An overview of solutions to the bus bunching problem in urban bus systems

Abstract

Bus bunching has been a persistent issue in urban bus system since it first appeared, and it remains a challenge not fully resolved. This phenomenon may reduce the operational efficiency of the urban bus system, which is detrimental to the operation of fast-paced public transport in cities. Fortunately, extensive research has been undertaken in the long development and optimization of the urban bus system, and many solutions have emerged so far. The purpose of this paper is to summarize the existing solutions and serve as a guide for subsequent research in this area. Upon careful examination of current findings, it is found that, based on the different optimization objects, existing solutions to the bus bunching problem can be divided into five directions, i.e., operational strategy improvement, traffic control improvement, driver driving rules improvement, passenger habit improvement, and others. While numerous solutions to bus bunching are available, there remains a gap in research exploring the integrated application of methods from diverse directions. Furthermore, with the development of autonomous driving, it is expected that the use of modular autonomous vehicles could be the most potential solution to the issue of bus bunching in the future.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

bus bunching / operation strategy / traffic control / driver driving rules / passenger habits

References

[1] Abkowitz M D, Engelstein I, (1983). Factors affecting running time on transit routes. Transportation Research Part A: General, 17( 2): 107–113

[2] AlbrightEFigliozziM A (2012). Analysis of the impacts of transit signal priority on bus bunching and performance. In: Proceedings of the Conference on Advanced Systems for Public Transport. Santiago

[3] Andreotti E, Selpi P, (2023). Potential impact of autonomous vehicles in mixed traffic from simulation using real traffic flow. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 6( 1): 1–15

[4] Andres M, Nair R, (2017). A predictive-control framework to address bus bunching. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 104: 123–148

[5] Aramrattana M, Fu J, (2022). Behavioral adaptation of drivers when driving among automated vehicles. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 3): 309–315

[6] ArchanaaRNivethaDAnjalikumariTPreethikkaBKiranM V K (2017). A thrifty approach to the bus bunching problem. In: International Conference on Signal Processing and Communication. Coimbatore: IEEE, 191–195

[7] Arriagada J, Gschwender A, Munizaga M A, Trépanier M, (2019). Modeling bus bunching using massive location and fare collection data. Journal of Intelligent Transport Systems, 23( 4): 332–344

[8] Berrebi S J, Hans E, Chiabaut N, Laval J A, Leclercq L, Watkins K E, (2018). Comparing bus holding methods with and without real-time predictions. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 87: 197–211

[9] Bueno-Cadena C E, Muñoz J C, (2017). Reducing metro trip times and energy consumption through speed control, holding and boarding limits. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science, 13( 9): 767–793

[10] Byon Y J, Cortés C E, Jeong Y S, Martínez F J, Munizaga M A, Zúñiga M, (2018). Bunching and headway adherence approach to public transport with GPS. International Journal of Civil Engineering, 16( 6): 647–658

[11] Cai P L, He J, Li Y K, (2023). Hybrid cooperative intersection management for connected automated vehicles and pedestrians. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 6( 2): 91–101

[12] Cats O, (2014). Regularity-driven bus operation: Principles, implementation and business models. Transport Policy, 36: 223–230

[13] Cats O, (2019). Determinants of bus riding time deviations: Relationship between driving patterns and transit performance. Journal of Transportation Engineering, Part A: Systems, 145( 1): 04018078

[14] ChamC L (2006). Understanding Bus Service Reliability: A Practical Framework Using AVL/APC Data. Dissertation for the Master’s Degree. Boston, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology

[15] Chen L, Li Y C, Huang C, Li B, Xing Y, Tian D X, Li L, Hu Z X, Na X X, Li Z X, Teng S Y, Lv C, Wang J J, Cao D P, Zheng N N, Wang F Y, (2023). Milestones in autonomous driving and intelligent vehicles: Survey of surveys. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles, 8( 2): 1046–1056

[16] Chen X, Yu L, Zhang Y, Guo J, (2009). Analyzing urban bus service reliability at the stop, route, and network levels. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 43( 8): 722–734

[17] Cheng S B, Quilodrán-Casas C, Ouala S, Farchi A, Liu C, Tandeo P, Fablet R, Lucor D, Iooss B, Brajard J, Xiao D H, Janjic T, Ding W P, Guo Y K, Carrassi A, Bocquet M, Arcucci R, (2023). Machine learning with data assimilation and uncertainty quantification for dynamical systems: A review. IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 10( 6): 1361–1387

[18] ComiANuzzoloABrinchiSVerghiniR (2017). Bus dispatching irregularity and travel time dispersion. In: Proceedings of 5th IEEE International Conference on Models and Technologies for Intelligent Transportation Systems. Napoli: IEEE, 856–860

[19] Comi A, Sassano M, Valentini A, (2022). Monitoring and controlling real-time bus services: A reinforcement learning procedure for eliminating bus bunching. Transportation Research Procedia, 62: 302–309

[20] Daganzo C F, Pilachowski J, (2011). Reducing bunching with bus-to-bus cooperation. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 45( 1): 267–277

[21] Dai Z, Liu X C, Chen X, Ma X, (2020). Joint optimization of scheduling and capacity for mixed traffic with autonomous and human-driven buses: A dynamic programming approach. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 114: 598–619

[22] Dakic I, Ambühl L, Schümperlin O, Menendez M, (2020). On the modeling of passenger mobility for stochastic bi-modal urban corridors. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 113: 146–163

[23] DanaherA (2020a). Developing a Guide to Bus Transit Service Reliability. Washington D.C.: The National Academies Press

[24] DanaherA (2020b). Minutes Matter: A Bus Transit Service Reliability Guidebook. Washington D.C.: The National Academies Press

[25] DelgadoFMunozJ CGiesenR (2016). BRRT adding an R for reliability. In: Munoz J C, Laurel PS, eds. Restructuring Public Transport through Bus Rapid Transit. Bristol: Policy Press, 317–336

[26] DiabEBertiniREl-GeneidyA (2016). Bus transit service reliability: Understanding the impacts of overlapping bus service on headway delays and determinants of bus bunching. In: 95th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board. Washington D.C

[27] Ding F, Mi G Y, Tong E, Zhang N, Bao J M, Zhang D Y, (2022). Multi-channel high-resolution network and attention mechanism fusion for vehicle detection model. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 1): 122–130 (in Chinese)

[28] DrabickiACatsOKucharskiR (2021). The potential of real-time crowding information in reducing bus bunching under different network saturation levels. In: 7th International Conference on Models and Technologies for Intelligent Transportation Systems. Heraklion: IEEE, 1–6

[29] Durán-Hormazábal E, Tirachini A, (2016). Estimation of travel time variability for cars, buses, metro and door-to-door public transport trips in Santiago, Chile. Research in Transportation Economics, 59: 26–39

[30] El-Geneidy A M, Horning J, Krizek K J, (2011). Analyzing transit service reliability using detailed data from automatic vehicular locator systems. Journal of Advanced Transportation, 45( 1): 66–79

[31] Fang L, Guan Z W, Wang T, Gong J F, Du F, (2022). Collision avoidance model and its validation for intelligent vehicles based on deep learning LSTM. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 1): 104–111 (in Chinese)

[32] FengWFigliozziM A (2015). Empirical analysis of bus bunching characteristics based on bus AVL/APC data. In: 94th Annual Meeting of Transportation Research Board. Washington D.C

[33] FigliozziM AFengW CLafferriereGFengW (2012). A study of headway maintenance for bus routes: Causes and effects of “bus bunching” in extensive and congested service areas. Technical Report

[34] Furth P G, Muller T H J, (2000). Conditional bus priority at signalized intersections: Better service with less traffic disruption. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 1731( 1): 23–30

[35] Gkiotsalitis K, Cats O, (2018). Reliable frequency determination: Incorporating information on service uncertainty when setting dispatching headways. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 88: 187–207

[36] Gkiotsalitis K, Wu Z, Cats O, (2019). A cost-minimization model for bus fleet allocation featuring the tactical generation of short-turning and interlining options. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 98: 14–36

[37] Godachevich J, Tirachini A, (2021). Does the measured performance of bus operators depend on the index chosen to assess reliability in contracts? An analysis of bus headway variability. Research in Transportation Economics, 90: 101000

[38] Guo G, Yang D Q, Zhang R Y K, (2023). Distributed trajectory optimization and platooning of vehicles to guarantee smooth traffic flow. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles, 8( 1): 684–695

[39] Hammerle M, Haynes M, McNeil S, (2005). Use of automatic vehicle location and passenger count data to evaluate bus operations: Experience of the Chicago Transit Authority, Illinois. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 1903( 1): 27–34

[40] Han S Y, Sun Q W, Yang X H, Han R Z, Zhou J, Chen Y H, (2022). Adaptation scheduling for urban traffic lights via FNT-based prediction of traffic flow. Electronics, 11( 4): 658

[41] He S X, (2015). An anti-bunching strategy to improve bus schedule and headway reliability by making use of the available accurate information. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 85: 17–32

[42] He S X, Liang S D, Dong J, Zhang D, He J J, Yuan P C, (2020). A holding strategy to resist bus bunching with dynamic target headway. Computers & Industrial Engineering, 140: 106237

[43] HeY XLiuYYangLQuX B (2023). Deep adaptive control: Deep reinforcement learning-based adaptive vehicle trajectory control algorithms for different risk levels. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles: 1–12

[44] Hu W, Deng Z J, Cao D P, Zhang B J, Khajepour A, Zeng L, Wu Y, (2022a). Probabilistic lane-change decision-making and planning for autonomous heavy vehicles. IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 9( 12): 2161–2173

[45] Hu Y Z, Jiang T, Liu X, Shi Y N, (2022b). Pedestrian-crossing intention-recognition based on dual-stream adaptive graph-convolutional neural-network. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 2): 325–332 (in Chinese)

[46] IliopoulouCMiliotiCVlahogianniEKepaptsoglouKSánchez-MedinaJ (2018). The bus bunching problem: Empirical findings from spatial analytics. In: 21st International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITSC). Maui, HI: IEEE, 871–876

[47] Ishaq R, Cats O, (2020). Designing bus rapid transit systems: Lessons on service reliability and operations. Case Studies on Transport Policy, 8( 3): 946–953

[48] Jara-Díaz S R, Tirachini A, (2013). Urban bus transport: Open all doors for boarding. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 47( 1): 91–106

[49] Ji J H, Bie Y M, Zeng Z L, Wang L H, (2022). Trip energy consumption estimation for electric buses. Communications in Transportation Research, 2: 100069

[50] Khan Z S, He W, Menéndez M, (2023). Application of modular vehicle technology to mitigate bus bunching. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 146: 103953

[51] Koehler L A, Seman L O, Kraus W, Camponogara E, (2019). Real-time integrated holding and priority control strategy for transit systems. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, 20( 9): 3459–3469

[52] KoppisettiM VKavithaVAyestaU (2018). Bus schedule for optimal bus bunching and waiting times. In: 10th International Conference on Communication Systems & Networks. Bengaluru: IEEE, 607–612

[53] Li M Y, Lv H Y, He X M, Xu G Q, Yu W, (2022a). Surrounding vehicle recognition and information map construction technology in automatic driving. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 1): 131–141 (in Chinese)

[54] Li S, Liu Y, Qu X B, (2022b). Model controlled prediction: A reciprocal alternative of model predictive control. IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 9( 6): 1107–1110

[55] Li W L, Xiao K W, Ren Y P, Li C, Yi F, (2022c). Path planning and control method for vehicle obstacle avoidance in pedestrian crossing scenes. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 3): 489–501 (in Chinese)

[56] Li Y, Zhao L, Gao K, An Y, Andric J, (2022d). Revealing driver psychophysiological response to emergency braking in distracted driving based on field experiments. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 3): 270–282

[57] Li Z, Hensher D A, Rose J M, (2010). Willingness to pay for travel time reliability in passenger transport: A review and some new empirical evidence. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 46( 3): 384–403

[58] LinH YHeY XLiuYGaoKQuX B (2023a). Deep demand prediction: An enhanced conformer model with cold-start adaptation for origin–destination ride-hailing demand prediction. IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Magazine, in press, doi:10.1109/MITS.2023.3309653

[59] Lin M, Chen S, Wang W, Wu J, (2023b). Multi-feature fusion-based instantaneous energy consumption estimation for electric buses. IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 10( 10): 2035–2037

[60] Liu B, Liu X Y, Yang Y, Chen X, Ma X L, (2023a). Resilience assessment framework toward interdependent bus–rail transit network: Structure, critical components, and coupling mechanism. Communications in Transportation Research, 3: 100098

[61] Liu Y, Jia R, Ye J P, Qu X B, (2022a). How machine learning informs ride-hailing services: A survey. Communications in Transportation Research, 2: 100075

[62] Liu Y, Liu Z Y, Jia R, (2019). DeepPF: A deep learning based architecture for metro passenger flow prediction. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 101: 18–34

[63] Liu Y, Lyu C, Zhang Y, Liu Z Y, Yu W W, Qu X B, (2021). DeepTSP: Deep traffic state prediction model based on large-scale empirical data. Communications in Transportation Research, 1: 100012

[64] Liu Y, Wu F Y, Liu Z Y, Wang K, Wang F Y, Qu X B, (2023b). Can language models be used for real-world urban-delivery route optimization?. The Innovation, 4( 6): 100520

[65] Liu Y, Wu F Y, Lyu C, Li S, Ye J P, Qu X B, (2022b). Deep dispatching: A deep reinforcement learning approach for vehicle dispatching on online ride-hailing platform. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 161: 102694

[66] Liu Y H, Wang L H, Zeng Z L, Bie Y M, (2022c). Optimal charging plan for electric bus considering time-of-day electricity tariff. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 2): 123–137

[67] Liu Z Y, Yan Y, Qu X B, Zhang Y, (2013). Bus stop-skipping scheme with random travel time. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 35: 46–56

[68] Loder A, Ambühl L, Menendez M, Axhausen K W, (2017). Empirics of multi-modal traffic networks: Using the 3D macroscopic fundamental diagram. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 82: 88–101

[69] Lyu N, Wang Y G, Wu C Z, Peng L F, Thomas A F, (2022). Using naturalistic driving data to identify driving style based on longitudinal driving operation conditions. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 1): 17–35

[70] MartinezY FMunozJ CDelgadoF (2018). How does considering bus drivers with different driving behaviors impact the performance of interval control tools? In: 14th International Conference on Advanced Systems in Public Transport. Brisbane

[71] Milkovits M N, (2008). Modeling the factors affecting bus stop dwell time: Use of automatic passenger counting, automatic fare counting, and automatic vehicle location data. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2072( 1): 125–130

[72] Mo H, Meng Y H, Wang F Y, Wu D R, (2022). Interval type-2 fuzzy hierarchical adaptive cruise following-control for intelligent vehicles. IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 9( 9): 1658–1672

[73] Morales D, Muñoz J C, Gazmuri P, (2019). A stochastic model for bus injection in a public transport service. Transportation Research Procedia, 38: 688–708

[74] Moreira-Matias L, Cats O, Gama J, Mendes-Moreira J, de Sousa J F, (2016). An online learning approach to eliminate bus bunching in real-time. Applied Soft Computing, 47: 460–482

[75] Muñoz J C, Soza-Parra J, Raveau S, (2020). A comprehensive perspective of unreliable public transport services’ costs. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science, 16( 3): 734–748

[76] NewellG FPottsR B (1964). Maintaining a bus schedule. In: 2nd Australian Road Research Board Conference. Melbourne, 388–393

[77] Petit A, Lei C, Ouyang Y F, (2019). Multiline bus bunching control via vehicle substitution. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 126: 68–86

[78] Petit A, Ouyang Y F, Lei C, (2018). Dynamic bus substitution strategy for bunching intervention. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 115: 1–16

[79] Qu X B, Lin H Y, Liu Y, (2023). Envisioning the future of transportation: Inspiration of ChatGPT and large models. Communications in Transportation Research, 3: 100103

[80] Qu X B, Liu Y J, Chen Y W, Bie Y M, (2022a). Urban electric bus operation management: Review and outlook. Journal Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 3): 407–420 (in Chinese)

[81] Qu X B, Zeng Z L, Wang K, Wang S A, (2022b). Replacing urban trucks via ground–air cooperation. Communications in Transportation Research, 2: 100080

[82] RamírezAMejíaJ SGutiérrezÁ O (2015). Bus rapid transit control system using restrictive holding and operating tables. In: Chilean Conference on Electrical, Electronics Engineering, Information and Communication Technologies. Santiago: IEEE, 141–148

[83] Sáez D, Cortés C E, Milla F, Núñez A, Tirachini A, Riquelme M, (2012). Hybrid predictive control strategy for a public transport system with uncertain demand. Transportmetrica, 8( 1): 61–86

[84] Schmöcker J D, Sun W Z, Fonzone A, Liu R H, (2016). Bus bunching along a corridor served by two lines. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 93: 300–317

[85] Soza-Parra J, Muñoz J C, Raveau S, (2021). Factors that affect the evolution of headway variability along an urban bus service. Transportmetrica B: Transport Dynamics, 9( 1): 479–490

[86] Strathman J G, Dueker K J, Kimpel T, Gerhart R, Turner K, Taylor P, Callas S, Griffin D, Hopper J, (1999). Automated bus dispatching, operations control, and service reliability: Baseline analysis. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 1666( 1): 28–36

[87] Strathman J G, Kimpel T J, Dueker K J, Gerhart R L, Callas S, (2002). Evaluation of transit operations: Data applications of Tri-Met’s automated bus dispatching system. Transportation, 29( 3): 321–345

[88] Sun L J, Tirachini A, Axhausen K W, Erath A, Lee D H, (2014). Models of bus boarding and alighting dynamics. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 69: 447–460

[89] Tang C Y, Shi H D, Liu T, (2023). Optimization of single-line electric bus scheduling with skip-stop operation. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 117: 103652

[90] Tirachini A, Godachevich J, Cats O, Muñoz J C, Soza-Parra J, (2022). Headway variability in public transport: A review of metrics, determinants, effects for quality of service and control strategies. Transport Reviews, 42( 3): 337–361

[91] Tirachini A, Hensher D A, Bliemer M C J, (2014). Accounting for travel time variability in the optimal pricing of cars and buses. Transportation, 41( 5): 947–971

[92] Verbich D, Diab E, El-Geneidy A, (2016). Have they bunched yet? An exploratory study of the impacts of bus bunching on dwell and running times. Public Transport, 8( 2): 225–242

[93] Wang J W, Sun L, (2020). Dynamic holding control to avoid bus bunching: A multi-agent deep reinforcement learning framework. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 116: 102661

[94] Wang K J, Xiao Y, He Y X, (2023). Charting the future: Intelligent and connected vehicles reshaping the bus system. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 6( 3): 113–115

[95] WangT (2014). A FlexiFare Bus (F2B) system to reduce bus bunching problem. In: IEEE International Conference on Progress in Informatics and Computing. Shanghai: IEEE, 651–655

[96] West J, Cats O, (2017). Individual and synergetic effects of transit service improvement strategies: Simulation and validation. Journal of Transportation Engineering, Part A: Systems, 143( 12): 04017061

[97] Wu W T, Liu R H, Jin W Z, (2017). Modelling bus bunching and holding control with vehicle overtaking and distributed passenger boarding behaviour. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 104( 6): 175–197

[98] Wu W T, Liu R H, Jin W Z, Ma C X, (2019). Simulation-based robust optimization of limited-stop bus service with vehicle overtaking and dynamics: A response surface methodology. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 130: 61–81

[99] Xu J, Pei X F, Yang B, Fang Z G, (2022a). Learning-based automatic driving decision-making integrated with vehicle trajectory prediction. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 2): 317–324 (in Chinese)

[100] Xu J, Zhang Y, Dai Z H, Li F, Chen J, (2022b). Vehicle trajectory oscillation characteristics and lane width control under human natural driving conditions. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 4): 718–728 (in Chinese)

[101] Xu L, Jin S, Li B, Wu J, (2022c). Traffic signal coordination control for arterials with dedicated CAV lanes. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 2): 72–87

[102] Yang H, Zhao J, Wang M, (2022). Optimal control of automated left-turn platoon at contraflow left-turn lane intersections. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 3): 206–214

[103] Yanumula V K, Typaldos P, Troullinos D, Malekzadeh M, Papamichail I, Papageorgiou M, (2023). Optimal trajectory planning for connected and automated vehicles in lane-free traffic with vehicle nudging. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles, 8( 3): 2385–2399

[104] Yu H Y, Chen D W, Wu Z H, Ma X L, Wang Y P, (2016). Headway-based bus bunching prediction using transit smart card data. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 72: 45–59

[105] Yu R, Zhang Y, Wang L, Du X, (2022). Time headway distribution analysis of naturalistic road users based on aerial datasets. Journal of Intelligent and Connected Vehicles, 5( 3): 149–156

[106] Zeng Z L, Qu X B, (2023). What’s next for battery-electric bus charging systems?. Communications in Transportation Research, 3: 100094

[107] Zhao S E, Chen W B, Deng Z X, Liu W, (2022). Trajectory tracking control for intelligent vehicles driving in curved road based on expanded state observers. Journal of Automotive Safety and Energy, 13( 1): 112–121 (in Chinese)

[108] Zhong C, Wu P L, Zhang Q, Ma Z L, (2023). Online prediction of network-level public transport demand based on principle component analysis. Communications in Transportation Research, 3: 100093

[109] Zhou C, Tian Q, Wang D Z W, (2022). A novel control strategy in mitigating bus bunching: Utilizing real-time information. Transport Policy, 123: 1–13

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Open Access

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.

The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). This article is published with open access at link.springer.com and journal.hep.com.cn