Adoption of green finance and green innovation for achieving circularity: An exploratory review and future directions

Abstract

There is growing attention from governments and regulators towards crucial matters such as climate change and global warming, resulting in a pressing need to investigate the factors that make it possible for businesses to engage in green finance (GF). The externality of environmental pollution prioritizes the need of green innovation (GI) in public management. GF distributes financial resources to the research and development (R&D) of clean energy and environmentally friendly goods and processes; it is complementary to the GI process for environmental protection. GF policies help to alleviate the impacts of financial constraints and GI impaired industries involving new products, processes, services and the global market. To better understand how GF and GI have functioned as a catalyst for circular economy practices, this paper seeks to present a historical and contemporary overview of these concepts. The research is thoroughly dissected by a systematic literature evaluation of articles from 2016 to 2023 that appear in peer-reviewed journals and are indexed in the SCOPUS database. To attain supply chain circularity, this article encompasses four major research themes concerning the adoption of GF and green technologies. The research also includes a network analysis of shortlisted articles to examine the overall citation trends. It is shown that several institutional theories are associated with the investigated area. As a final step, a framework is provided to illustrate how GF and GIs might be used to achieve supply chain circularity. The research findings provide a novel concept related to GF within the context of GI which are significant for environmentalists, policymakers, green investors, and researchers. Through its findings, the study provides a conceptual framework that promotes sustainable strategies to effectively balance financial considerations and environmental innovation. It helps to leverage the potential of green research and practice to create value for businesses and to benefit society at large. The analysis provides an unexplored and significant contribution to current literature in terms of delivering evidence of the past and present approaches to GF and GI in a circular economy. The results of this study will attract the attention of policymakers and stakeholders to develop and combine the two concepts in research and practice to attain environmental balance in the circular economy and to promote long term sustainability.

Keywords

Green finance / Green innovation / Systematic literature review / Environmental protection / Climate change

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Rohit Agrawal: Formal analysis, Methodology, Writing – original draft. Shruti Agrawal: Methodology, Investigation, Writing – original draft. Ashutosh Samadhiya: Data curation, Writing – review & editing. Anil Kumar: Writing – review & editing, Supervision. Sunil Luthra: Visualization, Validation. Vranda Jain: Conceptualization, Supervision.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

References

[1] M.E. Abdalazeem, H. Hassan, T. Asawa, H. Mahmoud. Review on integrated photovoltaic-green roof solutions on urban and energy-efficient buildings in hot climate. Sustain. Cities Soc., 82 (2022), Article 103919,

[2] I.S.K. Acquah, C. Baah, Y. Agyabeng-Mensah, E. Afum. Green procurement and green innovation for green organizational legitimacy and access to green finance: The mediating role of total quality management. Glob. Bus. Organ. Excell., 42 (3) (2023), pp. 24-41,

[3] R. Agrawal, V. Surendra Yadav, A. Majumdar, A. Kumar, S. Luthra, J. Arturo Garza-Reyes. Opportunities for disruptive digital technologies to ensure circularity in supply Chain: A critical review of drivers, barriers and challenges. Comput. Ind. Eng., 178 (2023), Article 109140,

[4] G. Aid, M. Eklund, S. Anderberg, L. Baas. Expanding roles for the Swedish waste management sector in inter-organizational resource management. Resour. Conserv. Recycl., 124 (2017), pp. 85-97,

[5] D.C. Andersen. Do credit constraints favor dirty production? Theory and plant-level evidence. J. Environ. Econ. Manag., 84 (2017), pp. 189-208,

[6] M.F. Anjos, F. Feijoo, S. Sankaranarayanan. A multinational carbon-credit market integrating distinct national carbon allowance strategies. Appl. Energy, 319 (2022), Article 119181,

[7] D. Azhgaliyeva, A. Kapoor, Y. Liu. Green bonds for financing renewable energy and energy efficiency in South-East Asia: a review of policies. J. Sustain. Finance Invest., 10 (2) (2020), pp. 113-140,

[8] B. Bharadwaj, R.K. Rai, M. Nepal. Sustainable financing for municipal solid waste management in Nepal. PLoS One, 15 (8) (2020), p. e0231933

[9] M. Bhatnagar, S. Taneja, E. Özen. A wave of green start-ups in India—The study of green finance as a support system for sustainable entrepreneurship. Green Finance, 4 (2) (2022), pp. 253-273,

[10] C. Camarasa, C. Nägeli, Y. Ostermeyer, M. Klippel, S. Botzler. Diffusion of energy efficiency technologies in European residential buildings: A bibliometric analysis. Energ. Build., 202 (2019), Article 109339,

[11] E. Campiglio. Beyond carbon pricing: The role of banking and monetary policy in financing the transition to a low-carbon economy. Ecol. Econ., 121 (2016), pp. 220-230,

[12] S. Çetin, C. de Wolf, N. Bocken. Circular digital built environment: An emerging framework. Sustainability, 13 (11) (2021), p. 6348,

[13] C.J. Chiappetta Jabbour, S. Seuring, L. de Sousa, A.B. Jabbour, D. Jugend, P. de Camargo Fiorini, H. Latan, W.C. Izeppi. Stakeholders, innovative business models for the circular economy and sustainable performance of firms in an emerging economy facing institutional voids. J. Environ. Manage., 264 (2020), Article 110416,

[14] F. Chien, Q.-T. Ngo, C.-C. Hsu, K.Y. Chau, R. Iram. Assessing the mechanism of barriers towards green finance and public spending in small and medium enterprises from developed countries. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 28 (43) (2021), pp. 60495-60510,

[15] H. Cui, R. Wang, H. Wang. An evolutionary analysis of green finance sustainability based on multi-agent game. J. Clean. Prod., 269 (2020), Article 121799,

[16] A. Dehnokhalaji, M. Ghiyasi, P. Korhonen. Resource allocation based on cost efficiency. J. Oper. Res. Soc., 68 (10) (2017), pp. 1279-1289,

[17] K.S. Dhayal, A.K. Giri, L. Esposito, S. Agrawal. Mapping the significance of green venture capital for sustainable development: A systematic review and future research agenda. J. Clean. Prod., 396 (2023), Article 136489,

[18] G. Di Foggia. Energy efficiency measures in buildings for achieving sustainable development goals. Heliyon, 4 (11) (2018), p. e00953

[19] S. Dikau, U. Volz. Central bank mandates, sustainability objectives and the promotion of green finance. Ecol. Econ., 184 (2021), Article 107022,

[20] N. Donthu, S. Kumar, D. Mukherjee, N. Pandey, W.M. Lim. How to conduct a bibliometric analysis: An overview and guidelines. J. Bus. Res., 133 (2021), pp. 285-296,

[21] G. Dorfleitner, D. Braun. Fintech, Digitalization and Blockchain: Possible Applications for Green Finance. The Rise of Green Finance in Europe. Springer Nature (2019), pp. 207-237,

[22] Dörry, S., & Schulz, C. (2018). Green financing, interrupted. Potential directions for sustainable finance in Luxembourg. 23(7), 717–733.

[23] N. Epicoco, M. Falagario. Decision support tools for developing sustainable transportation systems in the EU: A review of research needs, barriers, and trends. Res. Transp. Bus. Manag., 43 (2022), Article 100819,

[24] F. Fahim, B. Mahadi. Green supply chain management/green finance: a bibliometric analysis of the last twenty years by using the Scopus database. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 29 (56) (2022), pp. 84714-84740,

[25] S. Fatica, R. Panzica. Green bonds as a tool against climate change?. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 30 (5) (2021), pp. 2688-2701,

[26] Y. Feng, K. Lai, Q. Zhu. Green supply chain innovation: Emergence, adoption, and challenges. Int. J. Prod. Econ., 248 (2022), Article 108497,

[27] D. Gao, Y. Li, G. Li. Boosting the green total factor energy efficiency in urban China: Does low-carbon city policy matter?. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 29 (37) (2022), pp. 56341-56356,

[28] J. García-Quevedo, E. Jové-Llopis, E. Martínez-Ros. Barriers to the circular economy in European small and medium-sized firms. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 29 (6) (2020), pp. 2450-2464,

[29] S. Gawusu, X. Zhang, A. Ahmed, S.A. Jamatutu, E.D. Miensah, A.A. Amadu, F.A.J. Osei. Renewable energy sources from the perspective of blockchain integration: From theory to application. Sustainable Energy Technol. Assess., 52 (2022), Article 102108,

[30] V.V. Gedam, R.D. Raut, Lopes de Sousa, A.B. Jabbour, A.N. Tanksale, B.E. Narkhede. Circular economy practices in a developing economy: Barriers to be defeated. J. Clean. Prod., 311 (2021), Article 127670,

[31] M. Geissdoerfer, S.N. Morioka, M.M. de Carvalho, S. Evans. Business models and supply chains for the circular economy. J. Clean. Prod., 190 (2018), pp. 712-721,

[32] D. Gielen, F. Boshell, D. Saygin, M.D. Bazilian, N. Wagner, R. Gorini. The role of renewable energy in the global energy transformation. Energ. Strat. Rev., 24 (2019), pp. 38-50,

[33] K. Govindan, P.C. Jha, K. Garg. Product recovery optimization in closed-loop supply chain to improve sustainability in manufacturing. Int. J. Prod. Res., 54 (5) (2016), pp. 1463-1486,

[34] E. Guldmann, R.D. Huulgaard. Barriers to circular business model innovation: A multiple-case study. J. Clean. Prod., 243 (2020), Article 118160,

[35] J.N. Hernandez-Aguilera, M.I. Gómez, A.D. Rodewald, X. Rueda, C. Anunu, R. Bennett, H.M. van Es. Quality as a driver of sustainable agricultural value chains: The case of the relationship coffee model. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 27 (2) (2018), pp. 179-198,

[36] C.-C. Hsu, K.-C. Tan, S.H. Mohamad Zailani. Strategic orientations, sustainable supply chain initiatives, and reverse logistics. Int. J. Oper. Prod. Manag., 36 (1) (2016), pp. 86-110,

[37] H. Huang, W. Mbanyele, F. Wang, M. Song, Y. Wang. Climbing the quality ladder of green innovation: Does green finance matter?. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang., 184 (2022), Article 122007,

[38] R.L. Ibrahim, I. Ozturk, M.A.S. Al-Faryan, U. Al-Mulali. Exploring the nexuses of disintegrated energy consumption, structural change, and financial development on environmental sustainability in BRICS: Modulating roles of green innovations and regulatory quality. Sustainable Energy Technol. Assess., 53 (2022), Article 102529,

[39] M. Irfan, A. Razzaq, A. Sharif, X. Yang. Influence mechanism between green finance and green innovation: Exploring regional policy intervention effects in China. Technol. Forecast. Soc. Chang., 182 (2022), Article 121882,

[40] J. Jesic, A. Okanovic, A.A. Panic. Net zero 2050 as an EU priroty: modeling a system for efficient investments in eco innovation for climate change mitigation. Energy Sustainab. Soc., 11 (1) (2021), p. 50,

[41] L. Jinru, Z. Changbiao, B. Ahmad, M. Irfan, R. Nazir. How do green financing and green logistics affect the circular economy in the pandemic situation: key mediating role of sustainable production. Economic Res.-Ekonomska Istraživanja, 35 (1) (2021), pp. 3836-3856,

[42] P.A. Khan, S.K. Johl, A. Kumar, S. Luthra. Hope-hype of green innovation, corporate governance index, and impact on firm financial performance: a comparative study of Southeast Asian countries. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 30 (19) (2023), pp. 55237-55254,

[43] N. Khan, R.L. Ray, H.S. Kassem, S. Zhang. Mobile internet technology adoption for sustainable agriculture: evidence from wheat farmers. Appl. Sci., 12 (10) (2022), p. 4902,

[44] G. Lăzăroiu, L. Ionescu, C. Uță, I. Hurloiu, M. Andronie, I. Dijmărescu. Environmentally responsible behavior and sustainability policy adoption in green public procurement. Sustainability, 12 (5) (2020), p. 2110,

[45] E. Leising, J. Quist, N. Bocken. Circular Economy in the building sector: Three cases and a collaboration tool. J. Clean. Prod., 176 (2018), pp. 976-989,

[46] L. Li, H. Msaad, H. Sun, M.X. Tan, Y. Lu, A.K.W. Lau. Green innovation and business sustainability: new evidence from energy intensive industry in China. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 17 (21) (2020), p. 7826,

[47] L. Liu, Q. Peng. Evolutionary game analysis of enterprise green innovation and green financing in platform supply chain. Sustainability, 14 (13) (2022), p. 7807,

[48] H. Liu, P. Yao, S. Latif, S. Aslam, N. Iqbal. Impact of Green financing, FinTech, and financial inclusion on energy efficiency. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 29 (13) (2022), pp. 18955-18966,

[49] W. Lu, L. Du, V.W.Y. Tam, Z. Yang, C. Lin, C. Peng. Evolutionary game strategy of stakeholders under the sustainable and innovative business model: A case study of green building. J. Clean. Prod., 333 (2022), Article 130136,

[50] S.K. Mangla, S. Luthra, S. Jakhar, S. Gandhi, K. Muduli, A. Kumar. A step to clean energy - Sustainability in energy system management in an emerging economy context. J. Clean. Prod., 242 (2020), Article 118462,

[51] Mankata, L. M., Owusu-Manu, D. G., Hosseini, M. R., & Edwards, D. J. (2020). Analysis of success-dependent factors for green bond financing of infrastructure projects in Ghana. 12(3), 832–848.

[52] W. Mengist, T. Soromessa, G. Legese. Method for conducting systematic literature review and meta-analysis for environmental science research. MethodsX, 7 (2020), Article 100777,

[53] J. Miemczyk, M. Howard, T.E. Johnsen. Dynamic development and execution of closed-loop supply chains: a natural resource-based view. Suppl. Chain Manage. Internat. J., 21 (4) (2016), pp. 453-469,

[54] A.A. Mir, A.A. Bhat. Green banking and sustainability – a review. Arab Gulf J. Sci. Res., 40 (3) (2022), pp. 247-263,

[55] S.B. Moore, S.L. Manring. Strategy development in small and medium sized enterprises for sustainability and increased value creation. J. Clean. Prod., 17 (2) (2009), pp. 276-282,

[56] G.E. Mushi, G. di Marzo Serugendo, P.-Y. Burgi. Digital Technology and Services for Sustainable Agriculture in Tanzania: A Literature Review. Sustainability, 14 (4) (2022), p. 2415,

[57] G. Mutezo, J. Mulopo. A review of Africa’s transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy using circular economy principles. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 137 (2021), Article 110609,

[58] A.W. Ng. From sustainability accounting to a green financing system: Institutional legitimacy and market heterogeneity in a global financial centre. J. Clean. Prod., 195 (2018), pp. 585-592,

[59] S.R. Paramati, U. Shahzad, B. Doğan. The role of environmental technology for energy demand and energy efficiency: Evidence from OECD countries. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 153 (2022), Article 111735,

[60] H. Peng, N. Shen, H. Ying, Q. Wang. Can environmental regulation directly promote green innovation behavior?—— based on situation of industrial agglomeration. J. Clean. Prod., 314 (2021), Article 128044,

[61] M.P.P. Pieroni, T.C. McAloone, D.C.A. Pigosso. Business model innovation for circular economy and sustainability: A review of approaches. J. Clean. Prod., 215 (2019), pp. 198-216,

[62] F. Polzin, M. Sanders. How to finance the transition to low-carbon energy in Europe?. Energy Policy, 147 (2020), Article 111863,

[63] T. Qin, L. Wang, Y. Zhou, L. Guo, G. Jiang, L. Zhang. Digital Technology-and-Services-Driven Sustainable Transformation of Agriculture: Cases of China and the EU. Agriculture, 12 (2) (2022), p. 297,

[64] G. Ray, J.B. Barney, W.A. Muhanna. Capabilities, business processes, and competitive advantage: choosing the dependent variable in empirical tests of the resource-based view. Strateg. Manag. J., 25 (1) (2004), pp. 23-37,

[65] K. Rennings. Redefining innovation — eco-innovation research and the contribution from ecological economics. Ecol. Econ., 32 (2) (2000), pp. 319-332,

[66] B.J. Richardson. Climate finance and its governance: moving to a low carbon economy through socially responsible financing?. Internat. Comp. Law Quart., 58 (3) (2009), pp. 597-626,

[67] V. Rizos, A. Behrens, W. van der Gaast, E. Hofman, A. Ioannou, T. Kafyeke, A. Flamos, R. Rinaldi, S. Papadelis, M. Hirschnitz-Garbers, C. Topi. Implementation of Circular Economy Business Models by Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs): Barriers and Enablers. Sustainability, 8 (11) (2016), p. 1212,

[68] M. Sadiq, M.A. Amayri, C. Paramaiah, N.H. Mai, T.Q. Ngo, T.T.H. Phan. How green finance and financial development promote green economic growth: deployment of clean energy sources in South Asia. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res., 29 (43) (2022), pp. 65521-65534,

[69] S. Sahoo, A. Kumar, A. Upadhyay. How do green knowledge management and green technology innovation impact corporate environmental performance? Understanding the role of green knowledge acquisition. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 32 (1) (2023), pp. 551-569,

[70] F.B. Sawe, A. Kumar, J.A. Garza-Reyes, R. Agrawal. Assessing people-driven factors for circular economy practices in small and medium-sized enterprise supply chains: Business strategies and environmental perspectives. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 30 (7) (2021), pp. 2951-2965,

[71] B.J. Shah, A. Shroff. Inventory model for sustainable operations of fixed-life products: Role of trapezoidal demand and two-level trade credit financing. J. Clean. Prod., 380 (2022), Article 135093,

[72] M. Song, Q. Xie, Z. Shen. Impact of green credit on high-efficiency utilization of energy in China considering environmental constraints. Energy Policy, 153 (2021), Article 112267,

[73] W. Song, H. Yu. Green Innovation Strategy and Green Innovation: The Roles of Green Creativity and Green Organizational Identity. Corp. Soc. Respon. Environ. Manag., 25 (2) (2018), pp. 135-150,

[74] P. Soundarrajan, N. Vivek. Green finance for sustainable green economic growth in India. Agric. Econ. (Zemědělská Ekonomika), 62 (1) (2016), pp. 35-44, 10.17221/174/2014-AGRICECON

[75] T. Tomić, D.R. Schneider. Circular economy in waste management – Socio-economic effect of changes in waste management system structure. J. Environ. Manage., 267 (2020), Article 110564,

[76] Á. Triguero, M.C. Cuerva, F.J. Sáez-Martínez. Closing the loop through eco-innovation by European firms: Circular economy for sustainable development. Bus. Strateg. Environ., 31 (5) (2022), pp. 2337-2350,

[77] M. Vaka, R. Walvekar, A.K. Rasheed, M. Khalid. A review on Malaysia’s solar energy pathway towards carbon-neutral Malaysia beyond Covid’19 pandemic. J. Clean. Prod., 273 (2020), Article 122834,

[78] G. Velvizhi, R. Nair, C. Goswami, S.K. Arumugam, N.P. Shetti, T.M. Aminabhavi. Carbon credit reduction: A techno-economic analysis of “drop-in” fuel production. Environ. Pollut., 316 (2023), Article 120507,

[79] M. Wang, X. Li, S. Wang. Discovering research trends and opportunities of green finance and energy policy: A data-driven scientometric analysis. Energy Policy, 154 (2021), Article 112295,

[80] Y. Wang, Q. Zhi. The Role of Green Finance in Environmental Protection: Two Aspects of Market Mechanism and Policies. Energy Procedia, 104 (2016), pp. 311-316,

[81] F. Welter, D. Smallbone. Institutional Perspectives on Entrepreneurial Behavior in Challenging Environments. J. Small Bus. Manag., 49 (1) (2011), pp. 107-125,

[82] K. Winans, A. Kendall, H. Deng. The history and current applications of the circular economy concept. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 68 (2017), pp. 825-833,

[83] S. Yadav, T.M. Choi, A. Kumar, S. Luthra, F. Naz. A meta-analysis of sustainable supply chain practices and performance: the moderating roles of type of economy and innovation. Int. J. Oper. Prod. Manag., 43 (5) (2023), pp. 802-845,

[84] Y.Cong Yang, P. Yan Nie, J. Bo Huang. The optimal strategies for clean technology to advance green transition. Sci. Total Environ., 716 (2020), Article 134439,

[85] W. Yu, T. Jamasb, M. Pollitt. Willingness-to-pay for quality of service: an application to efficiency analysis of the UK electricity distribution utilities. Energy J., 30 (4) (2009), pp. 1-48,