Systematic literature review on smart contracts in the construction industry: Potentials, benefits, and challenges

Abstract

The development of digital transformation in the construction industry has led to the increasing adoption of smart contracts. As programmable applications to automatically write, verify, and enforce transaction conditions, smart contracts can be used in different areas mainly to improve automation level, information security, and built digital environment enhancement. However, the smart contract is commonly mentioned as a blockchain appendage, while its unique connotation and value in the construction industry have not been recognized. Therefore, this study carries out a systematic review based on 81 research articles published from 2014 to 2021 on smart contract applications in construction to explore and highlight their potentials under domain-specific requirements. Results are analyzed according to research type categorization and domain codification. Eight research domains are identified, where the three most highly explored domains are contract and payment, supply chain and logistics, and information management. The integration of smart contracts with other innovative concepts and advanced technologies is analyzed. The applicability, benefits, and challenges of smart contract applications regarding different research domains are discussed.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

smart contracts / blockchain / construction industry / BIM / systematic review

References

[1] Agbo,C C Mahmoud,Q H Eklund,J M 2019. Blockchain technology in healthcare: A systematic review. Health Care, 7( 2): 56

[2] Ahmadisheykhsarmast,S Sonmez,R 2020. A smart contract system for security of payment of construction contracts. Automation in Construction, 120: 103401

[3] Arditi,D Mochtar,K 2000. Trends in productivity improvement in the US construction industry. Construction Management and Economics, 18( 1): 15– 27

[4] Badi,S Ochieng,E Nasaj,M Papadaki,M 2021. Technological, organisational and environmental determinants of smart contracts adoption: UK construction sector viewpoint. Construction Management and Economics, 39( 1): 36– 54

[5] BaekC , LeeD, ParkC(2020). Blockchain based framework for verifying the adequacy of scaffolding installation. In: Proceedings of the 37th International Symposium on Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC). Kitakyushu, 425–432

[6] Beach,T H Hippolyte,J L Rezgui,Y 2020. Towards the adoption of automated regulatory compliance checking in the built environment. Automation in Construction, 118: 103285

[7] ButerinV (2014). A next-generation smart contract and decentralized application platform. Ethereum White Paper

[8] Cai,W Wang,Z Ernst,J B Hong,Z Feng,C Leung,V C M 2018. Decentralized applications: The blockchain-empowered software system. IEEE Access, 6: 53019– 53033

[9] Calvetti,D Magalhães,P N M Sujan,S F Gonçalves,M C Campos,de Sousa H J 2020. Challenges of upgrading craft workforce into Construction 4.0: Framework and agreements. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers— Management, Procurement and Law, 173( 4): 158– 165

[10] CardeiraH(2015). Smart contracts and possible applications to the construction industry. In: New Perspectives in Construction Law Conference. Bucharest, 35–39

[11] Chan,D W Olawumi,T O Ho,A M 2019. Perceived benefits of and barriers to Building Information Modelling (BIM) implementation in construction: The case of Hong Kong. Journal of Building Engineering, 25: 100764

[12] Chong,H Y Diamantopoulos,A 2020. Integrating advanced technologies to uphold security of payment: Data flow diagram. Automation in Construction, 114: 103158

[13] Craveiro,F Duarte,J P Bartolo,H Bartolo,P J 2019. Additive manufacturing as an enabling technology for digital construction: A perspective on Construction 4. 0. Automation in Construction, 103: 251– 267

[14] Darabseh,M Martins,J P 2020. Risks and opportunities for reforming construction with blockchain: Bibliometric study. Civil Engineering Journal, 6( 6): 1204– 1217

[15] Das,M Luo,H Cheng,J C 2020. Securing interim payments in construction projects through a blockchain-based framework. Automation in Construction, 118: 103284

[16] DasM, TaoX, ChengJ C P(2021). A secure and distributed construction document management system using blockchain. In: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Computing in Civil and Building Engineering (ICCCBE). Cham: Springer, 850–862

[17] Di GiudaG M, GianaP E, PattiniG(2020a). The shortening and the automation of payments: The potentiality of smart contract in the AECO sector. In: 5th Australasia and South-East Asia Structural Engineering and Construction Conference. Christchurch: ISEC Press, CON-12

[18] DiGiuda G M PattiniG SeghezziE SchievanoM PaleariF (2020b). The construction contract execution through the integration of blockchain technology. In: Daniotti B, Gianinetto M, Della Torre S, eds. Digital Transformation of the Design, Construction and Management Processes of the Built Environment. Cham: Springer, 27– 36

[19] DounasT JabiW LombardiD (2020). Smart contracts for decentralised building information modelling. In: Proceedings of 38th Education and Research in Computer Aided Architectural Design in Europe (eCAADe) Conference. Berlin: 565– 574

[20] DounasT LombardiD JabiW (2019). Towards Blockchains for architectural design: Consensus mechanisms for collaboration in BIM. In: Proceedings of the 37th Education and Research in Computer Aided Architectural Design in Europe (eCAADe) Conference. Porto: 267– 274

[21] Dounas,T Lombardi,D Jabi,W 2021. Framework for decentralised architectural design BIM and Blockchain integration. International Journal of Architectural Computing, 19( 2): 157– 173

[22] Elghaish,F Abrishami,S Hosseini,M R 2020. Integrated project delivery with blockchain: An automated financial system. Automation in Construction, 114: 103182

[23] Erri Pradeep,A S Yiu,T W Zou,Y Amor,R 2021. Blockchain-aided information exchange records for design liability control and improved security. Automation in Construction, 126: 103667

[24] Fan,S L 2014. Intellectual property rights in building information modeling application in Taiwan. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 140( 3): 4013058

[25] Fernandez-Carames,T M Fraga-Lamas,P 2019. A review on the application of blockchain to the next generation of cybersecure Industry 4. 0 smart factories. IEEE Access, 7: 45201– 45218

[26] GötzC S KarlssonP YitmenI (2020). Exploring applicability, interoperability and integrability of Blockchain-based digital twins for asset life cycle management. Smart and Sustainable Built Environment, in press, doi:10.1108/SASBE-08-2020-0115

[27] GurgunA P KocK (2021). Administrative risks challenging the adoption of smart contracts in construction projects. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, in press,

[28] Gürkaynak,G Yılmaz,İ Yeşilaltay,B Bengi,B 2018. Intellectual property law and practice in the blockchain realm. Computer Law & Security Review, 34( 4): 847– 862

[29] Hamledari,H Fischer,M 2021a. The application of blockchain-based crypto assets for integrating the physical and financial supply chains in the construction & engineering industry. Automation in Construction, 127: 103711

[30] Hamledari,H Fischer,M 2021b. Construction payment automation using blockchain-enabled smart contracts and reality capture technologies. Automation in Construction, 132: 103926

[31] Hamledari,H Fischer,M 2021c. Measuring the impact of blockchain and smart contract on construction supply chain visibility. Advanced Engineering Informatics, 50: 101444

[32] Hamledari,H Fischer,M 2021d. Role of blockchain-enabled smart contracts in automating construction progress payments. Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction, 13( 1): 4520038

[33] Hunhevicz,J J Hall,D M 2020. Do you need a blockchain in construction? Use case categories and decision framework for DLT design options.. Advanced Engineering Informatics, 45: 101094

[34] HunheviczJ J, Schraner T, HallD M(2020). Incentivizing high-quality data sets in construction using blockchain: A feasibility study in the Swiss industry. In: Proceedings of the 37th International Symposium on Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC). Kitakyushu, 1291–1298

[35] Kifokeris,D Koch,C 2020. A conceptual digital business model for construction logistics consultants, featuring a sociomaterial blockchain solution for integrated economic, material and information flows. Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 25( 29): 500– 521

[36] KiuM S ChiaF C WongP F (2020). Exploring the potentials of blockchain application in construction industry: A systematic review. International Journal of Construction Management, in press, doi:10.1080/15623599.2020.1833436

[37] Koc,K Gurgun,A P 2020. Drivers for construction stakeholders to adopt smart contracts. Journal of Construction Engineering, Management and Innovation, 3( 2): 101– 112

[38] Kochovski,P Gec,S Stankovski,V Bajec,M Drobintsev,P D 2019. Trust management in a blockchain based fog computing platform with trustless smart oracles. Future Generation Computer Systems, 101: 747– 759

[39] Kochovski,P Stankovski,V 2021. Building applications for smart and safe construction with the DECENTER Fog Computing and Brokerage Platform. Automation in Construction, 124: 103562

[40] Kumar,A Abhishek,K Bhushan,B Chakraborty,C 2021. Secure access control for manufacturing sector with application of Ethereum blockchain. Peer-to-Peer Networking and Applications, 14( 5): 3058– 3074

[41] LambK (2018). Blockchain and smart contracts: What the AEC sector needs to know. CDBB_REP_003. London: Centre for Digital Built Britain, University of Cambridge

[42] Li,J Greenwood,D Kassem,M 2019a. Blockchain in the built environment and construction industry: A systematic review, conceptual models and practical use cases. Automation in Construction, 102: 288– 307

[43] Li,J Kassem,M 2021. Applications of distributed ledger technology (DLT) and Blockchain-enabled smart contracts in construction. Automation in Construction, 132: 103955

[44] LiJ, KassemM, CiribiniA, Bolpagni M(2019b). A proposed approach integrating DLT, BIM, IoT and smart contracts: Demonstration using a simulated installation task. In: 2nd International Conference on Smart Infrastructure and Construction (ICSIC). Cambridge: ICE Publishing, 275–282

[45] LiJ, KassemM, WatsonR(2020). A blockchain and smart contract-based framework to increase traceability of built assets. In: Proceedings of 37th CIB W78 Information Technology for Construction Conference. São Paulo, 347–362

[46] Liberati,A Altman,D G Tetzlaff,J Mulrow,C Gøtzsche,P C Ioannidis,J P A Clarke,M Devereaux,P J Kleijnen,J Moher,D 2009. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: Explanation and elaboration. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 62( 10): e1– e34

[47] Liu,Z Jiang,L Osmani,M Demian,P 2019. Building Information Management (BIM) and Blockchain (BC) for sustainable building design information management framework. Electronics, 8( 7): 724

[48] Lu,W Li,X Xue,F Zhao,R Wu,L Yeh,A G 2021. Exploring smart construction objects as blockchain oracles in construction supply chain management. Automation in Construction, 129: 103816

[49] Lu,Y Li,Y Skibniewski,M Wu,Z Wang,R Le,Y 2015. Information and communication technology applications in architecture, engineering, and construction organizations: A 15-year review. Journal of Management Engineering, 31( 1): A4014010

[50] LuoH, DasM, WangJ, Cheng J C P(2019). Construction payment automation through smart contract-based blockchain framework. In: Proceedings of the 36th International Symposium on Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC). Banff, 1254–1260

[51] MaA (2020). Emerging legal issues in blockchain for construction supply chains. In: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Vision, Image and Signal Processing. Bangkok: ACM, 1– 7

[52] Mason,J 2017. Intelligent contracts and the construction industry. Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction, 9( 3): 4517012

[53] McNamaraA (2020). Automating the chaos: Intelligent construction contracts. In: Shirowzhan S, Zhang K, eds. Smart Cities and Construction Technologies. London: IntechOpen

[54] McNamara,A Sepasgozar,S M 2021. Intelligent contract adoption in the construction industry: Concept development. Automation in Construction, 122: 103452

[55] NanayakkaraS PereraS SenaratneS ( 2019). Stakeholders’ perspective on blockchain and smart contracts solutions for construction supply chains. In: CIB World Building Congress. Hong Kong, 17– 21

[56] NawariN O ( 2021). Blockchain technologies: Hyperledger fabric in BIM work processes. In: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Computing in Civil and Building Engineering (ICCCBE). Cham: Springer, 813– 823

[57] Nawari,N O Ravindran,S 2019a. Blockchain and Building Information Modeling (BIM): Review and applications in post-disaster recovery. Buildings, 9( 6): 149

[58] Nawari,N O Ravindran,S 2019b. Blockchain technology and BIM process: Review and potential applications. Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 24( 12): 209– 238

[59] Ølnes,S Ubacht,J Janssen,M 2017. Blockchain in government: Benefits and implications of distributed ledger technology for information sharing. Government Information Quarterly, 34( 3): 355– 364

[60] Opoku,D G J Perera,S Osei-Kyei,R Rashidi,M 2021. Digital twin application in the construction industry: A literature review. Journal of Building Engineering, 40: 102726

[61] Palachuk,G 2020. The new decade of construction contracts: Technological and climate considerations for owners, designers, and builders. Seattle Journal of Technology, Environmental & Innovation Law, 11( 1): 7

[62] PattiniG Di GiudaG M TagliabueL C ( 2020). Blockchain application for contract schemes in the construction industry. In: Proceedings of International Structural Engineering and Construction. Limassol: ISEC Press, AAE-21

[63] Perera,S Nanayakkara,S Rodrigo,M Senaratne,S Weinand,R 2020. Blockchain technology: Is it hype or real in the construction industry?. Journal of Industrial Information Integration, 17: 100125

[64] Perrier,N Bled,A Bourgault,M Cousin,N Danjou,C Pellerin,R Roland,T 2020. Construction 4.0: A survey of research trends. Journal of Information Technology in Construction, 25( 24): 416– 437

[65] Pinna,A Baralla,G Lallai,G Marchesi,M Tonelli,R 2020. Design of a sustainable blockchain-oriented software for building workers management. Frontiers in Blockchain, 3: 38

[66] Pishdad-Bozorgi,P Yoon,J H Dass,N 2020. Blockchain-based information sharing: A new opportunity for construction supply chains. EPiC Series in Built Environment, 1: 274– 282

[67] Qian,X Papadonikolaki,E 2021. Shifting trust in construction supply chains through blockchain technology. Engineering, Construction, and Architectural Management, 28( 2): 584– 602

[68] Ramachandra,T Rotimi,J O B 2015. Mitigating payment problems in the construction industry through analysis of construction payment disputes. Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction, 7( 1): A4514005

[69] RaslanA KapogiannisG CheshmehzangiA TizaniW ToweyD (2020). A framework for assembling Asset Information Models (AIMs) through permissioned blockchain. In: IEEE 44th Annual Computers, Software, and Applications Conference. Madrid, 529– 534

[70] Sacks,R 2016. What constitutes good production flow in construction?. Construction Management and Economics, 34( 9): 641– 656

[71] SawhneyA RileyM IrizarryJ (2020). Construction 4.0: Introduction and overview. In: Sawhney A, Riley M, Irizarry J, eds. Construction 4.0: An Innovation Platform for the Built Environment. London: Routledge, 3– 22

[72] Shemov,G Garcia de Soto,B Alkhzaimi,H 2020. Blockchain applied to the construction supply chain: A case study with threat model. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 7( 4): 564– 577

[73] Sheng,D Ding,L Zhong,B Love,P E Luo,H Chen,J 2020. Construction quality information management with blockchains. Automation in Construction, 120: 103373

[74] ShojaeiA FloodI MoudH I HatamiM ZhangX ( 2020). An implementation of smart contracts by integrating BIM and blockchain. In: Proceedings of the Future Technologies Conference (FTC). Cham: Springer, 519– 527

[75] Snyder,H 2019. Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of Business Research, 104: 333– 339

[76] SrećkovićM ŠibenikG BreitfußD PreindlT KastnerW (2021). Analysis of design phase processes with BIM for blockchain implementation. In: Proceedings of 13th European Conference on Product & Process Modelling (ECPPM) — eWork and eBusiness in Architecture, Engineering and Construction. London: CRC Press, 125– 131

[77] Staples,M Niazi,M 2007. Experiences using systematic review guidelines. Journal of Systems and Software, 80( 9): 1425– 1437

[78] SzaboN ( 1994). Smart contracts. Available at: fon.hum.uva.nl/rob/Courses/InformationInSpeech/CDROM/Literature/LOTwinterschool2006/szabo.best.vwh.net/smart.contracts.html

[79] Tao,X Das,M Liu,Y Cheng,J C 2021. Distributed common data environment using blockchain and Interplanetary File System for secure BIM-based collaborative design. Automation in Construction, 130: 103851

[80] Tezel,A Febrero,P Papadonikolaki,E Yitmen,I 2021. Insights into blockchain implementation in construction: Models for supply chain management. Journal of Management Engineering, 37( 4): 4021038

[81] Tezel,A Papadonikolaki,E Yitmen,I Hilletofth,P 2020. Preparing construction supply chains for blockchain technology: An investigation of its potential and future directions. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 7( 4): 547– 563

[82] Tian,Y Lu,Z Adriaens,P Minchin,R E Caithness,A Woo,J 2020. Finance infrastructure through blockchain-based tokenization. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 7( 4): 485– 499

[83] Tiwari,A Batra,U 2021. Blockchain enabled reparations in smart buildings cyber physical system. Defence Science Journal, 71( 4): 491– 498

[84] TurkŽ ( 2021). Structured analysis of ICT adoption in the European construction industry. International Journal of Construction Management, in press,

[85] VrijhoefR KoskelaL ( 2005). Revisiting the three peculiarities of production in construction. In: 13th International Group for Lean Construction Conference. Sydney, 19– 27

[86] Wan,P K Huang,L Holtskog,H 2020. Blockchain-enabled information sharing within a supply chain: A systematic literature review. IEEE Access, 8: 49645– 49656

[87] Wang,B 2018. Addressing financial fragility in the construction industry through the blockchain and smart construction contracts. Australian Construction Law Newsletter, 30( 1–2): 116– 123

[88] Wang,C Yap,J B H Wood,L C Abdul-Rahman,H 2019a. Knowledge modelling for contract disputes and change control. Production Planning and Control, 30( 8): 650– 664

[89] Wang,S Ding,W Li,J Yuan,Y Ouyang,L Wang,F Y 2019b. Decentralized autonomous organizations: Concept, model, and applications. IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems, 6( 5): 870– 878

[90] Wang,S Ouyang,L Yuan,Y Ni,X Han,X Wang,F Y 2019c. Blockchain-enabled smart contracts: Architecture, applications, and future trends. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems, 49( 11): 2266– 2277

[91] Wang,Z Wang,T Hu,H Gong,J Ren,X Xiao,Q 2020. Blockchain-based framework for improving supply chain traceability and information sharing in precast construction. Automation in Construction, 111: 103063

[92] Wieringa,R Maiden,N Mead,N Rolland,C 2006. Requirements engineering paper classification and evaluation criteria: A proposal and a discussion. Requirements Engineering, 11( 1): 102– 107

[93] Wu,H Zhong,B Li,H Guo,J Wang,Y 2021. On-site construction quality inspection using blockchain and smart contracts. Journal of Management Engineering, 37( 6): 4021065

[94] Xue,F Lu,W 2020. A semantic differential transaction approach to minimizing information redundancy for BIM and blockchain integration. Automation in Construction, 118: 103270

[95] Yang,R Wakefield,R Lyu,S Jayasuriya,S Han,F Yi,X Yang,X Amarasinghe,G Chen,S 2020. Public and private blockchain in construction business process and information integration. Automation in Construction, 118: 103276

[96] YeX König M ( 2021). Framework for automated billing in the construction industry using BIM and smart contracts. In: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Computing in Civil and Building Engineering (ICCCBE). Cham: Springer, 824– 838

[97] YeX Sigalov K KönigM ( 2020). Integrating BIM- and cost-included information container with blockchain for construction automated payment using billing model and smart contracts. In: Proceedings of the 37th International Symposium on Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC). Kitakyushu, 1388– 1395

[98] Zhang,Z Yuan,Z Ni,G Lin,H Lu,Y 2020. The quality traceability system for prefabricated buildings using blockchain: An integrated framework. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 7( 4): 528– 546

[99] Zhong,B Wu,H Ding,L Luo,H Luo,Y Pan,X 2020. Hyperledger fabric-based consortium blockchain for construction quality information management. Frontiers of Engineering Management, 7( 4): 512– 527

Open Access

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.

The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2022 The Author(s). This article is published with open access at link.springer.com and journal.hep.com.cn