The development of roadside green swales in the Chinese Sponge City Program: Challenges and opportunities

Abstract

Roadside green swales have emerged as popular stormwater management infrastructure in urban areas, serving to mitigate stormwater pollution and reduce urban surface water discharge. However, there is a limited understanding of the various types, structures, and functions of swales, as well as the potential challenges they may face in the future. In recent years, China has witnessed a surge in the adoption of roadside green swales, especially as part of the prestigious Sponge City Program (SCP). These green swales play a crucial role in controlling stormwater pollution and conserving urban water resources by effectively removing runoff pollutants, including suspended solids, nitrogen, and phosphorus. This review critically examines recent research findings, identifies key knowledge gaps, and presents future recommendations for designing green swales for effective stormwater management, with a particular emphasis on ongoing major Chinese infrastructure projects. Despite the growing global interest in bioswales and their significance in urban development, China’s current classification of such features lacks a clear definition or specific consideration of bioswales. Furthermore, policymakers have often underestimated the adverse environmental effects of road networks, as reflected in existing laws and planning documents. This review argues that the construction and maintenance of roadside green swales should be primarily based on three critical factors: Well-thought-out road planning, suitable construction conditions, and sustainable long-term funding. The integration of quantitative environmental standards into road planning is essential to effectively address the challenge of pollution from rainfall runoff. To combat pollution associated with roads, a comprehensive assessment of potential pollution loadings should be carried out, guiding the appropriate design and construction of green swales, with a particular focus on addressing the phenomenon of first flush. One of the major challenges faced in sustaining funds for ongoing maintenance after swale construction. To address this issue, the implementation of a green finance platform is proposed. Such a platform would help ensure the availability of funds for continuous maintenance, thus maximizing the long-term effectiveness of green swales in stormwater management. Ultimately, the findings of this review aim to assist municipal governments in enhancing and implementing future urban road designs and SCP developments, incorporating effective green swale strategies.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

grass swale / infiltration swale / bioswale / wet swale / sponge city

References

[1] Allen, D Olive, V Arthur, S Haynes, H (2015). Urban sediment transport through an established vegetated swale: Long-term treatment efficiencies and deposition. Water, 7( 3): 1046–1067

[2] Anderson, B S Phillips, B M Voorhees, J P Siegler, K Tjeerdema, R (2016). Bioswales reduce contaminants associated with toxicity in urban storm water. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 35( 12): 3124–3134

[3] Bäckström, M (2003). Grassed swales for stormwater pollution control during rain and snowmelt. Water Science and Technology, 48( 9): 123–132

[4] Barrett, M E Walsh, P M Malina Jr, J F Charbeneau, R J (1998). Performance of vegetative controls for treating highway runoff. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 124( 11): 1121–1128

[5] Bellprat, O Guemas, V Doblas-Reyes, F Donat, M G (2019). Towards reliable extreme weather and climate event attribution. Nature Communications, 10( 1): 1732

[6] Bevilacqua, P (2021). The effectiveness of green roofs in reducing building energy consumptions across different climates: A summary of literature results. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 151: 111523

[7] Blecken, G T Hunt, III W F Al-Rubaei, A M Viklander, M Lord, W G (2017). Stormwater control measure (SCM) maintenance considerations to ensure designed functionality. Urban Water Journal, 14( 3): 278–290

[8] Bouzouidja, R Leconte, F Kiss, M Pierret, M Pruvot, C Détriché, S Louvel, B Bertout, J Aketouane, Z Wu, T V Goiffon, R Colin, B Pétrissans, A Lagière, P Pétrissans, M (2021). Experimental comparative study between conventional and green parking lots: Analysis of subsurface thermal behavior under warm and dry summer conditions. Atmosphere, 12( 8): 994

[9] Bressy, A Gromaire, M C Lorgeoux, C Saad, M Leroy, F Chebbo, G (2014). Efficiency of source control systems for reducing runoff pollutant loads: Feedback on experimental catchments within Paris conurbation. Water Research, 57: 234–246

[10] Brodsky, O L Shek, K L Dinwiddie, D Bruner, S G Gill, A S Hoch, J M Palmer, M I McGuire, K L (2019). Microbial communities in bioswale soils and their relationships to soil properties, plant species, and plant physiology. Frontiers in Microbiology, 10: 2368

[11] Brunetti, G Simunek, J Piro, P (2016). A comprehensive numerical analysis of the hydraulic behavior of a permeable pavement. Journal of Hydrology, 540: 1146–1161

[12] Chan, F K S Chen, W Y Gu, X B Peng, Y Sang, Y F (2022a). Transformation towards resilient sponge cities in China. Nature Reviews Earth & Environment, 3( 2): 99–101

[13] Chan, F K S Chen, W Y Wang, Z Loh, C Thadani, D R Mitchell, G Chau, P Y K Altamirano, M A Jaimerena, B A Qi, Y Li, L Gu, X B Zhang, F (2022b). Meeting financial challenge facing China’s Sponge City Program (SCP): Hong Kong as a gateway to green finance. Nature-Based Solutions, 2: 100019

[14] Chang, C L Lo, S L Huang, S M (2009). Optimal strategies for best management practice placement in a synthetic watershed. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 153( 1–4): 359–364

[15] Chatzimentor, A Apostolopoulou, E Mazaris, A D (2020). A review of green infrastructure research in Europe: Challenges and opportunities. Landscape and Urban Planning, 198: 103775

[16] Che, W Zhao, Y Yang, Z Li, J Q Shi, M (2014). Integral stormwater management master plan and design in an ecological community. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 26( 9): 1818–1823

[17] Church, S P (2015). Exploring green streets and rain gardens as instances of small scale nature and environmental learning tools. Landscape and Urban Planning, 134: 229–240

[18] Davis, A P Stagge, J H Jamil, E Kim, H (2012). Hydraulic performance of grass swales for managing highway runoff. Water Research, 46( 20): 6775–6786

[19] Deletic, A (1998). The first flush load of urban surface runoff. Water Research, 32( 8): 2462–2470

[20] EkkaS AHunt B (2020). Swale Terminology for Urban Stormwater Treatment. Urban Waterway Series, NC State Extension. Raleigh, NC: North Carolina State University

[21] Ekka, S A Rujner, H Leonhardt, G Blecken, G T Viklander, M Hunt, W F (2021). Next generation swale design for stormwater runoff treatment: A comprehensive approach. Journal of Environmental Management, 279: 111756

[22] Fach, S Engelhard, C Wittke, N Rauch, W (2011). Performance of infiltration swales with regard to operation in winter times in an Alpine region. Water Science and Technology, 63( 11): 2658–2665

[23] Fardel, A Peyneau, P E Bechet, B Lakel, A Rodriguez, F (2019). Analysis of swale factors implicated in pollutant removal efficiency using a swale database. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 26( 2): 1287–1302

[24] García-Serrana, M Gulliver, J S Nieber, J L (2017). Non-uniform overland flow-infiltration model for roadside swales. Journal of Hydrology, 552: 586–599

[25] García-Serrana, M Gulliver, J S Nieber, J L (2018). Calculator to estimate annual infiltration performance of roadside swales. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 23( 6): 04018017

[26] Gavrić, S Leonhardt, G Marsalek, J Viklander, M (2019). Processes improving urban stormwater quality in grass swales and filter strips: A review of research findings. Science of the Total Environment, 669: 431–447

[27] Gong, Y W Yin, D K Liu, C Li, J Q Shi, H H Fang, X (2019). The influence of external conditions on runoff quality control of grass swale in Beijing and Shenzhen, China. Water Practice & Technology, 14( 2): 482–494

[28] Green, D O’Donnell, E Johnson, M Slater, L Thorne, C Zheng, S Stirling, R Chan, F K S Li, L Boothroyd, R J (2021). Green infrastructure: The future of urban flood risk management?. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water, 8( 6): e21560

[29] Gülbaz, S Kazezyilmaz-Alhan, C M (2014). Investigating effects of low impact development on surface runoff and TSS with a calibrated hydrodynamic model. La Houille Blanche, 100( 3): 77–84

[30] Gwynne, C S (1942). Swell and swale pattern of the Mankato lobe of the Wisconsin drift plain in Iowa. Journal of Geology, 50( 2): 200–208

[31] Hernández-Crespo, C Fernandez-Gonzalvo, M Martin, M Andres-Domenech, I (2019). Influence of rainfall intensity and pollution build-up levels on water quality and quantity response of permeable pavements. Science of the Total Environment, 684: 303–313

[32] Horstmeyer, N Huber, M Drewes, J E Helmreich, B (2016). Evaluation of site-specific factors influencing heavy metal contents in the topsoil of vegetated infiltration swales. Science of the Total Environment, 560: 19–28

[33] Houser, C Hobbs, C Saari, B (2008). Posthurricane airflow and sediment transport over a recovering dune. Journal of Coastal Research, 24( 4): 944–953

[34] Hunt, W F Davis, A P Traver, R G (2012). Meeting hydrologic and water quality goals through targeted bioretention design. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 138( 6): 698–707

[35] Ingvertsen, S T Cederkvist, K Regent, Y Sommer, H Magid, J Jensen, M B (2012). Assessment of existing roadside swales with engineered filter soil: I characterization and lifetime expectancy. Journal of Environmental Quality, 41( 6): 1960–1969

[36] Jia, H F Wang, X W Ti, C P Zhai, Y Y Field, R Tafuri, A N Cai, H H Yu, S L (2015). Field monitoring of an LID-BMP treatment train system in China. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 187( 6): 373

[37] Jiang, C B Li, J K Li, H E Li, Y J Zhang, Z X (2020). Low-impact development facilities for stormwater runoff treatment: Field monitoring and assessment in Xi’an area, China. Journal of Hydrology, 585: 124803

[38] Jung, J W Park, H N Yoon, K S Choi, D H Lim, B J (2013). Event mean concentrations (EMCs) and first flush characteristics of runoff from a public park in Korea. Journal of the Korean Society for Applied Biological Chemistry, 56( 5): 597–604

[39] Kazemi, F Beecham, S Gibbs, J (2011). Streetscape biodiversity and the role of bioretention swales in an Australian urban environment. Landscape and Urban Planning, 101( 2): 139–148

[40] Kirby, J T Durrans, S R Pitt, R Johnson, P D (2005). Hydraulic resistance in grass swales designed for small flow conveyance. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 131( 1): 65–68

[41] Knight, E M P Hunt, W F Winston, R J (2013). Side-by-side evaluation of four level spreader-vegetated filter strips and a swale in eastern North Carolina. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 68( 1): 60–72

[42] Koscielniak, H Gorka, A (2016). Green cities PPP as a method of financing sustainable urban development. Transportation Research Procedia, 16: 227–235

[43] Lee, H S Lim, B R Hur, J Kim, H S Shin, H S (2021). Combined dual-size foam glass media filtration process with micro-flocculation for simultaneous removal of particulate and dissolved contaminants in urban road runoff. Journal of Environmental Management, 277: 111475

[44] Lee, J H Bang, K W Ketchum Jr, L H Choe, J S Yu, M J (2002). First flush analysis of urban storm runoff. Science of the Total Environment, 293( 1–3): 163–175

[45] Leroy, M C Legras, M Marcotte, S Moncond’huy, V Machour, N Le, Derf F Portet-Koltalo, F (2015). Assessment of PAH dissipation processes in large-scale outdoor mesocosms simulating vegetated road-side swales. Science of the Total Environment, 520: 146–153

[46] Leroy, M C Marcotte, S Legras, M Moncond’huy, V Le, Derf F Portet-Koltalo, F (2017). Influence of the vegetative cover on the fate of trace metals in retention systems simulating roadside infiltration swales. Science of the Total Environment, 580: 482–490

[47] Li, D Y Wan, J Q Ma, Y W Wang, Y Huang, M Z Chen, Y M (2015). Stormwater runoff pollutant loading distributions and their correlation with rainfall and catchment characteristics in a rapidly industrialized city. PLoS One, 10( 3): e0118776

[48] Li, F Z Chen, J Q Engel, B A Liu, Y Z Wang, S Z Sun, H (2021). Assessing the effectiveness and cost efficiency of green infrastructure practices on surface runoff reduction at an urban watershed in China. Water, 13( 1): 24

[49] Li, H (2015). Green infrastructure for highway stormwater management: Field investigation for future design, maintenance, and management needs. Journal of Infrastructure Systems, 21( 4): 05015001

[50] Li, J K Li, Y Zhang, J Y Li, H E Li, Y J (2016). Bio-swale column experiments and simulation of hydrologic impacts on urban road stormwater runoff. Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, 25( 1): 173–184

[51] Li, M H Barrett, M E Rammohan, P Olivera, F Landphair, H C (2008). Documenting stormwater quality on Texas highways and adjacent vegetated roadsides. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 134( 1): 48–59

[52] Li, Y Huang, J J Hu, M C Yang, H Tanaka, K (2020). Design of low impact development in the urban context considering hydrological performance and life-cycle cost. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 13( 3): e12625

[53] Liu, F Vianello, A Vollertsen, J (2019). Retention of microplastics in sediments of urban and highway stormwater retention ponds. Environmental Pollution, 255( 2): 113335

[54] Liu, T Q Lawluvy, Y Shi, Y Yap, P S (2021). Low Impact Development (LID) practices: A review on recent developments, challenges and prospects. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, 232( 9): 344

[55] Liu, W Chen, W Feng, Q Peng, C Kang, P (2016). Cost-benefit analysis of green infrastructures on community stormwater reduction and utilization: A case of Beijing, China. Environmental Management, 58( 6): 1015–1026

[56] Locatelli, L Mark, O Mikkelsen, P S Arnbjerg-Nielsen, K Wong, T Binning, P J (2015). Determining the extent of groundwater interference on the performance of infiltration trenches. Journal of Hydrology, 529( 3): 1360–1372

[57] Logan, T M Zaitchik, B Guikema, S Nisbet, A (2020). Night and day: The influence and relative importance of urban characteristics on remotely sensed land surface temperature. Remote Sensing of Environment, 247: 111861

[58] Luan, Q H Fu, X R Song, C P Wang, H C Liu, J H Wang, Y (2017). Runoff effect evaluation of LID through SWMM in typical mountainous, low-lying urban areas: A case study in China. Water, 9( 6): 439

[59] Lucke, T Mohamed, M A K Tindale, N (2014). Pollutant removal and hydraulic reduction performance of field grassed swales during runoff simulation experiments. Water, 6( 7): 1887–1904

[60] Mazer, G Booth, D Ewing, K (2001). Limitations to vegetation establishment and growth in biofiltration swales. Ecological Engineering, 17( 4): 429–443

[61] McIntyre, J K Prat, J Cameron, J Wetzel, J Mudrock, E Peter, K T Tian, Z Y Mackenzie, C Lundin, J Stark, J D King, K Davis, J W Kolodziej, E P Scholz, N L (2021). Treading water: Tire wear particle leachate recreates an urban runoff mortality syndrome in coho but not chum salmon. Environmental Science & Technology, 55( 17): 11767–11774

[62] Monrabal-Martinez, C Aberle, J Muthanna, T M Orts-Zamorano, M (2018). Hydrological benefits of filtering swales for metal removal. Water Research, 145: 509–517

[63] Moore, T L Rodak, C M Ahmed, F Vogel, J R (2018). Urban stormwater characterization: Control and treatment. Water Environment Research, 90( 10): 1821–1871

[64] National Committee on Soil and Terrain (Australia) (2009). Australian Soil and Land Survey Field Handbook. 3rd ed. Clayton: CSIRO Publishing

[65] O’Donnell, E C Thorne, C R (2020). Drivers of future urban flood risk. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical, and Engineering Sciences, 378( 2168): 20190216

[66] O’Reilly, A M Wanielista, M P Chang, N B Xuan, Z Harris, W G (2012). Nutrient removal using biosorption activated media: Preliminary biogeochemical assessment of an innovative stormwater infiltration basin. Science of the Total Environment, 432: 227–242

[67] Perera, T Mcgree, J Egodawatta, P Jinadasa, K Goonetilleke, A (2021). New conceptualisation of first flush phenomena in urban catchments. Journal of Environmental Management, 281: 111820

[68] Qin, Y H (2020). Urban flooding mitigation techniques: A systematic review and future studies. Water, 12( 12): 3579

[69] Rezaei, A R Ismail, Z Niksokhan, M H Dayarian, M A Ramli, A H Yusoff, S (2021). Optimal implementation of low impact development for urban stormwater quantity and quality control using multi-objective optimization. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 193( 4): 241

[70] Roy, A H Rhea, L K Mayer, A L Shuster, W D Beaulieu, J J Hopton, M E Morrison, M A St., Amand A (2014). How much is enough? Minimal responses of water quality and stream biota to partial retrofit stormwater management in a suburban neighborhood. PLoS One, 9( 1): e85011

[71] Saniei, K Yazdi, J Majdzadehtabatabei, M R (2021). Optimal size, type and location of low impact developments (LIDs) for urban stormwater control. Urban Water Journal, 18( 8): 585–597

[72] Shaneyfelt, K M Anderson, A R Kumar, P Hunt, III W F (2017). Air quality considerations for stormwater green street design. Environmental Pollution, 231( 1): 768–778

[73] Smith, C Connolly, R Ampomah, R Hess, A Sample-Lord, K Smith, V (2021). Temporal soil dynamics in bioinfiltration systems. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, 147( 11): 04021053

[74] Sossalla, N A Nivala, J Reemtsma, T Schlichting, R Konig, M Forquet, N van Afferden, M Muller, R A Escher, B I (2021). Removal of micropollutants and biological effects by conventional and intensified constructed wetlands treating municipal wastewater. Water Research, 201: 117349

[75] SpechtR LSpecht A (1999). Australian Plant Communities: Dynamics of Structure, Growth and Biodiversity. Oxford: Oxford University Press

[76] Tang, J F Wang, W D Feng, J Y Yang, L Ruan, T Xu, Y Y (2021). Urban green infrastructure features influence the type and chemical composition of soil dissolved organic matter. Science of the Total Environment, 764: 144240

[77] Tang, N Y Li, T Ge, J (2016). Assessing ability of a wet swale to manage road runoff: A case study in Hefei, China. Journal of Central South University, 23( 6): 1353–1362

[78] van Dijk, S Lounsbury, A W Hoekstra, A Y Wang, R R (2020). Strategic design and finance of rainwater harvesting to cost-effectively meet large-scale urban water infrastructure needs. Water Research, 184: 116063

[79] Vijayaraghavan, K Biswal, B K Adam, M G Soh, S H Tsen-Tieng, D L Davis, A P Chew, S H Tan, P Y Babovic, V Balasubramanian, R (2021). Bioretention systems for stormwater management: Recent advances and future prospects. Journal of Environmental Management, 292: 112766

[80] Wang, S Min, F T Fu, J (2020). A method to measure hydrologic restoration attributed to low impact development by computing similarity between runoff frequency spectra. Journal of Hydrology, 588: 125134

[81] Wang, Y T Sun, M X Song, B M (2017). Public perceptions of and willingness to pay for sponge city initiatives in China. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 122: 11–20

[82] Wigington, P J Randall, C W Grizzard, T J (1986). Accumulation of selected trace-metals in soils of urban runoff swale drains. Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 22( 1): 73–79

[83] Winston, R J Anderson, A R Hunt, W F (2017). Modelling sediment reduction in grass swales and vegetated filter strips using particle settling theory. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 143( 1): 04016075

[84] Winston, R J Hunt, W F Kennedy, S G Wright, J D Lauffer, M S (2012). Field evaluation of storm-water control measures for highway runoff treatment. Journal of Environmental Engineering, 138( 1): 101–111

[85] Winston, R J Powell, J T Hunt, W F (2019). Retrofitting a grass swale with rock check dams: Hydrologic impacts. Urban Water Journal, 16( 6): 404–411

[86] Wu, J S Chen, Y Yang, R Zhao, Y H (2020). Exploring the optimal cost-benefit solution for a low impact development layout by zoning, as well as considering the inundation duration and inundation depth. Sustainability, 12( 12): 4990

[87] Xiao, Q F McPherson, E G (2011). Performance of engineered soil and trees in a parking lot bioswale. Urban Water Journal, 8( 4): 241–253

[88] Xu, C Q Shi, X M Jia, M Y Han, Y Zhang, R R Ahmad, S Jia, H F (2022). China Sponge City database development and urban runoff source control facility configuration comparison between China and the US. Journal of Environmental Management, 304: 114241

[89] Yang, M Y Sang, Y F Sivakumar, B Chan, F K S Pan, X Y (2020). Challenges in urban stormwater management in Chinese cities: A hydrologic perspective. Journal of Hydrology, 591: 125314

[90] Yazdi, J Khazaei, P (2019). Copula-based performance assessment of online and offline detention ponds for urban stormwater management. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 24( 9): 04019025

[91] Yu, J Yu, H Xu, L (2013). Performance evaluation of various stormwater best management practices. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 20( 9): 6160–6171

[92] Yu, S L Kuo, J T Fassman, E A Pan, H (2001). Field test of grassed-swale performance in removing runoff pollution. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 127( 3): 168–171

[93] Yuan, D H He, J W Li, C W Guo, X J Xiong, Y Yan, C L (2019). Insights into the pollutant-removal performance and DOM characteristics of stormwater runoff during grassy-swales treatment. Environmental Technology, 40( 4): 441–450

[94] Zaqout, T Andradottir, H O (2021). Hydrologic performance of grass swales in cold maritime climates: Impacts of frost, rain-on-snow and snow cover on flow and volume reduction. Journal of Hydrology, 597: 126159

[95] Zhang, D Q Gersberg, R M Ng, W J Tan, S K (2017). Conventional and decentralized urban stormwater management: A comparison through case studies of Singapore and Berlin, Germany. Urban Water Journal, 14( 2): 113–124

[96] Zhang, R Zhou, W B Field, R Tafuri, A Yu, S L Jin, K L (2009). Field test of best management practice pollutant removal efficiencies in Shenzhen, China. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering in China, 3( 3): 354–363

[97] Zhang, Y Y Qin, H P Ye, Y J Ding, W (2022). The effect of low impact development facilities on evapotranspiration in an outdoor space of urban buildings. Journal of Hydrology, 608: 127647

[98] Zuniga-Teran, A A Staddon, C de Vito, L Gerlak, A K Ward, S Schoeman, Y Hart, A Booth, G (2020). Challenges of mainstreaming green infrastructure in built environment professions. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 63( 4): 710–732

Electronic Supplementary Material

Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at https://doi.org/10.1007/s42524-023-0267-z and is accessible for authorized users.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Open Access

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.

The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2023 The Author(s). This article is published with open access at link.springer.com and journal.hep.com.cn