Potential effects of elevated carbon dioxide on leaf-feeding forest insects

Abstract

The elevated concentration of atmospheric CO₂ may result in a decline of leaf nutritional quality (especially N) and an increase in some kinds of defensive secondary components (such as phenolics). The changes in the phytochemistry of trees, combined with the effect of elevated CO₂ per se, have a potential negative influence on insect herbivores. Here, we review the effect of elevated CO₂ on the performance of leaf-feeding forest insects at individual-level and community-level. The elevated CO₂ per se have little influence on the metabolism of insects. Over half of the tree-insect experimental systems show that the performance of individual insect become poorer under high-CO₂ grown trees; but the others show that the insects have just little or no response to the treatments. The direction and magnitude of the changes in the performance of insects could be mediated by various factors. The effects of treatment are strongly species-dependent. The magnitude of changes in the phytochemistry, the sensitivity and adaptive capacity of insects to the poorer leaf quality, the differences in plant growth conditions and experimental methods, and the mediated effects of other environmental factors (such as soil nutrient availability, light, temperature, O₃) were all closely related to the final performance of insects. However, the larvae’s consumption usually increased under enriched CO₂ treatment, which was widely thought to be a compensatory response to poorer plant quality. The experiments on forest community-level found identically a reduction in herbivory, which was contrary to the results from small-scale experiments. The changes in insect population and the actual response of consumption by leaf-feeding forest insects under CO₂ enrichment remain unclear, and more field-based experiments need to be conducted.

References

1. Agrell J Kopper B McDonald. E P Lindroth. R L 2005 CO₂ and O₃ effects on host plantpreferences of the forest tent caterpillar (Malacosoma disstria)GlobalChange Biology11588599
2. Agrell J McDonald E P Lindroth R L 2000 Effects of CO₂ andlight on tree phytochemistry and insect performanceOikos88259272
3. Bezemer T M Jones T H 1998 Plant-insectherbivore interactions in elevated atmospheric CO₂: quantitative analyses and guild effectsOikos82212222
4. Brooks G L Whittaker J B 1998 Responsesto elevated CO₂ of multiple generations of Gastrophysa viridula feeding on Rumex obtusifoliusGlobal Change Biology46375
5. Bryant J P Chapin F S I I I Klein D R 1983 Carbon/nutrient balance of boreal plantsin relation to vertebrate herbivoryOikos40357368
6. Buse A Good J E D Dury S Perrins C M 1998 Effects of elevated temperature and carbon dioxide on the nutritionalquality of leaves of oak (Quercus robur L.) as food for the winter moth (Operophterabrumata L.).Functional Ecology12742749
7. Ceulemans R Mousseau M 1994 Effects ofelevated atmospheric CO₂ on woody plantsNew Phytologist127425446
8. Chen F J Ge F Liu X H 2004 Responses of cotton to elevated CO₂ and the effects on cotton aphid occurrencesActa Ecologica Sinica24(5)991996 (in Chinese)
9. Chen F J Ge F Parajulee M N 2005 Impact of Elevated CO₂ on Tri-Trophic Interaction of Gossypiumhirsutum, Aphis gossypii, and Leis axyridisEnvironmental Entomology34(1)3746
10. Coviella C Trumble J T 1999 Affects ofelevated atmospheric carbon dioxide on insect-plant interactions:implications for insect conservationConservationBiology13700712
11. Curtis P S Wang X 1998 A meta-analysisof elevated CO₂ effects on woody plant mass,form, and physiologyOecologia113299313
12. Hall M C Stiling P Moon D C Drake B G Hunter M D 2005 Effects of elevated CO₂ on foliar quality and herbivore damage in a scrub oakecosystemJournal of Chemical Ecology31267286
13. Hamilton J G Zangerl A R Berenbaum M R Pippen J Aldea M DeLucia E H 2004 Insect herbivory in an intact forest understory under experimentalCO₂ enrichmentOecologia138566573
14. Hättenschwiler S Schafellner C 1999 Opposing effectsof elevated CO₂ and N deposition on Lymantria monacha larvae feeding on sprucetreesOecologia118210217
15. Hättenschwiler S Schafellner C 2004 Gypsy mothfeeding in the canopy of a CO₂-enriched matureforestGlobal Change Biology1018991908
16. Holton M K Lindroth R L Nordheim E V 2003 Foliar quality influences tree-herbivore-parasitoidinteractions: effects of elevated CO₂, O₃, and plant genotypeOecologia137233244
17. Hunter M D 2001 Effects of elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide on insect-plantinteractionsAgricultural and Forest Entomology3153159
18. IPCC 2001 Climate Change 2001, Synthesis Report: Summary for PolicymakersDownloaded, Jan. 2004: www.ipcc.ch/pub/un/syreng/spm.pdf
19. Jiang G M Qu Ch M 2000 Photosyntheticresponse of six woody species to elevated CO₂ in Quercus Liaotungensis forestin the Beijing Mountainous areasActa PhytoecologicaSinica24(2)204208 (in Chinese)
20. Kinney K K Lindroth R L Jung S M Nordheim E V 1997 Effects of CO₂ and NO₃ availability on deciduous trees, phytochemistry and insect performanceEcology78215230
21. Kopper B J Lindroth R L 2003a Effects ofelevated carbon dioxide and ozone on the phytochemistry of aspen andperformance of an herbivoreOecologia13495103
22. Kopper B J Lindroth R L 2003b Responsesof trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides) phytochemistry and aspen blotch leafminer (Phyllonorycter tremuloidiella) performance to elevatedlevels of atmospheric CO₂ and O₃Agricultural and Forest Entomology51726
23. Korner Ch 2003 Ecological impacts of atmospheric CO₂ enrichment on terrestrial ecosystemsPhilosophicalTransactions of the Royal Society A36120232041
24. Lincoln D E 1993 The influence of plant carbon dioxide and nutrient supplyon susceptibility to insect herbivoresVegetatio104273280
25. Lindroth R L Kinney K K Platz C L 1993 Responses of deciduous trees to elevatedatmospheric CO₂: Productivity,phytochemistry,and insect performanceEcology74763777
26. Lindroth R L Roth S Kruger E L Volin J C Koss P A 1997 CO₂-mediated changes in aspen chemistry: effects on gypsy moth performanceand susceptibility to virusGlobal ChangeBiology3279289
27. Lindroth R L Wood S A Kopper B J 2002 Response of quaking aspen genotypes toenriched CO₂: foliar chemistry and tussockmoth performanceAgricultural and ForestEntomology4315323
28. Lindroth R L 1996 Consequences of elevated atmospheric CO₂ for forest insectsIn: Koch G Wed. Carbon Dioxide and Terrestrial EcosystemsSan DiegoAcademicPress105120
29. Lindroth R L 1996 CO₂-mediated changes in tree chemistryand tree-Lepidoptera interactionsIn: KornerCed. Carbon dioxide, Populations,and CommunitiesSan DiegoAcademic Press347361
30. Lindroth R L Kinney K K 1998 Consequencesof enriched atmospheric CO₂ and defoliationfor foliar chemistry and gypsy moth performanceJournal of Chemical Ecology2416771695
31. Liu S H R Guo Q S H Wang B 1998 The likely impacts of rising atmosphericCO₂ concentration on plants and ecosystemsexamined at different levels of space and timeWorld Forestry Research11(1)2736 (in Chinese)
32. McGuire A D Melillo J M Joyce L A 1995 The role of nitrogen in the response offorest net primary production to elevated atmospheric carbon dioxideAnnual Review of Eecology and Systematics26473503
33. Norby R J Willschleger S D Gunderson C A Johnson D W Ceulemans R 1999 Tree responses to risingCO₂ in field experiments: implications forthe future forestPlant Cell and Environment22683714
34. Peñuelas J Estiarte M 1998 Can elevatedCO₂ affect secondary metabolism and ecosystemfunction?Trends in Ecology & Evolution132024
35. Percy K E Awmack C S Lindroth R L Kubiske M E Kopper B J Isebrands J G Pregitzer K S Hendrey G R Dickson R E Zak D R Oksanen E Sober J Harrington R Karnosky D F 2002 Altered performance of forest pests under atmospheres enriched byCO₂ and O₃Nature420403407
36. Roth S Lindroth R L Volin J C Kruger E L 1998 Enriched atmospheric CO₂ and defoliation:effects on tree chemistry and insect performanceGlobal Change Biology4419430
37. Roth S K Lindroth R L 1994 Effects ofCO₂-mediated changes in paper birch and whitepine chemistry on gypsy moth performanceOecologia98133138
38. Saxon M E Davis M A Pritchard S G Runion G B Prior S A Stelzer H E Rogers H H Dute R R 2004 Influence of elevated CO₂, nitrogen, and Pinus elliottii genotypes on performance of the redheadedpine sawfly, Neodiprion leconteiCanadian Journal of Forest Research3410071017
39. Schowalter T D Hargrove W W Crossley D A 1986 Herbivory in forested ecosystemsAnnual Review of Entomology3117796
40. Scriber J M Slansky F J r 1981 The nutritionalecology of immature insectsAnnual Reviewof Entomology26183211
41. Stiling P Cattell M Moon D C Rossi A Hungate B A Hymus G Drake B 2002 Elevated atmosphericCO₂ lowers herbivore abundance, but increasesleaf abscission ratesGlobal Change Biology8658667
42. Stiling P Moon D C Hunter M D Colson J Rossi A M Hymus G J Drake B G 2003 Elevated CO₂ lowers relative and absolute herbivore density acrossall species of a scrub oak forestOecologia1348287
43. Strain B R 1991 Available Technologies for Field Experimentation with ElevatedCO₂ in Global Change ResearchIn: Mooney H Aed. Ecosystem ExperimentsWileyU.K.
44. Traw M B Lindroth R L Bazzaz F A 1996 Decline in gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar) performance on an elevatedCO₂ atmosphere depends upon host plant speciesOecologia108113120
45. Veteli T O Kuokkanen K Julkunen-Tiitto R Roininen H Tahvanainen J 2002 Effects ofelevated CO₂ and temperature on plant growthand herbivore defensive chemistryGlobalChange Biology812401252
46. Watt A D Whittaker J B Docherty M Brooks G Lindsay E Salt D T 1995 The impact of elevated atmospheric CO₂ on insect herbivoresIn: Harrington Red. Insects in a Changing EnvironmentAcademicNew York197217
47. Williams R S Lincoln D E Norby R J 1998 Leaf age effects of elevated CO₂-grown white oak leaves on spring-feeding lepidopteransGlobal Change Biology4235246
48. Williams R S Lincoln D E Norby R J 2003 Development of gypsy moth larvae feedingon red maple saplings at elevated CO₂ and temperatureOecologia137114122
49. Williams R S Lincoln D E Thomas R B 1994 Loblolly pine grown under elevated CO₂ affects early instar pine sawfly performanceOecologia986471
50. Williams R S Norby R J Lincoln D E 2000 Effects of elevated CO₂ and temperature-grown red and sugar maple on gypsy moth performanceGlobal Change Biology6685695
51. Wu Y Jin C X 1993 Carbon dioxideand the insectEntomology Knowledge30(5)314317 (in Chinese)
52. Zhang J Liu J Wang G X Wang Y F 2001 Effect of elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrationon Rhopalsiphum padi populationunder different soil water levelsChineseJournal of Applied Ecology12(2)253256 (in Chinese)