Omnichannel retail operations with ship-to-store and ship-from-store options under supply disruption

Abstract

Omnichannel retailing strategies are widely used in practice and have been extensively studied in recent years, but few studies have explored omnichannel retailing operations in response to supply disruption in the post-pandemic era. To fill this gap, this study explores whether the adoption of omnichannel fulfillment options (i.e., ship-from-store and ship-to-store options) can mitigate the risk of supply disruption in a supply chain where a retailer orders products from a reliable supplier and a risky supplier, respectively. Under the omnichannel retailing strategy, the retailer’s order quantity from the risky supplier may increase or decrease while that from the reliable supplier may increase. Interestingly, it is possible to achieve a win–win–win outcome when the supply disruption risk is high and the market share of the channel offered by the risky supplier is low. Moreover, the entire supply chain benefits from the omnichannel retailing strategy even if it faces a high level of disruption risk.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

supply chain disruption / omnichannel fulfillment option / ship-from-store / ship-to-store

References

[1] Ang, E Iancu, D A Swinney, R (2017). Disruption risk and optimal sourcing in multitier supply networks. Management Science, 63( 8): 2397–2419

[2] Anupindi, R Akella, R (1993). Diversification under supply uncertainty. Management Science, 39( 8): 944–963

[3] Bayram, A Cesaret, B (2021). Order fulfillment policies for ship-from-store implementation in omni-channel retailing. European Journal of Operational Research, 294( 3): 987–1002

[4] Belhadi, A Kamble, S S Venkatesh, M Chiappetta Jabbour, C J Benkhati, I (2022). Building supply chain resilience and efficiency through additive manufacturing: An ambidextrous perspective on the dynamic capability view. International Journal of Production Economics, 249: 108516

[5] Bell, D R Gallino, S Moreno, A (2018). Offline showrooms in omnichannel retail: Demand and operational benefits. Management Science, 64( 4): 1629–1651

[6] Cachon, G P Swinney, R (2009). Purchasing, pricing, and quick response in the presence of strategic consumers. Management Science, 55( 3): 497–511

[7] Chen, F Zheng, Y S (1994). Lower bounds for multi-echelon stochastic inventory systems. Management Science, 40( 11): 1426–1443

[8] Chen, J Sohal, A S Prajogo, D I (2013). Supply chain operational risk mitigation: A collaborative approach. International Journal of Production Research, 51( 7): 2186–2199

[9] Dada, M Petruzzi, N C Schwarz, L B (2007). A newsvendor’s procurement problem when suppliers are unreliable. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 9( 1): 9–32

[10] Darom, N A Hishamuddin, H Ramli, R Mat Nopiah, Z (2018). An inventory model of supply chain disruption recovery with safety stock and carbon emission consideration. Journal of Cleaner Production, 197: 1011–1021

[11] DeCroix, G A (2013). Inventory management for an assembly system subject to supply disruptions. Management Science, 59( 9): 2079–2092

[12] DerryT (2020). 75% of companies report supply chain disruption. Online Report

[13] Dong, L Tang, S Y Tomlin, B (2018). Production chain disruptions: Inventory, preparedness, and insurance. Production and Operations Management, 27( 7): 1251–1270

[14] Du, S Wang, L Hu, L (2019). Omnichannel management with consumer disappointment aversion. International Journal of Production Economics, 215: 84–101

[15] Dzyabura, D Jagabathula, S (2018). Offline assortment optimization in the presence of an online channel. Management Science, 64( 6): 2767–2786

[16] El Baz, J Ruel, S (2021). Can supply chain risk management practices mitigate the disruption impacts on supply chains’ resilience and robustness? Evidence from an empirical survey in a COVID-19 outbreak era. International Journal of Production Economics, 233: 107972

[17] Gao, F Su, X (2017a). Omnichannel retail operations with buy-online-and-pick-up-in-store. Management Science, 63( 8): 2478–2492

[18] Gao, F Su, X (2017b). Online and offline information for omnichannel retailing. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 19( 1): 84–98

[19] Gao, Y Feng, Z Zhang, S (2021). Managing supply chain resilience in the era of VUCA. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 8( 3): 465–470

[20] Gümüş, M Ray, S Gurnani, H (2012). Supply-side story: Risks, guarantees, competition, and information asymmetry. Management Science, 58( 9): 1694–1714

[21] He, Y Xu, Q Shao, Z (2021). “Ship-from-Store” strategy in platform retailing. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 145: 102153

[22] He, Y Xu, Q Wu, P (2020). Omnichannel retail operations with refurbished consumer returns. International Journal of Production Research, 58( 1): 271–290

[23] Hu, M Xu, X Xue, W Yang, Y (2022). Demand pooling in omnichannel operations. Management Science, 68( 2): 883–894

[24] Ishfaq, R Raja, U (2018). Evaluation of order fulfillment options in retail supply chains. Decision Sciences, 49( 3): 487–521

[25] Ivanov, D (2020). Predicting the impacts of epidemic outbreaks on global supply chains: A simulation-based analysis on the coronavirus outbreak (COVID-19/SARS-CoV-2) case. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 136: 101922

[26] Jin, M Li, G Cheng, T C E (2018). Buy online and pick up in-store: Design of the service area. European Journal of Operational Research, 268( 2): 613–623

[27] Kong, R Luo, L Chen, L Keblis, M (2020). The effects of BOPS implementation under different pricing strategies in omnichannel retailing. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 141: 102014

[28] Kumar, M Basu, P Avittathur, B (2018). Pricing and sourcing strategies for competing retailers in supply chains under disruption risk. European Journal of Operational Research, 265( 2): 533–543

[29] Li, G Li, L Zhou, Y Guan, X (2017). Capacity restoration in a decentralized assembly system with supply disruption risks. International Transactions in Operational Research, 24( 4): 763–782

[30] Li, G Liu, M Bian, Y Sethi, S P (2020). Guarding against disruption risk by contracting under information asymmetry. Decision Sciences, 51( 6): 1521–1559

[31] Li, G Liu, M Zheng, H (2022). Subsidization or diversification? Mitigating supply disruption with manufacturer information sharing. Omega, 112: 102670

[32] Li, M Zhang, X Dan, B (2021). Cooperative advertising and pricing in an O2O supply chain with buy-online-and-pick-up-in-store. International Transactions in Operational Research, 28( 4): 2033–2054

[33] Li, Y Xu, L Choi, T M Govindan, K (2014). Optimal advance-selling strategy for fashionable products with opportunistic consumers returns. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems, 44( 7): 938–952

[34] Lin, X Zhou, Y W Hou, R (2021). Impact of a “buy-online-and-pickup-in-store” channel on price and quality decisions in a supply chain. European Journal of Operational Research, 294( 3): 922–935

[35] Liu, Z Li, M Zhai, X (2022). Managing supply chain disruption threat via a strategy combining pricing and self-protection. International Journal of Production Economics, 247: 108452

[36] Lücker, F Chopra, S Seifert, R W (2021). Mitigating product shortage due to disruptions in multi-stage supply chains. Production and Operations Management, 30( 4): 941–964

[37] Lücker, F Seifert, R W Biçer, I (2019). Roles of inventory and reserve capacity in mitigating supply chain disruption risk. International Journal of Production Research, 57( 4): 1238–1249

[38] Mahajan, K Tomar, S (2021). COVID-19 and supply chain disruption: Evidence from food markets in India. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 103( 1): 35–52

[39] Mahar, S Wright, P D (2017). In-store pickup and returns for a dual channel retailer. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 64( 4): 491–504

[40] Mandal, P Basu, P Saha, K (2021). Forays into omnichannel: An online retailer’s strategies for managing product returns. European Journal of Operational Research, 292( 2): 633–651

[41] Modgil, S Singh, R K Hannibal, C (2022). Artificial intelligence for supply chain resilience: Learning from COVID-19. International Journal of Logistics Management, 33( 4): 1246–1268

[42] Moosavi, J Fathollahi-Fard, A M Dulebenets, M A (2022). Supply chain disruption during the COVID-19 pandemic: Recognizing potential disruption management strategies. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 75: 102983

[43] Nageswaran, L Cho, S H Scheller-Wolf, A (2020). Consumer return policies in omnichannel operations. Management Science, 66( 12): 5558–5575

[44] Naghshineh, B Carvalho, H (2022). The implications of additive manufacturing technology adoption for supply chain resilience: A systematic search and review. International Journal of Production Economics, 247: 108387

[45] Pang, Z Xiao, W Zhao, X (2021). Preorder price guarantee in e-commerce. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 23( 1): 123–138

[46] Park, J Dayarian, I Montreuil, B (2021). Showcasing optimization in omnichannel retailing. European Journal of Operational Research, 294( 3): 895–905

[47] Parlar, M Berkin, D (1991). Future supply uncertainty in EOQ models. Naval Research Logistics, 38( 1): 107–121

[48] Qi, L Lee, K (2015). Supply chain risk mitigations with expedited shipping. Omega, 57: 98–113

[49] Qi, X Bard, J F Yu, G (2004). Supply chain coordination with demand disruptions. Omega, 32( 4): 301–312

[50] Queiroz, M M Telles, R Bonilla, S H (2019). Blockchain and supply chain management integration: A systematic review of the literature. Supply Chain Management, 25( 2): 241–254

[51] Remko, V H (2020). Research opportunities for a more resilient post-COVID-19 supply chain: Closing the gap between research findings and industry practice. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 40( 4): 341–355

[52] RoggioA (2017). Ship-from-store fulfillment a must for brick-and-click retailers. Online Report

[53] Saha, K Bhattacharya, S (2021). Buy online and pick up in-store: Implications for the store inventory. European Journal of Operational Research, 294( 3): 906–921

[54] Saleheen, F Habib, M M (2022). Global supply chain disruption management post COVID-19. American Journal of Industrial and Business Management, 12( 3): 376–389

[55] Serkan Akturk, M Ketzenberg, M Heim, G R (2018). Assessing impacts of introducing ship-to-store service on sales and returns in omnichannel retailing: A data analytics study. Journal of Operations Management, 61( 1): 15–45

[56] Shao, X F (2012). Demand-side reactive strategies for supply disruptions in a multiple-product system. International Journal of Production Economics, 136( 1): 241–252

[57] Shekarian, M Mellat Parast, M (2021). An Integrative approach to supply chain disruption risk and resilience management: A literature review. International Journal of Logistics Research and Applications, 24( 5): 427–455

[58] Tomlin, B (2006). On the value of mitigation and contingency strategies for managing supply chain disruption risks. Management Science, 52( 5): 639–657

[59] Tomlin, B Wang, Y (2005). On the value of mix flexibility and dual sourcing in unreliable newsvendor networks. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 7( 1): 37–57

[60] van Hoek, R Lacity, M (2020). How the pandemic is pushing blockchain forward. Harvard Business Review, 27

[61] Wang, Y Gilland, W Tomlin, B (2010). Mitigating supply risk: Dual sourcing or process improvement?. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 12( 3): 489–510

[62] Wu, T Blackhurst, J O’Grady, P (2007). Methodology for supply chain disruption analysis. International Journal of Production Research, 45( 7): 1665–1682

[63] Xu, Q Shao, Z He, Y (2021). Effect of the buy-online-and-pickup-in-store option on pricing and ordering decisions during online shopping carnivals. International Transactions in Operational Research, 28( 5): 2496–2517

[64] Yan, S Hua, Z Bian, Y (2020). Does retailer benefit from implementing “online-to-store” channel in a competitive market?. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 67( 2): 496–512

[65] Yang, D Qi, E Li, Y (2015). Quick response and supply chain structure with strategic consumers. Omega, 52: 1–14

[66] Yang, D Zhang, X (2020). Quick response and omnichannel retail operations with the ship-to-store program. International Transactions in Operational Research, 27( 6): 3007–3030

[67] Yoon, J Talluri, S Rosales, C (2020). Procurement decisions and information sharing under multi-tier disruption risk in a supply chain. International Journal of Production Research, 58( 5): 1362–1383

[68] Zhang, S Zhang, J (2020). Agency selling or reselling: E-tailer information sharing with supplier offline entry. European Journal of Operational Research, 280( 1): 134–151

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Higher Education Press