Can energy storage make off-grid photovoltaic hydrogen production system more economical?

Abstract

Under the ambitious goal of carbon neutralization, photovoltaic (PV)-driven electrolytic hydrogen (PVEH) production is emerging as a promising approach to reduce carbon emission. Considering the intermittence and variability of PV power generation, the deployment of battery energy storage can smoothen the power output. However, the investment cost of battery energy storage is pertinent to non-negligible expenses. Thus, the installation of energy-storage equipment in a PVEH system is a complex trade-off problem. The primary goals of this study are to compare the engineering economics of PVEH systems with and without energy storage, and to explore time nodes when the cost of the former scenario can compete with the latter by factoring the technology learning curve. The levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) is a widely used economic indicator. Represented by seven areas in seven regions of China, results show that the LCOH with and without energy storage is approximately 22.23 and 20.59 yuan/kg in 2020, respectively. In addition, as technology costs drop, the LCOH of a PVEH system with energy storage will be less than that without energy storage in 2030.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

hydrogen / off-grid photovoltaic / energy storage / LCOH / engineering economics

References

[1] Abdin, Z Mérida, W (2019). Hybrid energy systems for off-grid power supply and hydrogen production based on renewable energy: A techno-economic analysis. Energy Conversion and Management, 196: 1068–1079

[2] Al-Qahtani, A Parkinson, B Hellgardt, K Shah, N Guillen-Gosalbez, G (2021). Uncovering the true cost of hydrogen production routes using life cycle monetisation. Applied Energy, 281: 115958

[3] Bae, J H Cho, G L (2010). A dynamic general equilibrium analysis on fostering a hydrogen economy in Korea. Energy Economics, 32: S57–S66

[4] Bernal-Agustín, J L Dufo-López, R (2010). Techno-economical optimization of the production of hydrogen from PV-Wind systems connected to the electrical grid. Renewable Energy, 35( 4): 747–758

[5] Bhandari, R Shah, R R (2021). Hydrogen as energy carrier: Techno-economic assessment of decentralized hydrogen production in Germany. Renewable Energy, 177: 915–931

[6] Chen, C Lu, Y Xing, L (2021). Levelling renewable power output using hydrogen-based storage systems: A techno-economic analysis. Journal of Energy Storage, 37: 102413

[7] Chi, J Yu, H (2018). Water electrolysis based on renewable energy for hydrogen production. Chinese Journal of Catalysis, 39( 3): 390–394

[8] Fan, J L Wei, S Yang, L Wang, H Zhong, P Zhang, X (2019). Comparison of the LCOE between coal-fired power plants with CCS and main low-carbon generation technologies: Evidence from China. Energy, 176: 143–155

[9] Feng, Z Niu, W Cheng, C Zhou, J Yang, T (2022). China’s hydropower energy system toward carbon neutrality. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 9( 4): 677–682

[10] Giddey, S Kulkarni, A Badwal, S (2015). Low emission hydrogen generation through carbon assisted electrolysis. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 40( 1): 70–74

[11] Hart, A Leeke, G Greaves, M Wood, J (2014). Down-hole heavy crude oil upgrading by CAPRI: Effect of hydrogen and methane gases upon upgrading and coke formation. Fuel, 119: 226–235

[12] Holl, M Rausch, L Pelz, P F (2017). New methods for new systems: How to find the techno-economically optimal hydrogen conversion system. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 42( 36): 22641–22654

[13] Khouya, A (2020). Levelized costs of energy and hydrogen of wind farms and concentrated photovoltaic thermal systems: A case study in Morocco. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 45( 56): 31632–31650

[14] Kong, L Li, L Cai, G Liu, C Ma, P Bian, Y Ma, T (2021). Techno-economic analysis of hydrogen energy for renewable energy power smoothing. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 46( 3): 2847–2861

[15] Lockley, A von Hippel, T (2021). The carbon dioxide removal potential of Liquid Air Energy Storage: A high-level technical and economic appraisal. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 8( 3): 456–464

[16] Longden, T Beck, F J Jotzo, F Andrews, R Prasad, M (2022). “Clean” hydrogen? Comparing the emissions and costs of fossil fuel versus renewable electricity based hydrogen. Applied Energy, 306: 118145

[17] Menanteau, P Quéméré, M M Le, Duigou A Le, Bastard S (2011). An economic analysis of the production of hydrogen from wind-generated electricity for use in transport applications. Energy Policy, 39( 5): 2957–2965

[18] National Energy Administration (2016). What are the disadvantages of geothermal energy? (in Chinese)

[19] National Energy Administration (2021). Summary of energy storage related policies (in Chinese)

[20] National Development and Reform Commission, National Energy Administration (2021). Guidance on Accelerating the Development of New Energy Storage (in Chinese)

[21] Nematollahi, O Alamdari, P Jahangiri, M Sedaghat, A Alemrajabi, A A (2019). A techno-economical assessment of solar/wind resources and hydrogen production: A case study with GIS maps. Energy, 175: 914–930

[22] Olateju, B Kumar, A (2016). A techno-economic assessment of hydrogen production from hydropower in Western Canada for the upgrading of bitumen from oil sands. Energy, 115: 604–614

[23] Pan, G Gu, W Qiu, H Lu, Y Zhou, S Wu, Z (2020). Bi-level mixed-integer planning for electricity-hydrogen integrated energy system considering levelized cost of hydrogen. Applied Energy, 270: 115176

[24] Rahmouni, S Negrou, B Settou, N Dominguez, J Gouareh, A (2017). Prospects of hydrogen production potential from renewable resources in Algeria. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 42( 2): 1383–1395

[25] Rezaei, M Khalilpour, K R Mohamed, M A (2021). Co-production of electricity and hydrogen from wind: A comprehensive scenario-based techno-economic analysis. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 46( 35): 18242–18256

[26] Rezaei, M Mostafaeipour, A Qolipour, M Momeni, M (2019). Energy supply for water electrolysis systems using wind and solar energy to produce hydrogen: A case study of Iran. Frontiers in Energy, 13( 3): 539–550

[27] Saba, S M Müller, M Robinius, M Stolten, D (2018). The investment costs of electrolysis: A comparison of cost studies from the past 30 years. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 43( 3): 1209–1223

[28] Sanchez, V M Chavez-Ramirez, A Duron-Torres, S M Hernandez, J Arriaga, L Ramirez, J M (2014). Techno-economical optimization based on swarm intelligence algorithm for a stand-alone wind-photovoltaic-hydrogen power system at south-east region of Mexico. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 39( 29): 16646–16655

[29] Shah, S A A (2020). Feasibility study of renewable energy sources for developing the hydrogen economy in Pakistan. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 45( 32): 15841–15854

[30] Squadrito, G Nicita, A Maggio, G (2021). A size-dependent financial evaluation of green hydrogen-oxygen co-production. Renewable Energy, 163: 2165–2177

[31] State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of the State Council (2021). Guidance on Promoting the High-Quality Development of Central Enterprises and Doing a Good Job in Carbon Peak and Carbon Neutralization (in Chinese)

[32] Timilsina, G R (2021). Are renewable energy technologies cost competitive for electricity generation?. Renewable Energy, 180: 658–672

[33] Xu, C Ke, Y Li, Y Chu, H Wu, Y (2020). Data-driven configuration optimization of an off-grid wind/PV/hydrogen system based on modified NSGA-II and CRITIC-TOPSIS. Energy Conversion and Management, 215: 112892

[34] Yang, Y Wang, H Löschel, A Zhou, P (2022). Energy transition toward carbon-neutrality in China: Pathways, implications and uncertainties. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 9( 3): 358–372

[35] Yates, J Daiyan, R Patterson, R Egan, R Amal, R Ho-Baille, A Chang, N L (2020). Techno-economic analysis of hydrogen electrolysis from off-grid stand-alone photovoltaics incorporating uncertainty analysis. Cell Reports Physical Science, 1( 10): 100209

[36] Yukesh, Kannah R Kavitha, S Preethi, Karthikeyan O Parthiba, G Kumar, N V Dai-Viet, Banu J (2021). Techno-economic assessment of various hydrogen production methods: A review. Bioresource Technology, 319: 124175

[37] Zhang, Y Wei, W (2020). Decentralized coordination control of PV generators, storage battery, hydrogen production unit and fuel cell in islanded DC microgrid. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 45( 15): 8243–8256

[38] Zhao, H Yang, R Wang, C Pabasara, W Wijeratne, U Liu, C Xue, X Abdeen, N (2019). Effects of design parameters on rooftop photovoltaic economics in the urban environment: A case study in Melbourne, Australia. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 6( 3): 351–367

[39] Zhou, D Ding, H Wang, Q Su, B (2021). Literature review on renewable energy development and China’s roadmap. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 8( 2): 212–222

[40] Zhou, K Zhang, Z Liu, L Yang, S (2022). Energy storage resources management: Planning, operation, and business model. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 9( 3): 373–391

[41] Ziegler, M S Mueller, J M Pereira, G D Song, J Ferrara, M Chiang, Y M Trancik, J E (2019). Storage requirements and costs of shaping renewable energy toward grid decarbonization. Joule, 3( 9): 2134–2153

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2023 Higher Education Press