Carbon isotope fractionation during methane transport through tight sedimentary rocks: Phenomena, mechanisms, characterization, and implications

Abstract

The phenomenon of carbon isotopic fractionation, induced by the transport of methane in tight sedimentary rocks through processes primarily involving diffusion and adsorption/desorption, is ubiquitous in nature and plays a significant role in numerous geological and geochemical systems. Consequently, understanding the mechanisms of transport-induced carbon isotopic fractionation both theoretically and experimentally is of considerable scientific importance. However, previous experimental studies have observed carbon isotope fractionation phenomena that are entirely distinct, and even exhibit opposing characteristics. At present, there is a lack of a convincing mechanistic explanation and valid numerical model for this discrepancy. Here, we performed gas transport experiments under different gas pressures (1–5 MPa) and confining pressures (10–20 MPa). The results show that methane carbon isotope fractionation during natural gas transport through shale is controlled by its pore structure and evolves regularly with increasing effective stress. Compared with the carbon isotopic composition of the source gas, the initial effluent methane is predominantly depleted in ¹³C, but occasionally exhibits ¹³C enrichment. The carbon isotopic composition of effluent methane converges to that of the source gas as mass transport reaches a steady state. The evolution patterns of the isotope fractionation curve, transitioning from the initial non-steady state to the final steady state, can be categorized into five distinct types. The combined effect of multi-level transport channels offers the most compelling mechanistic explanation for the observed evolution patterns and their interconversion. Numerical simulation studies demonstrate that existing models, including the Rayleigh model, the diffusion model, and the coupled diffusion-adsorption/desorption model, are unable to describe the observed complex isotope fractionation behavior. In contrast, the multi-scale multi-mechanism coupled model developed herein, incorporating diffusion and adsorption/desorption across multi-level transport channels, effectively reproduces all the observed fractionation patterns and supports the mechanistic rationale for the combined effect. Finally, the potential carbon isotopic fractionation resulting from natural gas transport in/through porous media and its geological implications are discussed in several hypothetical scenarios combining numerical simulations. These findings highlight the limitations of carbon isotopic parameters for determining the origin and maturity of natural gas, and underscore their potential in identifying greenhouse gas leaks and tracing sources.

Keywords

Natural gas / Carbon isotope fractionation / Mass transport / Numerical modeling / Combined effect

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Wenbiao Li: Conceptualization, Investigation, Methodology, Software, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. Jun Wang: Investigation, Software. Chengzao Jia: Funding acquisition, Supervision. Shuangfang Lu: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Project administration, Supervision, Writing – review & editing. Junqian Li: Methodology, Resources, Supervision. Pengfei Zhang: Investigation, Validation. Yongbo Wei: Investigation. Zhaojing Song: Investigation. Guohui Chen: Investigation. Nengwu Zhou: Investigation.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

This work was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 42302170, 42302160), the Innovation Platform for Academicians of Hainan Province (YSPTZX202301), the National Postdoctoral Innovative Talent Support Program (Grant No. BX20220062), the National Science Foundation of Heilongjiang Province of China (Grant No. YQ2023D001), the Project of Sanya Yazhou Bay Science and Technology City (Grant No. SCKJ-JYRC-2023-01), CNPC Innovation Found (Grant No. 2022DQ02-0104).

References

[1] E. Barth-Naftilan, J. Sohng, J.E. Saiers. Methane in groundwater before, during, and after hydraulic fracturing of the Marcellus Shale. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A, 115 (2018), pp. 6970-6975,

[2] Bernard, B., Brooks, J.M., Sackett, W.M., 1977. A Geochemical Model For Characterization Of Hydrocarbon Gas Sources In Marine Sediments. Offshore Technology Conference, May 1-4, OTC-2934-MS. https://doi.org/10.4043/2934-MS.

[3] U. Berner, E. Faber, G. Scheeder, D. Panten. Primary cracking of algal and landplant kerogens: Kinetic models of isotope variations in methane, ethane and propane. Chem. Geol., 126 (1995), pp. 233-245,

[4] G. Cao, H. Zhang, W. Jiang, S. Wu, D. Zhu, M. Lin. A new gas-content-evaluation method for organic-rich shale using the fractionation of carbon isotopes of methane. SPE J., 24 (2019), pp. 2574-2589,

[5] A. Chen, J. Li. Study of geochemical indicators of natural gas migration. Nat. Gas Geosci., 24 (1994), pp. 38-67

[6] J. Chen, X. Wang, J. Chen, Y. Ni, B. Xiang, F. Liao, W. He, L. Yao, E. Li. New equation to decipher the relationship between carbon isotopic composition of methane and maturity of gas source rocks. Sci. China Earth Sci., 64 (2021), pp. 470-493,

[7] I. Clark, P. Fritz. Environmental Isotopes in Hydrogeology. CRC Press (1997)

[8] J. Crank. The Mathematics of Diffusion. (2nd ed.), Oxford University Press, Ely House, London W. I (1975)

[9] X. Cui, A.M.M. Bustin, R.M. Bustin. Measurements of gas permeability and diffusivity of tight reservoir rocks: different approaches and their applications. Geofluids, 9 (2009), pp. 208-223,

[10] J. Dai. Identification of various alkane gases. Sci. China (Series B), 2 (1992), pp. 185-193

[11] J. Dai, H. Qi. The δ13C-R0 relationship of coal-forming hydrocarbon gas in China. Sci. Bull., 9 (1989), pp. 690-692

[12] Z. Ding, W. Liu, Y. Zhou, K. Zhao. Study on water environment supervision experience of shale gas development in the United States. Environ. Protect. Oil Gas Fields, 24 (4–8) (2013), p. 78

[13] A. Feitz, C. Jenkins, U. Schacht, A. McGrath, H. Berko, I. Schroder, R. Noble, T. Kuske, S. George, C. Heath, S. Zegelin, S. Curnow, H. Zhang, X. Sirault, J. Jimenez-Berni, A. Hortle. An assessment of near surface CO2 leakage detection techniques under Australian conditions. Energy Procedia, 63 (2014), pp. 3891-3906,

[14] X. Feng, B. Yuan, Y. Li, C. Zhang, L. Song. Distribution of helium resources in Weihe Basin, Central China: Insight from 3D magnetic inversion. J. Earth Sci., 33 (2022), pp. 977-992,

[15] A.N. Fuex. The use of stable carbon isotopes in hydrocarbon exploration. J. Geochem. Explor., 7 (1977), pp. 155-188,

[16] A.N. Fuex. Experimental evidence against an appreciable isotopic fractionation of methane during migration. Phys. Chem. Earth, 12 (1980), pp. 725-732,

[17] L. Gao, S. Wu, A. Deev, R.K. Olson, F. Mosca, S. Zhang, Y. Ni, Q. Qu, R. Lafollette, G. Chen, Y. Tang. The gas isotope interpretation tool: A novel method to better predict production decline. AAPG Bull., 101 (2017), pp. 1263-1275,

[18] J.R. Gat. Oxygen and hydrogen isotopes in the hydrologic cycle. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci., 24 (1996), pp. 225-262,

[19] R. Gholami, A. Raza, S. Iglauer. Leakage risk assessment of a CO2 storage site: A review. Earth-Sci. Rev., 223 (2021), Article 103849,

[20] B.D. Gunter, J.D. Gleason. Isotope fractionation during gas chromatographic separations. J. Chromatogr. Sci., 9 (1971), pp. 191-192,

[21] J.S. Harkness, T.H. Darrah, N.R. Warner, C.J. Whyte, M.T. Moore, R. Millot, W. Kloppmann, R.B. Jackson, A. Vengosh. The geochemistry of naturally occurring methane and saline groundwater in an area of unconventional shale gas development. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 208 (2017), pp. 302-334,

[22] S. Iglauer. Optimum storage depths for structural CO2 trapping. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control, 77 (2018), pp. 82-87,

[23] A.T. James. Correlation of natural gas by use of carbon isotopic distribution between hydrocarbon components. AAPG Bull., 67 (1983), pp. 1176-1191,

[24] C. Kendall, E.A. Caldwell. Chapter 2 - Fundamentals of Isotope Geochemistry. C. Kendall, J.J. McDonnell (Eds.), Isotope Tracers in Catchment Hydrology, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1998), pp. 51-86

[25] T.E. Larson, D.O. Breecker. Adsorption isotope effects for carbon dioxide from illite- and quartz-packed column experiments. Chem. Geol., 370 (2014), pp. 58-68,

[26] W. Li, S. Lu, J. Li, P. Zhang, S. Wang, W. Feng, Y. Wei. Carbon isotope fractionation during shale gas transport: Mechanism, characterization and significance. Sci. China Earth Sci., 63 (2020), pp. 674-689,

[27] W. Li, S. Lu, J. Li, Y. Wei, W. Feng, P. Zhang, Z. Song. Geochemical modeling of carbon isotope fractionation during methane transport in tight sedimentary rocks. Chem. Geol., 566 (2021), Article 120033,

[28] X. Li, S. Lu, S. Liu, J. Li, X. Pang, W. Li, J. Wang. Determination of shale gas-bearing properties based on carbon isotope fractionation model: A case study from Longmaxi Formation shales in Jiaoshiba Area, Sichuan Basin, China. Energy Fuels, 37 (2023), pp. 11055-11066,

[29] Liebscher, A., M¨oller, F., Bannach, A., K¨ohler, S., Wiebach, J., Schmidt-Hattenberger, C., Weiner, M., Pretschner, C., Ebert, K., Zemke, J., 2013. Injection operation and operational pressure–temperature monitoring at the CO2 storage pilot site Ketzin, Germany—design, results, recommendations. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control 15, 163–173. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijggc.2013.02.019.

[30] M.C. Long, B.B. Stephens, K. McKain, C. Sweeney, R.F. Keeling, E.A. Kort, E.J. Morgan, J.D. Bent, N. Chandra, F. Chevallier, R. Commane, B.C. Daube, P.B. Krummel, Z. Loh, I.T. Luijkx, D. Munro, P. Patra, W. Peters, M. Ramonet, C. Rödenbeck, A. Stavert, P. Tans, S.C. Wofsy. Strong Southern Ocean carbon uptake evident in airborne observations. Science, 374 (2021), pp. 1275-1280,

[31] J.-P. Nicot, P. Mickler, T. Larson, M. Clara Castro, R. Darvari, K. Uhlman, R. Costley. Methane occurrences in aquifers overlying the Barnett Shale play with a focus on Parker County, Texas. Groundwater, 55 (2017), pp. 469-481,

[32] H. Nie, C. Sun, P. Li, Z. Jin, Q. Liu, H. Bao, B. Shen, W. Dang. Carbon isotope evidence for shale gas preservation conditions and large methane release over million years: A case study of shale gas reservoirs of Wufeng and Longmaxi Formations in the Sichuan Basin. Geosci. Front., 14 (2023), Article 101642,

[33] M. Niemann, M.J. Whiticar. Stable isotope systematics of coalbed gas during desorption and production. Geosciences, 7 (2017), p. 43,

[34] S.G. Osborn, A. Vengosh, N.R. Warner, R.B. Jackson. Methane contamination of drinking water accompanying gas-well drilling and hydraulic fracturing. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 108 (2011), pp. 8172-8176,

[35] A.A. Prinzhofer, A.Y. Huc. Genetic and post-genetic molecular and isotopic fractionations in natural gases. Chem. Geol., 126 (1995), pp. 281-290,

[36] Raza, A., Gholami, R., 2019. Introduction to carbon dioxide capture and storage. In: Inamuddin, Asiri, A.M., Lichtfouse, E. (Eds.), Sustainable Agriculture Reviews 37: Carbon Sequestration Vol. 1 Introduction and Biochemical Methods. Springer International Publishing, Cham, pp. 1–11.

[37] R.H. Reitsema, A.J. Kaltenback, F.A. Lindberg. Source and migration of light hydrocarbons indicated by carbon isotopic ratios. AAPG Bull., 65 (1981), pp. 1536-1542,

[38] A.L. Rice, C.L. Butenhoff, D.G. Teama, F.H. Röger, M.A.K. Khalil, R.A. Rasmussen. Atmospheric methane isotopic record favors fossil sources flat in 1980s and 1990s with recent increase. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 113 (2016), pp. 10791-10796,

[39] M.A. Rooney, G.E. Claypool, H. Moses Chung. Modeling thermogenic gas generation using carbon isotope ratios of natural gas hydrocarbons. Chem. Geol., 126 (1995), pp. 219-232,

[40] S. Schloemer, B.M. Krooss. Molecular transport of methane, ethane and nitrogen and the influence of diffusion on the chemical and isotopic composition of natural gas accumulations. Geofluids, 4 (2004), pp. 81-108,

[41] M. Schoell. The hydrogen and carbon isotopic composition of methane from natural gases of various origins. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 44 (1980), pp. 649-661,

[42] M. Schoell. Genetic characterization of natural gases. AAPG Bull., 67 (1983), pp. 2225-2238,

[43] T.T. Schowalter. Schowalter mechanics of secondary hydrocarbon migration and entrapment. AAPG Bull., 63 (1979), pp. 723-760,

[44] L.H. Spangler, L.M. Dobeck, K.S. Repasky, A.R. Nehrir, S.D. Humphries, J.L. Barr, C.J. Keith, J.A. Shaw, J.H. Rouse, A.B. Cunningham, S.M. Benson, C.M. Oldenburg, J.L. Lewicki, A.W. Wells, J.R. Diehl, B.R. Strazisar, J.E. Fessenden, T.A. Rahn, J.E. Amonette, J.L. Barr, W.L. Pickles, J.D. Jacobson, E.A. Silver, E.J. Male, H.W. Rauch, K.S. Gullickson, R. Trautz, Y. Kharaka, J. Birkholzer, L. Wielopolski. A shallow subsurface controlled release facility in Bozeman, Montana, USA, for testing near surface CO2 detection techniques and transport models. Environ. Earth Sci., 60 (2010), pp. 227-239,

[45] Stahl. Carbon isotope fractionations in natural gases. Nature, 251 (1974), pp. 134-135,

[46] D. Strąpoc, A. Schimmelmann, M. Mastalerz. Carbon isotopic fractionation of CH4 and CO2 during canister desorption of coal. Org. Geochem., 37 (2006), pp. 152-164,

[47] C. Tao, J. Wang, B. Shen, L. Yu, H. Yang. Experimental study on carbon isotopic fractionation of methane flow. Natural Gas Geoscience, 32 (2021), pp. 1709-1713

[48] Y. Wang, J. Chen, X. Pang, B. Zhang, Y. Wang, L. He, Z. Chen, G. Zhang. Anomalies of natural gas compositions and carbon isotope ratios caused by gas diffusion – A case from the Donghe Sandstone reservoir in the Hadexun Oilfield, Tarim Basin, northwest China. J. Asian Earth Sci., 156 (2018), pp. 75-89,

[49] X. Wang, P. Liu, Q. Meng, P. Weniger, W. Liu. Physical selectivity on isotopologues of gaseous alkanes by shale pore network: Evidence from dynamic adsorption process of natural gas. J. Nat. Gas Sci. Eng., 97 (2022), Article 104252,

[50] X. Wang, P. Liu, W. Liu, C. Liu, Y. Lin, D. Zhang. Intramolecular carbon isotope of propane from coal-derived gas reservoirs of sedimentary basins: Implications for source, generation and post-generation of hydrocarbons. Geosci. Front., 15 (4) (2024), Article 101806,

[51] G. Wang, Y. Ma, Y. Zhao, W. Chen. Carbon isotope fractionation during shale gas transport through organic and inorganic nanopores from molecular simulations. Energy Fuels, 35 (2021), pp. 11992-12004,

[52] T. Wang, S. Yang, S. Duan, H. Chen, H. Liu, J. Cao. Multi-stage primary and secondary hydrocarbon migration and accumulation in lacustrine Jurassic petroleum systems in the northern Qaidam Basin, NW China. Mar. Pet. Geol., 62 (2015), pp. 90-101,

[53] Y. Wei, S. Lu, J. Li, R. Yu, W. Li, F. Cheng, C. Fu, T. Zhao, W. Feng, Z. Song. Impacts of gas pressure on carbon isotope fractionation during methane degassing—An experimental study on shales from Wufeng and Longmaxi Formations in southeast Sichuan, China. Mar. Pet. Geol., 128 (2021), Article 105001,

[54] M.J. Whiticar. Carbon and hydrogen isotope systematics of bacterial formation and oxidation of methane. Chem. Geol., 161 (1999), pp. 291-314,

[55] X. Xia, Y. Tang. Isotope fractionation of methane during natural gas flow with coupled diffusion and adsorption/desorption. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 77 (2012), pp. 489-503,

[56] H. Xu, J. Li, X. Luo, M. Cheng, C. Li, X. Zhang, H. Pan. A new method of the hydrocarbon secondary migration research: Numerical simulation. Mar. Pet. Geol., 160 (2024), Article 106656,

[57] S. You, Q. Guo, S. Wu, X. Chen, Z. Deng, Y. Wu. Review of environmental factors of shale gas development. China Mining Magazine, 53–57 (2015), p. 72

[58] T. Zhang, B.M. Krooss. Experimental investigation on the carbon isotope fractionation of methane during gas migration by diffusion through sedimentary rocks at elevated temperature and pressure. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 65 (2001), pp. 2723-2742,

[59] K. Zhang, Z. Meng, X. Wang. Distribution of methane carbon isotope and its significance on CBM accumulation of No.2 coal seam in Yanchuannan CBM block, Ordos Basin, China. J. Pet. Sci. Eng., 174 (2019), pp. 92-105,

[60] W. Zhang, B. Shen, Y. Chen, T. Wang, W. Chen. Molecular dynamics simulations about isotope fractionation of methane in shale nanopores. Fuel, 278 (2020), Article 118378,

[61] S. Zhao, S. Kang, M. Zheng, S. Lu, Y. Yang, H. Zhang, Y. Liu, Z. Xia, C. Zhang, H. Hu, D. Zhu. Prediction of decline in shale gas well production using stable carbon isotope technique. Front. Earth Sci., 15 (2021), pp. 849-859,