Research Status of Lava Tube Exploration in the Solar System

Abstract

Lava tubes, formed by the flow and cooling processes of volcanic lava, have been discovered on the surface of several heavenly bodies in the solar system and have become a window into the volcanic activity and thermal history of Earth-like planets. At the same time, lava tubes have extremely important scientific and engineering applications because of their thermostatic and radiation-proof interiors, which are also natural shelters for future human exploration activities or extraterrestrial survival. In this paper, the formation mechanism, detection and identification methods of lava tubes, and the distribution of lava tubes on the surface of different heavenly bodies in the solar system were summarized, the scientific significance and application prospects of lava tube detection were discussed. It was proposed that the Earth’s lava tubes are the most important objects for planetary lava tube analogical studies and detection, and the theory and methodology of the analogical studies of lava tubes were introduced, to provide theoretical basis and simulation experimental support for future exploration of extraterrestrial lava tubes.

Keywords

lava tubes / volcanic activity / solar system / planetary exploration

References

[1] USGS. What is a Shield Volcano? [EB/OL]. (2023-09-02).https：//www.nps.gov/articles/000/shield-volcanoes.htm.
[2] LEDERBERG J. Exobiology：approaches to life beyond the Earth[J]. Science，1960，132（3424）：393-400.
[3] LIM S，PRABHU V L，ANAND M，et al. Extra-terrestrial construction processes–Advancements，opportunities and challenges[J]. Advances in Space Research，2017，60（7）：1413-1429.
[4] WHITE F. The overview effect：space exploration and human evolution[M]. [S. l.]：AIAA，1998.
[5] RAPP D. Use of extraterrestrial resources for human space missions to Moon or Mars[M]. New York：Springer，2013.
[6] DING J，XIE G，GUO L，et al. Karst cave as terrestrial simulation platform to test and design human base in lunar lava tube[J]. Space：Science & Technology，2022（1）：489-499.
[7] STRAUS L G. Caves：a palaeoanthropological resource[J]. World Archaeology，1979，10（3）：331-339.
[8] ROKSANDIC M，MIHAILOVIĆ D，MERCIER N，et al. A human mandible （BH-1） from the Pleistocene deposits of Mala Balanica cave （Sićevo Gorge，Niš，Serbia）[J]. Journal of Human Evolution，2011，61（2）：186-196.
[9] BARRETT L，GAYNOR D，RENDALL D，et al. Habitual cave use and thermoregulation in chacma baboons （Papio hamadryas ursinus）[J]. Journal of Human Evolution，2004，46（2）：215-222.
[10] HARUYAMA J，HIOKI K，SHIRAO M，et al. Possible lunar lava tube skylight observed by SELENE cameras[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2009，36（21）：L21206：1-5.
[11] CUSHING G E，TITUS T N，WYNNE J J，et al. THEMIS observes possible cave skylights on Mars[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2007，34（17）：17201：1-5.
[12] VOCK A，NILSSON T. Holistic outpost design for lunar lava tubes[J]. ArXiv Preprint, 2022(2)：1-12.
[13] GREELEY R. Lava tubes and channels in the lunar Marius Hills[J]. The Moon，1971，3（3）：289-314.
[14] MAGHAREH A，GOMEZ D，DYKE S J，et al. Resilience for permanent extraterrestrial habitats[C]//Proceedings of the 48th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference. Texas：LPI，2017：19-23.
[15] DYKE S J，BOBET A，RAMIREZ J，et al. Resilient extraterrestrial habitat engineering[C]//Proceedings of 49th Annual Lunar and Planetary Science Conference. Texas：LPI，2018 （2083）：2882.
[16] PERKINS S. Lava tubes may be havens for ancient alien life and future human explorers[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences，2020，117（30）：17461-17464.
[17] POPA R，SMITH A R，POPA R，et al. Olivine-respiring bacteria isolated from the rock-ice interface in a lava-tube cave，a Mars analog environment[J]. Astrobiology，2012，12（1）：9-18.
[18] LÉVEILLÉ R J，DATTA S. Lava tubes and basaltic caves as astrobiological targets on Earth and Mars：a review[J]. Planetary and Space Science，2010，58（4）：592-598.
[19] SAURO F，POZZOBON R，MASSIRONI M，et al. Lava tubes on Earth，Moon and Mars：a review on their size and morphology revealed by comparative planetology[J]. Earth-Science Reviews，2020，209：103288.
[20] GREELEY R. Lava tubes in the solar system[C]// Proceedings of Sixth international symposium on vulcanospeleolog. Hilo，Hawaii：[s. n.]，1991：1-8.
[21] KESZTHELYI L. A preliminary thermal budget for lava tubes on the Earth and planets[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Solid Earth，1995，100（B10）：20411-20420.
[22] VON EHRENFRIED M D，VON EHRENFRIED M D. Terrestrial cave and lava tube research[J]. From Cave Man to Cave Martian：Living in Caves on the Earth，Moon and Mars，2019：49-81.
[23] CRUIKSHANK D P，WOOD C A. Lunar rilles and Hawaiian volcanic features：Possible analogues[J]. The Moon，1972，3（4）：412-447.
[24] 肖龙，黄俊，赵佳伟，等. 月面熔岩管洞穴探测的意义与初步设想[J]. 中国科学：物理学，力学，天文学，2018，48（11）：86-99.
XIAO LONG，HUANG JUN，ZHAO JIAWEI，et al. The significance and preliminary ideas of lunar lava tube cave detection[J]. Science in China：Physics，Mechanics，Astronomy，2018，48（11）：86-99.
[25] CALVARI S，PINKERTON H. Formation of lava tubes and extensive flow field during the 1991–1993 eruption of Mount Etna[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Solid Earth，1998，103（B11）：27291-27301.
[26] BLAIR D M，CHAPPAZ L，SOOD R，et al. The structural stability of lunar lava tubes[J]. Icarus，2017，282：47-55.
[27] WHITTAKER W. Technologies enabling exploration of skylights，lava tubes and caves[C]//Astrobotic Technology. Pittsburgh：[s.n.], 2012：1-51.
[28] MELOSH H J，IVANOV B A. Impact crater collapse[J]. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences，1999，27（1）：385-415.
[29] THURBER C H，SOLOMON S C. An assessment of crustal thickness variations on the lunar near side-Models，uncertainties，and implications for crustal differentiation[C]//Proceedings of Lunar and Planetary Science Conference. Houston：[s. n.]，1978：1-17.
[30] BILLS B G，FERRARI A J. A lunar density model consistent with topographic，gravitational，librational，and seismic data[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research，1977，82（8）：1306-1314.
[31] CHAPPAZ L，SOOD R，MELOSH H J，et al. Evidence of large empty lava tubes on the Moon using GRAIL gravity[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2017，44（1）：105-112.
[32] KAKU T，HARUYAMA J，MIYAKE W，et al. Detection of intact lava tubes at Marius Hills on the Moon by SELENE （Kaguya） Lunar Radar Sounder[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2017，44（20）：1-7.
[33] 林红磊，丁春雨，许学森，等. 月球就位光谱和雷达遥感科学研究进展[J]. 地球与行星物理论评，2021，52（4）：373-390.
LIN HONGLEI，DING CHUNYU，XU XUESEN，et al. Progress in scientific research on lunar placement spectroscopy and radar remote sensing[J]. Reviews of Earth and Planetary Physics，2021，52（4）：373-390.
[34] 丁春雨，封剑青，郑磊，等. 雷达探测技术在探月中的应用[J]. 天文研究与技术，2015，12（02）：228-242.
DING C Y，FENG J Q，ZHENG L，et al. Application of radar detection technology in lunar exploration[J]. Astronomical Research and Technology，2015，12（02）：228-242.
[35] HORVATH T，HAYNE P O，PAIGE D A. Thermal and illumination environments of lunar pits and caves：models and observations from the diviner lunar radiometer experiment[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2022，49（14）：1-9.
[36] DING C，FENG J Q，ZHENG L，et al. A review of applications of radar-detection techniques in lunar explorations[J]. Astronomical Research & Technology-Publications of National Astronomical Observatories of China，2015，12（2）：228-242.
[37] QIU X，DING C. Radar observation of the lava tubes on the Moon and Mars[J]. Remote Sensing，2023，15（11）：2850.
[38] NESNAS I A D，KERBER L，SELLAR G，et al. Moon diver：exploring a Pit's exposed strata to understand lunar volcanism[J]. Acta Astronautica，2023：163-176.
[39] BUNNELL D. Caves of Fire：inside america's lava tubes[M]. USA：National Speleological Society，2008：144.
[40] ALLRED K，ALLRED C. Development and morphology of Kazumura cave，Hawaii[J]. Journal of Caves and Karst Studies，1997，59：67-80.
[41] WYNNE J J，MYLROIE J E，TITUS T N，et al. Planetary caves：a solar system view of processes and products[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Planets，2022，127（11）：1-39.
[42] WAGNER R V，ROBINSON M S. Occurrence and origin of lunar pits：observations from a new catalog[C]//Proceedings of 52nd lunar and planetary science conference. Online：LPI，2021 （2548）：2530.
[43] GLAZE L S，ANDERSON S W，STOFAN E R，et al. Statistical distribution of tumuli on pahoehoe flow surfaces：analysis of examples in Hawaii and Iceland and potential applications to lava flows on Mars[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Solid Earth，2005：1-14.
[44] WERNER S C. The global martian volcanic evolutionary history[J]. Icarus，2009，201（1）：44-68.
[45] PETERS S I，CHRISTENSEN P R，CLARKE A B. Lava flow eruption conditions in the Tharsis volcanic province on Mars[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Planets，2021，126（7）：1-29
[46] SAM L，BHARDWAJ A，SINGH S，et al. Small lava caves as possible exploratory targets on Mars：analogies drawn from UAV imaging of an Icelandic lava field[J]. Remote Sensing，2020：1-30.
[47] BAIONI D，HAJNA N Z，WEZEL F C. Karst landforms in a Martian evaporitic dome[J]. Acta carsologica，2009，38（1）：175-184.
[48] ZHAO J，HUANG J，KRAFT M D，et al. Ridge-like lava tube systems in southeast Tharsis，Mars[J]. Geomorphology，2017，295：831-839.
[49] CUSHING G，OKUBO C. Description of the Mars Global Cave Candidate Catalog （MGC3） PDS Archive [J]. 2017,3：3708.
[50] FASSETT C I，KADISH S J，HEAD J W，et al. The global population of large craters on Mercury and comparison with the Moon[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2011：1-6.
[51] SPUDIS P D，GUEST J E. Stratigraphy and geologic history of Mercury[J]. Mercury，1988,5：118-164.
[52] GILLIS-DAVIS J J，BLEWETT D T，GASKELL R W，et al. Pit-floor craters on mercury：evidence of near-surface igneous activity[J]. Earth and Planetary Science Letters，2009，285（3-4）：243-250.
[53] DAVEY S C，ERNST R E，SAMSON C，et al. Hierarchical clustering of pit crater chains on Venus[J]. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences，2013，50（1）：109-126.
[54] MELVILLE G P. Lava tubes and channels of the Earth，Venus，Moon and Mars[J]. 1994（7）：1-175.
[55] VEEDER G J，DAVIES A G，MATSON D L，et al. Io：Heat flow from small volcanic features[J]. Icarus，2015，245：379-410.
[56] DAVIES A G，KESZTHELYI L P，WILLIAMS D A，et al. Thermal signature，eruption style，and eruption evolution at Pele and Pillan on Io[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Planets，2001，106（E12）：33079-33103.
[57] XIAO L，HUANG J，XIAO Z，et al. Volcanism in the Solar System[J]. Science China Earth Sciences，2023(1)：1-22.
[58] XIMENES S W，ELLIOTT J O，BANNOVA O. Defining a mission architecture and technologies for lunar lava tube reconnaissance[M]The 5th NASA/ASCE Workshop，California：Aerosapce Division of ASCE，2012：344-354.
[59] GOLDBERG P，SHERWOOD S C. Deciphering human prehistory through the geoarcheological study of cave sediments[J]. Evolutionary Anthropology：Issues，News，and Reviews：Issues，News，and Reviews，2006，15（1）：20-36.
[60] LEE P. Habitability of lava tubes on the Moon and Mars：lessons from Earth[J]. 2018,10：1-17.
[61] MARI N，GROEMER G，SEJKORA N. Potential futures in human habitation of martian lava tubes[J]. Mars：A Volcanic World，2021（5）：279-307.
[62] WILLIAMS J P，PAIGE D A，GREENHAGEN B T，et al. The global surface temperatures of the Moon as measured by the Diviner Lunar Radiometer Experiment[J]. Icarus，2017，283：300-325.
[63] THEINAT A K，MODIRIASARI A，BOBET A，et al. Lunar lava tubes：Morphology to structural stability[J]. Icarus，2020，338：113442.
[64] NAITO M，HASEBE N，SHIKISHIMA M，et al. Radiation dose and its protection in the Moon from galactic cosmic rays and solar energetic particles：at the lunar surface and in a lava tube[J]. Journal of Radiological Protection，2020，40（4）：947.
[65] MANDEVILLE J C，BARITEAU M. Cosmic dust and micro-debris measurements on the MIR space station[J]. Advances in Space Research，2001，28（9）：1317-1324.
[66] PRESCOTT R D，ZAMKOVAYA T，DONACHIE S P，et al. Islands within islands：bacterial phylogenetic structure and consortia in Hawaiian lava caves and fumaroles[J]. Frontiers in Microbiology，2022，13：1-20.
[67] WYNNE J J，TITUS T N，DIAZ G C. On developing thermal cave detection techniques for Earth，the Moon and Mars[J]. Earth and Planetary Science Letters，2008，272（1-2）：240-250.
[68] OHATA T，FURUKAWA T，HIGUCHI K. Glacioclimatological study of perennial ice in the Fuji ice cave，Japan. Part 1. Seasonal variation and mechanism of maintenance[J]. Arctic and Alpine Research，1994，26（3）：227-237.
[69] BANDYOPADHYAY S，LAZIO J，STOICA A，et al. Conceptual ideas for radio telescope on the far side of the Moon[C]//Proceedings of 2018 IEEE Aerospace Conference. [S. l.]：IEEE，2018：1-10.
[70] ELLERY A. Sustainable in-situ resource utilization on the moon[J]. Planetary and Space Science，2020，184：104870.
[71] JONES H W. Much lower launch costs make resupply cheaper than recycling for space life support[C]//Proceedings of International Conference on Environmental Systems （ICES-2017）. [S. l.]：ICES，2017：1-16.
[72] MIYAMOTO H，HARUYAMA J I，KOBAYASHI T，et al. Mapping the structure and depth of lava tubes using ground penetrating radar[J]. Geophysical Research Letters，2005（2）：1-5.
[73] OLHOEFT G R，SINEX D B，SANDER K A，et al. Hot and cold lava tube characterization with ground penetrating radar[C]//Proceedings of Eighth International Conference on Ground Penetrating Radar. [S. l.]：SPIE，2000，4084：482-487.
[74] ROWELL C R，PIDLISECKY A，IRVING J D，et al. Characterization of lava tubes using ground penetrating radar at Craters of the Moon National Monument[J]. Idaho，USA：CREWES Research Reoprt，2010，22：1-18.
[75] WHELLEY P，CROWN D A，BELL E，et al. Considerations for lava tube exploration[C]//Proceedings of AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts. 2020，2020：P063-04.
[76] BUTT M A，FOMCHENKOV S A，KHONINA S N. Modeling of a narrow band pass filter for Bathymetry light detection and ranging （LIDAR） system[J]. Journal of Physics：Conference Series，2017，917（6）：062004.
[77] LI J，YANG B，CHEN Y，et al. Evaluation of a compact helmet-based laser scanning system for aboveground and underground 3d mapping[J]. The International Archives of the Photogrammetry，Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences，2022，43：215-220.
[78] BELL JR E，SCHMERR N，YOUNG K，et al. Field mapping and modeling of terrestrial lava tube magnetic anomalies as an analog for lunar lava tube exploration and prospecting[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research：Planets，2022，127（6）：1-26.
[79] MIAJA P F，NAVARRO-MEDINA F，ALLER D G，et al. RoboCrane：a system for providing a power and a communication link between lunar surface and lunar caves for exploring robots[J]. Acta Astronautica，2022，192：30-46.
[80] KERBER L，NESNAS I，KESZTHELYI L，et al. Moon diver：A discovery mission concept for understanding the history of the mare basalts through the exploration of a lunar mare pit[J]. New Views of the Moon 2-Asia，2018，2070 603：1.