Causations of failure in megaprojects: A case study of the Ajaokuta Steel Plant project

Abstract

This paper uses project organizational theories to draw lessons from a historic megaproject, the Ajaokuta Steel Plant (ASP). Archival reports on the ASP were explored to identify the unique attributes of the project; the political wrangling that underplayed its evolution, its economic significance and organizational impacts. Findings suggest the goals of the ASP project were, and still are, unambiguous. Failure occurred as socio-political forces aggravated the project’s complex milestones. Stakeholders were impatient with pre-project investigations. During planning, owners ignored opinions that were contrary to their expectations. While delays lingered, pressures from the global economy weakened the project’s motivation to succeed. These combined to turn the project’s outcomes into a chaotic situation that triggered dire implications. Despite about 1400% overrun in cost, the success achieved on the plant was 28% at commissioning. Contractors remained on site until eight years after commissioning. Six key elements of the 482 items in the ASP project contract were not delivered nearly 40 years on. A simplistic look at these suggests poor planning is the main problem. However, planning issues is not entirely strange in greenfield projects. The paper draws strength from project organization theories to explain what was poor about the planning. Socrates’ generic management theory was used to explain the role of leadership in the failure of the ASP project. McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y explain the significance of stakeholders’ integration in megaprojects. Systems and chaos theories were used to explain the sensitivity of the ASP project to uncertainties. Narratives on these combine well to inspire stakeholders of megaprojects on where and how to seek courage in making effective plans that can help achieve success in complex projects. While normative literature only recognizes project success in a definitive perspective, this study provides insights from failure as an instrument to trigger sublime reflections.

Keywords

industrial projects / megaprojects / Nigeria / project organizational theories / steel plant

References

[1] Abramson L Y, Seligman M E, Teasdale J D (1978). Learned helplessness in humans: Critique and reformulation. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 87(1): 49–74

[2] Adebisi O (1989). The Challenge of independence: Major issue before and after. In: Tamuno, N.T. and Atanda, J.A., eds. Nigeria since Independence in the first 25 years. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books, Nigeria Limited.

[3] Ahmed S M, Kangari R (1995). Analysis of client-satisfaction factors in construction industry. Journal of Management Engineering, 11(2): 36–44

[4] Akeju R (2018). FG needs $652m to reactivate Ajaokuta Steel equipment. http://freedomonline.com.ng/fg-needs-652m-to-reactivate-ajaokuta-steel-equipment/, 2018–6-12

[5] Al-Amin M A (2013). Energy efficiency alternatives in the Ajoakuta Steel Project of Nigeria. International Journal of Advanced Research, 1: 592–599

[6] Andersen E S, Birchall D, Jessen S A, Money A H (2006). Exploring project success. Baltic Journal of Management, 1(2): 127–147

[7] Baccarini D (1996). The concept of project complexity€—€A review. International Journal of Project Management, 14(4): 201–204

[8] Balfour R, Mitchell C, Moletsane R (2008). Troubling contexts: Toward a generative theory of rurality as education research. Journal of Rural and Community Development, 3: 95–107

[9] Baloi D, Price A D F (2003). Modelling global risk factors affecting construction cost performance. International Journal of Project Management, 21(4): 261–269

[10] Barbour K M (1972). Planning for Nigeria: A Geographical Approach. Ibadan: Ibadan University Press

[11] Beazley C (2009). The many sides of optimism. Positive Psychology, United Kingdom

[12] Boehm B (2000). Project termination doesn’t equal project failure. Computer, 33(7): 94–96

[13] Bolden R, Gosling J, Marturano A, Dennison P (2003). Leadership Theory and Competency Frameworks. Exeter: Centre for Leadership Studies

[14] Boyd D, Chinyio E (2006). Understanding the Construction Client. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing

[15] Buckley P J, Casson M (2010). In: Buckley P J, Casson M, eds. The Multinational Enterprise Revisited. Berlin: Springer

[16] Cabrera D, Colosi L, Lobdell C (2008). Systems thinking. Evaluation and Program Planning, 31(3): 299–310

[17] Carver C S, Scheier M F (2014). Dispositional optimism. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 18(6): 293–299

[18] Chan A P C (2001). Framework for Measuring Success of Projects. Cooperative Research Centre for Construction, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia

[19] Checkland P (1999). Systems Thinking, Systems Practice: Includes a 30-Year Retrospective. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons Ltd

[20] Cleland D I (1995). Leadership and the project-management body of knowledge. International Journal of Project Management, 13(2): 83–88

[21] Collins A, Baccarini D (2004). Project success—A survey. Journal of Construction Research, 5(2): 211–231

[22] Cooke-Davies T (2011). In: T. Cooke-Davies, L. Crawford, J. Patton, C. Stevens and T. Williams, eds. Aspects of Complexity: Managing in a Complex World. Newtown Square: Project Management Institute

[23] Crowe S E (1942). The Berlin West African Conference, 1884–1885. New York: Longman

[24] De Meyer A, Loch C H, Pich M T (2002). Managing project uncertainty: From variation to chaos. MIT Sloan Management Review, 43: 60

[25] De Wit A (1988). Measurement of project success. International Journal of Project Management, 6(3): 164–170

[26] Ekeh P P (1975). Colonialism and the two publics in Africa: A theoretical statement. Comparative Studies in Society and History, 17(01): 91–112

[27] Emeriewen K O, Kalilu R O R (2015). Emerging trends in blacksmithing in Benin City, Nigeria. Journal of Science and Technology of the Arts, 7(2): 70–76

[28] Falola T (2004). Economic Reforms and Modernization in Nigeria, 1945–1965. Kent: Kent State University Press

[29] Fiedler (1967). A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness. New York: McGraw-Hill

[30] , Flyvbjerg B, Skramis-Holm M K, Buhl S (2002). Underestimating costs in public works projects: Error or lie? Journal of the American Planning Association, 68(3): 279–295

[31] Flyvbjerg B (2006). From Nobel Prize to project management. Project Management Institute Journal, 37(3): 5–15

[32] Flyvbjerg B (2007). Cost overruns and demand shortfalls in urban rail and other infrastructure. Transportation Planning and Technology, 30: 9–30

[34] Flyvbjerg B (2016). Introduction: The Iron Law of Megaproject Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press

[35] Flyvbjerg B, Garbuio M, Lovallo D (2013). Delusion and deception in large infrastructure projects: Two models for explaining and preventing executive disaster. California Management Review, 51 (2): 170–193

[36] Geraldi J G (2009). Reconciling order and chaos in multi-project firms. International Journal of Managing Projects in Business, 2(1): 149–158

[37] Grandia J (2016). Finding the missing link: Examining the mediating role of sustainable public procurement behaviour. Journal of Cleaner Production, 124: 183–190

[38] Grudinschi D, Sintonen S, Hallikas J (2014). Relationship risk perception and determinants of the collaboration fluency of buyer–supplier relationships in public service procurement. Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 20(2): 82–91

[39] Hersey P, Blanchard K H (1977). Management of Organizational Behaviour. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall

[40] Hobday M (2000). The project-based organisation: An ideal form for managing complex products and systems? Research Policy, 29(7-8): 871–893

[41] Hu Y, Chan A, Le Y (2012). Conceptual framework of program organization for managing construction megaprojects€—€Chinese client’s perspective. In: Proceedings of Engineering Project Organizations Conference. Rheden

[42] Hylighen F, Joslyn C (1995). In: Audi R, eds. Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[43] Isa H, Hassan P, Takim R, Mat M, Ithnin Z (2010). How adequate is adequate? A case of the adequacy in determining client requirements in the construction of four public hospitals in Malaysia. In: Proceedings of W092-Special Track 18th CIB World Building Congress. Salford: 248–261

[44] Jelodar M B, Yiu T W, Wilkinson S (2016). A conceptualisation of relationship quality in construction procurement. International Journal of Project Management, 34(6): 997–1011

[45] Jensen N, Wantchekon L (2004). Resource wealth and political regimes in Africa. Comparative Political Studies, 37(7): 816–841

[46] Jorre J D S (1972). The Nigerian Civil War. London: Hodder and Stoughton Ltd

[47] Kamara J M, Anumba C J, Evbuomwan N F O (2002). Capturing Client Requirements in Construction Projects. London: Thomas Telford Publishing

[48] Kellert S H (1994). In the Wake of Chaos: Unpredictable Order in Dynamical Systems. Chicago: University of Chicago press

[49] Killick D (2004). What do we know about African iron working? Journal of African Archaeology, 2(1): 97–112

[50] Kometa S T, Olomolaiye P O, Harris F C (1995). An evaluation of clients’ needs and responsibilities in the construction process. Engineering, Construction, and Architectural Management, 2(1): 57–76

[51] Lenfle S (2011). The strategy of parallel approaches in projects with unforeseeable uncertainty: The Manhattan case in retrospect. International Journal of Project Management, 29(4): 359–373

[52] Love P E D, Simpson I, Smith J, Regan M, Olatunji O A (2015). Understanding the landscape of overruns in transport infrastructure projects. Environment & Planning B, 42(3): 490–509

[53] Love P E D, Smith J (2016). Toward error management in construction: Moving beyond a zero vision. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 142 (11): 04016058

[54] Lundin R, Soderholm A (1995). A theory of the temporary organization. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 11(4): 437–455

[55] Manning C, Fruehan R (2001). Emerging technologies for iron and steelmaking. Journal of Materials, 53: 36–43

[56] Markus M L, Tanis C (2000). The enterprise systems experience€—€from adoption to success. Framing the Domains of IT Research: Glimpsing the Future through the Past, 173: 207–173

[57] Matusevich M (2003). No Easy Row for a Russian Hoe: Ideology and Pragmatism in Nigerian-Soviet Relations, 1960–1991. Trenton: Africa World Press

[58] McGregor D (1960). The Human Side of Enterprise. New York: McGraw Hill

[59] Mohammad-Hasanzadeh S, Hosseinalipour M, Hafezi M (2014). Collaborative procurement in construction projects performance measures, case study: Partnering in Iranian construction industry. Procedia: Social and Behavioral Sciences, 119: 811–818

[60] Murphy P (1996). Chaos theory as a model for managing issues and crises. Public Relations Review, 22(2): 95–113

[61] Murray P (2003). The Saga of Sydney Opera House: The Dramatic Story of the Design and Construction of the Icon of Modern Australia. London: Routledge

[62] Naoum S, Egbu C (2015). Critical review of procurement method research in construction journals. Procedia Economics and Finance, 21: 6–13

[63] Norem J K (2001). Optimism and Pessimism: Implications for Theory, Research, and Practice. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association

[64] Ogunlana S O (2010). Beyond the ‘iron triangle’: Stakeholder perception of key performance indicators (KPIs) for large-scale public sector development projects. International Journal of Project Management, 28(3): 228–236

[65] Olaniran O J, Love P E D, Edwards D, Olatunji O A, Matthews J (2015). Cost overruns in hydrocarbon megaprojects: A critical review and implications for research. Project Management Journal, 46(6): 126–138

[66] Olaniran O J, Love P E D, Edwards D J, Olatunji O, Matthews J (2017). Chaos theory: Implications for cost overrun research in hydrocarbon megaprojects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 143(2): 05016020

[67] Olatunji O A, Ajayi S O (2017). Rurality, Nigeria’s massification policy on access to basic education and turnover causations amongst teachers. Australian and International Journal of Rural Education, 26: 3–17

[68] Oyeyinka O, Adeloye O (1988). Technological change and project execution: Evolution of Ajaokuta Steel Plant in Nigeria. International Development Research Centre, Canada

[69] Packendorff J (1995). Inquiring into the temporary organization: New directions for project management research. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 11(4): 319–333

[70] Pich M T, Loch C H, Meyer A D (2002). On uncertainty, ambiguity, and complexity in project management. Management Science, 48(8): 1008–1023

[71] Pinto J K, Mantel S J (1990). The causes of project failure. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 37(4): 269–276

[72] Pinto J K, Slevin D P (1988). Project Success: Definitions and Measurement Techniques. Newtown Square: Project Management Institute

[73] Priemus H (2010). Mega-projects: Dealing with pitfalls. European Planning Studies, 18(7): 1023–1039

[74] Pryor R G L, Bright J E H (2007). Applying chaos theory to careers: Attraction and attractors. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 71(3): 375–400

[75] Rausch E, Barber E, Warn J (2005). Leadership in project management: From firefighter to firelighter. Management Decision, 43(7/8): 1032–1039

[76] Reichl L E (2004). The Transition to Chaos. Berlin: Springer

[77] Reigeluth C M (2004). Chaos theory and the sciences of complexity: Foundations for transforming education. In: Proceedings of Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association. San Diego

[78] Relle B, Gilge C (2013). How to successfully manage your mega-project. https://www.kpmg.com/US/en/IssuesAndInsights/ArticlesPublications/Documents/how-to-manage-mega-project.pdf

[79] Robertson R, Combs A (2014). Chaos Theory in Psychology and the Life Sciences. London: Psychology Press

[80] Schuldberg D (2011). In: Runco M A, Pritzker S R, eds. Encyclopedia of Creativity. San Diego: Academic Press

[81] Sellnow T L, Seeger M W, Ulmer R R (2002). Chaos theory, informational needs, and natural disasters. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 30(4): 269–292

[82] Shafritz J, Ott J, Jang Y (2015). Classics of Organization Theory. Boston: Cengage Learning

[83] Shenhar A J, Dvir D (2007). Project management research€—€the challenge and opportunity. Project Management Journal, 38(2): 93–99

[84] Shepherd D A, Patzelt H, Wolfe M (2011). Moving forward from project failure: Negative emotions, affective commitment, and learning from the experience. Academy of Management Journal, 54(6): 1229– 1259

[85] Smith J, Love P E D (2004). Stakeholder management during project inception: Strategic needs analysis. Journal of Architectural Engineering, 10(1): 22–33

[86] Smith W K, Lewis M W (2011). Toward a theory of paradox: A dynamic equilibrium model of organizing. Academy of Management Review, 36: 381–403

[87] Spencer S M, Norem J K (1996). Reflection and distraction defensive pessimism, strategic optimism, and performance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 22(4): 354–365

[88] Tannenbaum R, Schmidt W (1958). How to choose a leadership pattern. Harvard Business Review, 36: 95–101

[89] Turner J R (2008). Handbook of Project-based Management. New York: McGraw-Hill Professional Publishing

[90] Walker D H (1995). An investigation into construction time performance. Construction Management and Economics, 13(3): 263– 274

[91] Williams P H (1964). The industrialization of nigeria. In: Proceedings of the Oklahoma Academy of Science: Geography. 215–218

[92] Xenophon (1869). The Anabasis or Expedition of Cyrus and the Memorabilia of Socrates. New York: Karper and Row

[93] Xie Y, Zilberman D (2014). The economics of water project capacities and conservation technologies. In: Proceedings of Agricultural and Applied Economics Association 2014 Annual Meeting

[94] Zervas T, McMullan J T, Williams B C (1996). Developments in iron and steel making. International Journal of Energy Research, 20(1): 69–91

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2018 The Author(s) 2018. Published by Higher Education Press. This is an open access article under the CC-BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)