. Determination of the optimal parameters of soil agrophysical properties and assessment of the current status based on them. Soil Sci Agrochem, 2016, 1: 36-44

Varfolomeev LA, Sungurov RV (2007) Soil ecology of forest crops in the North. Arkhangelsk, p 291

ZhigunovAV, ShevchukSV. Forest cultures of pine and spruce from planting material grown by combined method. Russ for J, 2006, 6: 13-19

Zhigunov AV (2000) Theory and practice of containerized planting material growing. St.-Petersburg, p 294