Effects of thinning and understory removal on water use efficiency of Pinus massoniana: evidence from photosynthetic capacity and stable carbon isotope analyses

Abstract

Understanding the relationship between forest management and water use efficiency (WUE) is important for evaluating forest adaptability to climate change. However, the effects of thinning and understory removal on WUE and its key controlling processes are not well understood, which limits our comprehension of the physiological mechanisms of various management practices. In this study, four forest management measures (no thinning: NT; understory removal: UR; light thinning: LT; and heavy thinning: HT) were carried out in Pinus massoniana plantations in a subtropical region of China. Photosynthetic capacity and needle stable carbon isotope composition (δ¹³C) were measured to assess instantaneous water use efficiency (WUE_inst) and long-term water use efficiency (WUE_i). Multiple regression models and structural equation modelling (SEM) identified the effects of soil properties and physiological performances on WUE_inst and WUE_i. The results show that WUE_inst values among the four treatments were insignificant. However, compared with the NT stand (35.8 μmol·mol⁻¹), WUE_i values significantly increased to 41.7 μmol·mol⁻¹ in the UR, 50.1 μmol·mol⁻¹ in the LT and 46.6 μmol·mol⁻¹ in HT treatments, largely explained by photosynthetic capacity and soil water content. Understory removal did not change physiological performance (needle water potential and photosynthetic capacity). Thinning increased the net photosynthetic rate (A_n) but not stomatal conductance (g_s) or predawn needle water potential (ψ_pd), implying that the improvement in water use efficiency for thinned stands was largely driven by radiation interception than by soil water availability. In general, thinning may be an appropriate management measure to promote P. massoniana WUE to cope with seasonal droughts under future extreme climates.

Keywords

Stable carbon isotope / Water use efficiency / Thinning / Understory removal / Photosynthetic capacity / Needle water potential

References

[1]	Allen CD, Macalady AK, Chenchouni H, Bachelet D, McDowell N, Vennetier M, Kitzberger T, Rigling A, Breshears DD, Hogg EH (2010) A global overview of drought and heat-induced tree mortality reveals emerging climate change risks for forests. For Ecol Manag 259:660–684
[2]	Ameztegui A, Cabon A, De Cáceres M, Coll L (2017) Managing stand density to enhance the adaptability of Scots pine stands to climate change: a modelling approach. Ecol Modell 356:141–150
[3]	Barton K (2013) MuMIn: multi-model inference. R package version 1.9.13. Available online: http://CRAN.Rproject.org/package=MuMIn.
[4]	Bayar E, Delig?z A (2020) Impacts of precommercial thinning on gas exchange, midday water potential, and chlorophyll content in Pinus nigra subsp. pallasiana stand from the semiarid region. Trees 34:1169–1181
[5]	Bchir A, Escalona JM, Gallé A, Hernández-Montes E, Tortosa I, Braham M, Medrano H (2016) Carbon isotope discrimination (δ13C) as an indicator of vine water status and water use efficiency (WUE): looking for the most representative sample and sampling time. Agr Water Manage 167:11–20
[6]	Bose AK, Nelson AS, Kane M, Rigling A (2018) Density reduction in loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) stands to increase tree C assimilation: an approach with the dual δ13C and δ18O isotope signatures in needles. Ann Forest Sci 75:8
[7]	Bréda N, Granier A, Aussenac G (1995) Effects of thinning on soil and tree water relations, transpiration and growth in an oak forest (Quercus petraea (Matt.) Liebl.). Tree Physiol 15:295–306
[8]	Brooks JR, Mitchell AK (2011) Interpreting tree responses to thinning and fertilization using tree-ring stable isotopes. New Phytol 190:770–782
[9]	Burnham KP, Anderson DR (2002) Model selection and multimodel inference: a practical information-theoretic approach, 2nd edn. Springer, New York, pp 98–99
[10]	Chen ZX, Liu XJ, Cui XQ, Han YW, Wang GA, Li JZ (2021) Evaluating the response of 13C in Haloxylon ammodendron, a dominant C4 species in Asian desert ecosystems, to water and nitrogen addition as well as the availability of its 13C as an indicator of water use efficiency. Biogeosciences 18:2859–2870
[11]	Cooley SS, Fisher JB, Goldsmith GR (2022) Convergence in water use efficiency within plant functional types across contrasting climates. Nat Plants 8:341–345
[12]	Dawson TE, Mambelli S, Plamboeck AH, Templer PH, Tu KP (2002) Stable isotopes in plant ecology. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 33:507–559
[13]	Del Campo AD, González-Sanchis M, Lidón A, Ceacero C, García-Prats A (2018) Rainfall partitioning after thinning in two low-biomass semiarid forests: impact of meteorological variables and forest structure on the effectiveness of water-oriented treatments. J Hydrol 565:74–86
[14]	Del Campo AD, González-Sanchis M, García-Prats A, Ceacero CJ, Lull C (2019) The impact of adaptive forest management on water fluxes and growth dynamics in a water-limited low-biomass oak coppice. Agr Forest Meteorol 264:266–282
[15]	Di Matteo G, Nardi P, Fabbio G (2017) On the use of stable carbon isotopes to detect the physiological impact of forest management: the case of Mediterranean coppice woodland. For Ecol Manag 389:158–166
[16]	Ding YL, Nie YP, Chen HS, Wang KL, Querejeta JI (2021) Water uptake depth is coordinated with leaf water potential, water use efficiency and drought vulnerability in karst vegetation. New Phytol 229:1339–1353
[17]	Fan Y, Chen JQ, Shirkey G, John R, Wu SR, Park H, Shao CL (2016) Applications of structural equation modeling (SEM) in ecological studies: an updated review. Ecol Process 5:19–31
[18]	Farquhar GD, Richards R (1984) Isotopic composition of plant carbon correlates with water-use efficiency of wheat genotypes. Funct Plant Biol 11:539–552
[19]	Farquhar GD, O’Leary M, Berry J (1982) On the relationship between carbon isotope discrimination and the intercellular carbon dioxide concentration in leaves. Funct Plant Biol 9:121–137
[20]	Farquhar GD, Ehleringer JR, Hubick KT (1989) Carbon isotope discrimination and photosynthesis. Annu Rev Plant Biol 40:503–537
[21]	Fernandes TJG, Del Campo AD, Herrera R, Herrera R, Molina AJ (2016) Simultaneous assessment, through sap flow and stable isotopes, of water use efficiency (WUE) in thinned pines shows improvement in growth, tree-climate sensitivity and WUE, but not in WUEi. For Ecol Manag 361:298–308
[22]	Gao Y, Xia JB, Chen YP, Zhao YY, Kong QX, Lang Y (2017) Effects of extreme soil water stress on photosynthetic efficiency and water consumption characteristics of Tamarix chinensis in China’s Yellow River Delta. J For Res 28:491–501
[23]	Giuggiola A, Ogee J, Rigling A, Gessler A, Bugmann H, Treydte K (2016) Improvement of water and light availability after thinning at a xeric site: which matters more? A dual isotope approach. New Phytol 210:108–121
[24]	Giuggiola A, Zweifel R, Feichtinger LM, Vollenweide P, Bugmann H, Haeni M, Rigling A (2018) Competition for water in a xeric forest ecosystem-effects of understory removal on soil micro-climate, growth and physiology of dominant Scots pine trees. For Ecol Manag 409:241–249
[25]	Guerrieri R, Correia M, Martín-Forés I, Alfaro-Sánchez R, Pino J, Hampe A, Valladares F, Espelta JM (2021) Land-use legacies influence tree water-use efficiency and nitrogen availability in recently established European forests. Funct Ecol 35:1325–1340
[26]	Kelty MJ, Gould EM, Twery MJ (1987) Effects of understory removal in hardwood stands. Northern J Appl For 4:162–164
[27]	Klein T, Shpringer I, Fikler B (2013) Relationships between stomatal regulation, water-use, and water-use efficiency of two coexisting key Mediterranean tree species. For Ecol Manag 302:34–42
[28]	Kume A, Satomura T, Tsuboi N, Chiwa M, Hanba YT, Nakane K, Horikoshi T, Sakugawa H (2003) Effects of understory vegetation on the ecophysiology characteristics of an overstory pine, Pinus densiflora. For Ecol Manag 176:195–203
[29]	Lechuga V, Carraro V, Vi?egla B, Carreira JA, Linares GC (2017) Managing drought-sensitive forests under global change low competition enhances long-term growth and water uptake in Abies pinsapo. For Ecol Manag 406:72–82
[30]	Lei L, Xiao WF, Zeng LX, Zhu JH, Huang ZL, Cheng RM, Gao SK, Li MH (2017) Thinning but not understory removal increased heterotrophic respiration and total soil respiration in Pinus massoniana stands. Sci Total Environ 621:1360–1369
[31]	Li RS, Han JM, Guan X, Chi YG, Zhang WD, Chen LC, Wang QK, Xue M, Yang QP, Wang SL (2020) Crown pruning and understory removal did not change the tree growth rate in a Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) plantation. For Ecol Manag 464:118056
[32]	Li YJ, Dong ZP, Chen DL, Zhao SY, Zhou FF, Cao XG, Fang KY (2019) Growth decline of Pinus Massoniana in response to warming induced drought and increasing intrinsic water use efficiency in humid subtropical China. Dendrochronologia 57:125609
[33]	Liu X, Sun G, Mitra B, Noormets A, Gavazzi MJ, Domec J, Hallema DW, Li J, Fang Y, King JS, McNulty SG (2018) Drought and thinning have limited impacts on evapotranspiration in a managed pine plantation on the southeastern United States coastal plain. Agr Forest Meteorol 262:14–23
[34]	Liu YB, Xiao JF, Ju WM, Zhou YL, Wang SQ, Wu XC (2015) Water use efficiency of China’s terrestrial ecosystems and responses to drought. Sci Rep 5:13799
[35]	Liu ZQ, Yu XX, Jia GD (2019) Water uptake by coniferous and broad-leaved forest in a rocky mountainous area of northern China. Agric for Meteorol 265:381–389
[36]	Martín-Benito D, Del Río M, Heinrich I, Helle G, Ca?ellas I (2010) Response of climate-growth relationships and water use efficiency to thinning in a Pinus nigra afforestation. For Ecol Manag 259:967–975
[37]	McDowell N, Brooks JR, Fitzgerald SA, Bond BJ (2003) Carbon isotope discrimination and growth response of old Pinus ponderosa trees to stand density reductions. Plant Cell Environ 26:631–644
[38]	McJannet D, Vertessy R (2001) Effects of thinning on wood production, leaf area index transpiration and canopy interception of a plantation subject to drought. Tree Physiol 21:1001–1008
[39]	Moreno-Gutiérrez C, Barbera GG, Nicolas E, Luis MD, Castillo VM, Martínez-Fernández F, Querejeta JI (2011) Leaf δ18O of remaining trees is affected by thinning intensity in a semiarid pine forest. Plant Cell Environ 34:1009–1019
[40]	Niccoli F, Pelleri F, Manetti MC, Sansone D, Battipaglia G (2020) Effects of thinning intensity on productivity and water use efficiency of Quercus robur L. For Ecol Manag 473:118282
[41]	Niu SL, Xing XR, Zhang Z, Xia JY, Zhou XH, Song B, Li LH, Wan SQ (2011) Water-use efficiency in response to climate change: from leaf to ecosystem in a temperate steppe. Glob Chang Biol 17:1073–1082
[42]	Osmond CB, Bj?rkman O, Anderson DJ (1982) Physiological processes in plant ecology: toward a synthesis with Atriplex, vol 36. Springer, NewYork, p 98
[43]	Park J, Kim T, Moon M, Cho S, Ryu D, Seok Kim H (2018) Effects of thinning intensities on tree water use, growth, and resultant water use efficiency of 50-year-old Pinus koraiensis forest over four years. For Ecol Manag 408:121–128
[44]	Pascual M, Villar JM, Rufat J (2015) Water use efficiency in peach trees over a four-years experiment on the effects of irrigation and nitrogen application. Agr Water Manage 164:253–266
[45]	Pe?uelas J, Canadell JG, Ogaya R (2011) Increased water-use efficiency during the 20th century did not translate into enhanced tree growth. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 20:597–608
[46]	Powers MD, Pregitzer KS, Palik BJ, Webster CR (2010) Wood δ13C, δ18O and radial growth responses of residual red pine to variable retention harvesting. Tree Physiol 30:326–334
[47]	Saurer M, Siegenthaler U (1989) 13C/12C isotope ratios in trees are sensitive to relative humidity. Dendrochronologia 7:9–13
[48]	Scheidegger Y, Saurer M, Bahn M, Siegwolf R (2000) Linking stable oxygen and carbon isotopes with stomatal conductance and photosynthetic capacity: a conceptual model. Oecologia 125:350–357
[49]	Seibt U, Abazar R, Griffiths H, Berry JA (2008) Carbon isotopes and water use efficiency: sense and sensitivity. Oecologia 155:441–454
[50]	Sheng WP, Ren SJ, Yu GR, Fang HJ, Jiang CM, Zhang M (2011) Patterns and driving factors of WUE and NUE in natural forest ecosystems along the North-South Transect of Eastern China. J Geogr Sci 21:651–665
[51]	Skov KR, Kolb TE, Wallin KF (2004) Tree size and drought affect ponderosa pine physiological response to thinning and burning treatments. For Sci 50:81–91
[52]	Sohn JA, Gebhardt T, Ammer C, Bauhus J, H?berle KH, Matyssek R, Grams TEE (2013) Mitigation of drought by thinning: short-term and long-term effects on growth and physiological performance of Norway spruce (Picea abies). For Ecol Manag 308:188–197
[53]	Su BQ, Shangguan ZP (2020) Patterns and driving factors of water and nitrogen use efficiency in Robinia pseudoacacia L. On the Loess Plateau in China. Catena 195:104790
[54]	Sun SF, Huang JH, Han XG, Lin GH (2008) Comparisons in water relations of plants between newly formed riparian and non-riparian habitats along the bank of Three Gorges Reservoir, China. Trees 22:717–728
[55]	Tarin T, Nolan RH, Medlyn BE, Cleverly J, Eamus D (2020) Water-use efficiency in a semi-arid woodland with high rainfall variability. Glob Chang Biol 26:496–508
[56]	Wang J, Wen XF, Li XY, Li SG (2018) The strategies of water-carbon regulation of plants in a subtropical primary forest on karst soils in China. Biogeosciences 15:4193–4203
[57]	Wang T, Xu Q, Gao DQ, Zhang BB, Zuo HJ, Jiang J (2021) Effects of thinning and understory removal on the soil water-holding capacity in Pinus massoniana plantations. Sci Rep 11:13029
[58]	Wang T, Xu Q, Gao DQ, Zhang BB, Zhang Y, Ren RR, Jiang J (2022) Effects of understory removal and thinning on water uptake patterns in Pinus massoniana Lamb. plantations: evidence from stable isotope analysis. For Ecol Manag 503:119755
[59]	Wang WZ, McDowell N, Pennington S, Grossiord C, Leff R, Sengupta A, Ward N, Sezen U, Rich R, Megonigal P, Stegen J, Bond-Lamberty B, Bailey V (2020) Tree growth, transpiration, and water-use efficiency between shoreline and upland red maple (Acer rubrum) trees in a coastal forest. Agr Forest Meteorol 295:108163
[60]	Warren CR, Mcgrath JF, Adams MA (2001) Water availability and carbon isotope discrimination in conifers. Oecologia 127:476–486
[61]	Wu XC, Li XY, Chen YH, Bai Y, Tong YQ, Wang P, Liu HY, Wang MJ, Shi FZ, Zhang CC, Huang YM, Ma YJ, Hu X, Shi CM (2021) Atmospheric water demand dominates daily variations in water use efficiency in alpine meadows, northeastern Tibetan Plateau. Biogeosciences 124:2174–2185
[62]	Zhang BB, Xu Q, Gao DQ, Jiang CW, Liu FT, Jiang J, Ma YB (2019) Higher soil capacity of intercepting heavy rainfall in mixed stands than in pure stands in riparian forests. Sci Total Environ 658:1514–1522
[63]	Zhao Y, Wang L, Knighton J, Evaristo J, Wassen M (2021) Contrasting adaptive strategies by Caragana korshinskii and Salix psammophila in a semiarid revegetated ecosystem. Agr Forest Meteorol 300:10832
[64]	Zhou XZ (2001) Masson Pine in China. China Forestry Publishing House, Beijing, pp 11–12