Assessing the Effect of Global Travel and Contact Restrictions on Mitigating the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

Travel restrictions and physical distancing have been implemented across the world to mitigate the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, but studies are needed to understand their effectiveness across regions and time. Based on the population mobility metrics derived from mobile phone geolocation data across 135 countries or territories during the first wave of the pandemic in 2020, we built a metapopulation epidemiological model to measure the effect of travel and contact restrictions on containing COVID-19 outbreaks across regions. We found that if these interventions had not been deployed, the cumulative number of cases could have shown a 97-fold (interquartile range 79–116) increase, as of May 31, 2020. However, their effectiveness depended upon the timing, duration, and intensity of the interventions, with variations in case severity seen across populations, regions, and seasons. Additionally, before effective vaccines are widely available and herd immunity is achieved, our results emphasize that a certain degree of physical distancing at the relaxation of the intervention stage will likely be needed to avoid rapid resurgences and subsequent lockdowns.

Keywords

COVID-19 / Pandemic / Population mobility / Travel restriction / Physical distancing

References

[[1]] Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic [Internet]. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2020 [cited 2020 Feb 29]. Available from: https://www.who.int/ emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019.

[[2]] Bonaccorsi G, Pierri F, Cinelli M, Flori A, Galeazzi A, Porcelli F, et al. Economic and social consequences of human mobility restrictions under COVID-19. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2020;117(27):15530–5.

[[3]] Yang J, Li J, Lai S, Ruktanonchai CW, Xing W, Carioli A, et al. Uncovering two phases of early intercontinental COVID-19 transmission dynamics. J Travel Med 2020;27(8):taaa200.

[[4]] Walker PGT, Whittaker C, Watson OJ, Baguelin M, Winskill P, Hamlet A, et al. The impact of COVID-19 and strategies for mitigation and suppression in lowand middle-income countries. Science 2020;369(6502):413–22.

[[5]] Flaxman S, Mishra S, Gandy A, Unwin HJT, Mellan TA, Coupland H, et al. Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe. Nature 2020;584(7820):257–61.

[[6]] Hu M, Lin H, Wang J, Xu C, Tatem AJ, Meng B, et al. The risk of COVID-19 transmission in train passengers: an epidemiological and modelling study. Clin Infect Dis 2020.

[[7]] Koo JR, Cook AR, Park M, Sun Y, Sun H, Lim JT, et al. Interventions to mitigate early spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Singapore: a modelling study. Lancet Infect Dis 2020;20(6):678–88.

[[8]] Cowling BJ, Ali ST, Ng TWY, Tsang TK, Li JCM, Fong MW, et al. Impact assessment of non-pharmaceutical interventions against coronavirus disease 2019 and influenza in Hong Kong: an observational study. Lancet Public Health 2020;5(5):e279–88.

[[9]] Lai S, Ruktanonchai NW, Zhou L, Prosper O, Luo W, Floyd JR, et al. Effect of nonpharmaceutical interventions to contain COVID-19 in China. Nature 2020;585 (7825):410–3.

[[10]] European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Considerations relating to social distancing measures in response to COVID-19—second update. [Internet]. Stockholm: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 27]. Available from: https://www.ecdc.europa.eu/sites/default/files/ documents/covid-19-social-distancing-measuresg-guide-second-update.pdf.

[[11]] Fong MW, Gao H, Wong JY, Xiao J, Shiu EYC, Ryu S, et al. Nonpharmaceutical measures for pandemic influenza in nonhealthcare settings–social distancing measures. Emerg Infect Dis 2020;26(5):976–84.

[[12]] Chinazzi M, Davis JT, Ajelli M, Gioannini C, Litvinova M, Merler S, et al. The effect of travel restrictions on the spread of the 2019 novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak. Science 2020;368(6489):395–400.

[[13]] Tian H, Liu Y, Li Y, Wu CH, Chen B, Kraemer MUG, et al. An investigation of transmission control measures during the first 50 days of the COVID-19 epidemic in China. Science 2020;368(6491):638–42.

[[14]] Zhang J, Litvinova M, Liang Y, Wang Y, Wang W, Zhao S, et al. Changes in contact patterns shape the dynamics of the COVID-19 outbreak. Science 2020;368(6498):1481–6.

[[15]] Haug N, Geyrhofer L, Londei A, Dervic E, Desvars-Larrive A, Loreto V, et al. Ranking the effectiveness of worldwide COVID-19 government interventions. Nat Hum Behav 2020;4(12):1303–12.

[[16]] Brauner JM, Mindermann S, Sharma M, Johnston D, Salvatier J, Gavencˇiak T, et al. Inferring the effectiveness of government interventions against COVID19. Science 2021;371(6531):eabd9338.

[[17]] Maier BF, Brockmann D. Effective containment explains subexponential growth in recent confirmed COVID-19 cases in China. Science 2020;368 (6492):742–6.

[[18]] Leung K, Wu JT, Liu Di, Leung GM. First-wave COVID-19 transmissibility and severity in China outside Hubei after controlmeasures, and second-wave scenario planning: a modelling impact assessment. Lancet 2020;395(10233):1382–93.

[[19]] Kissler SM, Tedijanto C, Goldstein E, Grad YH, Lipsitch M. Projecting the transmission dynamics of SARS-CoV-2 through the postpandemic period. Science 2020;368(6493):860–8.

[[20]] Prem K, Liu Y, Russell TW, Kucharski AJ, Eggo RM, Davies N, et al. The effect of control strategies to reduce social mixing on outcomes of the COVID-19 epidemic in Wuhan, China: a modelling study. Lancet Public Health 2020;5(5): e261–70.

[[21]] López L, Rodó X. The end of social confinement and COVID-19 re-emergence risk. Nat Hum Behav 2020;4(7):746–55.

[[22]] Pang X, Ren L, Wu S, Ma W, Yang J, Di L, et al. Cold-chain food contamination as the possible origin of COVID-19 resurgence in Beijing. Natl Sci Rev 2020;7 (12):1861–4.

[[23]] Ruktanonchai NW, Floyd JR, Lai S, Ruktanonchai CW, Sadilek A, RenteLourenco P, et al. Assessing the impact of coordinated COVID-19 exit strategies across Europe. Science 2020;369(6510):1465–70.

[[24]] Sills J, Buckee CO, Balsari S, Chan J, Crosas M, Dominici F, et al. Aggregated mobility data could help fight COVID-19. Science 2020;368(6487):145–6.

[[25]] Lai S, Farnham A, Ruktanonchai NW, Tatem AJ. Measuring mobility, disease connectivity and individual risk: a review of using mobile phone data and mHealth for travel medicine. J Travel Med 2019;26(3):taz019.

[[26]] Ruktanonchai NW, Ruktanonchai CW, Floyd JR, Tatem AJ. Using google location history data to quantify fine-scale human mobility. Int J Health Geogr 2018;17(1):28.

[[27]] Lai S, Bogoch I, Ruktanonchai N, Watts A, Lu X, Yang W, et al. Assessing spread risk of novel coronavirus within and beyond China, January–April 2020: a travel network-based modelling study. 2020. medRxiv:2020.02.04.20020479.

[[28]] Wu JT, Leung K, Leung GM. Nowcasting and forecasting the potential domestic and international spread of the 2019-nCoV outbreak: a modelling study. Lancet 2020;395(10225):689–97.

[[29]] Aktay A, Bavadekar S, Cossoul G, Davis J, Damien Desfontaines, Fabrikant A, et al. Google COVID-19 community mobility reports: anonymization process description (version 1.0). 2020. arXiv:2004.04145.

[[30]] Oliver N, Lepri B, Sterly H, Lambiotte R, Deletaille S, De Nadai M, et al. Mobile phone data for informing public health actions across the COVID-19 pandemic life cycle. Sci Adv 2020;6(23):eabc0764.

[[31]] Bassolas A, Barbosa-Filho H, Dickinson B, Dotiwalla X, Eastham P, Gallotti R, et al. Hierarchical organization of urban mobility and its connection with city livability. Nat Commun 2019;10(1):4817.

[[32]] Ardalan MR, Shoja MM. Rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis in a patient with brucellosis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 2006;21(6):1743–4.

[[33]] Rader B, Scarpino SV, Nande A, Hill AL, Adlam B, Reiner RC, et al. Crowding and the shape of COVID-19 epidemics. Nat Med 2020;26(12):1829–34.

[[34]] Wilson R, Zhang CY, Lam W, Desfontaines D, Simmons-Marengo D, Gipson B. Differentially private SQL with bounded user contribution. 2019. arXiv:1909.0191.

[[35]] Baidu Migration. Popular places to relocate during the Spring Festival travel season (destination) [Internet]. Beijing: Baidu; 2020 [cited 2020 Feb 8]. Available from: https://qianxi.baidu.com/.

[[36]] Lai S, Wangteeraprasert T, Sermkaew T, Nararak O, Binsard S, Phanawadee M, et al. Evaluation of three main tuberculosis case reporting systems in Satun Province, Thailand, 2011. Outbreak Surveill Invest Rep 2014;7(3):16–23.

[[37]] Download today’s data on the geographic distribution of COVID-19 cases worldwide [Internet]. Stockholm: European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control; 2020 [cited 2020 May 2]. Available from: https://www.ecdc.europa. eu/en/publications-data/download-todays-data-geographic-distributioncovid-19-cases-worldwide.

[[38]] [COVID-19 pandemic daily report] [Internet]. Beijing: National Health Commission of China; 2021 [cited 2021 Jan 10]. Available from: http://www. nhc.gov.cn/xcs/yqtb/list_gzbd.shtml. Chinese.

[[39]] The knowledge center for China’s experiences in response to COVID-19: prevention and control measure of COVID-19 in China [Internet]. Beijing: Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 25]. Available from: https://covid19.alliancebrh. com/covid19en/c100037/202004/abfdd96da7f340fe9e4ca8a063b0d2a6/files/ 4b92097245cb48a391ea4f6b40707ae5.pdf.

[[40]] Data in coronavirus disease (COVID-19) [Internet]. Hong Kong: Centre for Health Protection HKS; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 28]. Available from: https://data.gov.hk/ en-data/dataset/hk-dh-chpsebcddr-novel-infectious-agent.

[[41]] Special webpage against epidemics [Internet]. Beijing: Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 28]. Available from: https://www.ssm.gov.mo/apps1/PreventCOVID-19/en.aspx#clg17046.

[[42]] Yang WZ, Lan YJ, Lyu W, Leng ZW, Feng LZ, Lai SJ, et al. Establishment of multipoint trigger mechanism and multi-channel surveillance mechanism for intelligent early warning of infectious diseases in China. Chin J Epidemiol 2020;41(11):1753–7. Chinese.

[[43]] Li Q, Guan X, Wu P, Wang X, Zhou L, Tong Y, et al. Early transmission dynamics in Wuhan, China, of novel coronavirus-infected pneumonia. N Engl J Med 2020;382(13):1199–207.

[[44]] data.humdata.org [Internet]. New York: United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 28]. Available from: https://data.humdata.org/dataset/acaps-covid19-governmentmeasures-dataset.

[[45]] Wallinga J, Lipsitch M. How generation intervals shape the relationship between growth rates and reproductive numbers. Proc Biol Sci 2007;274 (1609):599–604.

[[46]] Obadia T, Haneef R, Boelle PY. The R0 package: a toolbox to estimate reproduction numbers for epidemic outbreaks. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2012;12(1):147.

[[47]] Boëlle PY, Bernillon P, Desenclos JC. A preliminary estimation of the reproduction ratio for new influenza A (H1N1) from the outbreak in Mexico, March–April 2009. Euro Surveill 2009;14(19):19205.

[[48]] Hens N, Van Ranst M, Aerts M, Robesyn E, Van Damme P, Beutels P. Estimating the effective reproduction number for pandemic influenza from notification data made publicly available in real time: a multi-country analysis for influenza A/H1N1v 2009. Vaccine 2011;29(5):896–904.

[[49]] Abbott S, Hellewell J, Thompson RN, Sherratt K, Gibbs HP, Bosse NI, et al. Estimating the time-varying reproduction number of SARS-CoV-2 using national and subnational case counts. Wellcome Open Res 2020;5:112.

[[50]] Pan A, Liu L, Wang C, Guo H, Hao X, Wang Q, et al. Association of public health interventions with the epidemiology of the COVID-19 outbreak. JAMA 2020;323(19):1915–23.

[[51]] Huang L, Zhang X, Zhang X, Wei Z, Zhang L, Xu J, et al. Rapid asymptomatic transmission of COVID-19 during the incubation period demonstrating strong infectivity in a cluster of youngsters aged 16–23 years outside Wuhan and characteristics of young patients with COVID-19: a prospective contact-tracing study. J Infect 2020;80(6):e1–13.

[[52]] Li R, Pei S, Chen B, Song Y, Zhang T, Yang W, et al. Substantial undocumented infection facilitates the rapid dissemination of novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV2). Science 2020;368(6490):489–93.

[[53]] Hellewell J, Abbott S, Gimma A, Bosse NI, Jarvis CI, Russell TW, et al. Feasibility of controlling COVID-19 outbreaks by isolation of cases and contacts. Lancet Glob Health 2020;8(4):e488–96.

[[54]] Wuhan Bureau of Statistics. Wuhan statistical yearbook 2018 [Internet]. Wuhan: Wuhan Bureau of Statistics; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 10]. Available from: http://tjj. wuhan.gov.cn/tjfw/tjnj/202004/P020200426461240969401.pdf. Chinese.

[[55]] Pezzulo C, Hornby GM, Sorichetta A, Gaughan AE, Linard C, Bird TJ, et al. Subnational mapping of population pyramids and dependency ratios in Africa and Asia. Sci Data 2017;4(1):170089.

[[56]] Global health security index [Internet]. London: Global Health Security Index; 2020 [cited 2020 Apr 25]. Available from: https://www.ghsindex.org/.

[[57]] Normile D. As normalcy returns, can China keep COVID-19 at bay? Science 2020;368(6486):18–9.

[[58]] Young BE, Ong SWX, Kalimuddin S, Low JG, Tan SY, Loh J, et al. Epidemiologic features and clinical course of patients infected with SARS-CoV-2 in Singapore. JAMA 2020;323(15):1488–94.

[[59]] Richardson S, Hirsch JS, Narasimhan M, Crawford JM, McGinn T, Davidson KW, et al. Presenting characteristics, comorbidities, and outcomes among 5700 patients hospitalized with COVID-19 in the New York City area. JAMA 2020;323(20):2052.

[[60]] Grasselli G, Zangrillo A, Zanella A, Antonelli M, Cabrini L, Castelli A, et al. Baseline characteristics and outcomes of 1591 patients infected with SARSCoV-2 admitted to ICUs of the lombardy region, Italy. JAMA 2020;323 (16):1574–81.

[[61]] Tsang TK, Wu P, Lin Y, Lau EHY, Leung GM, Cowling BJ. Effect of changing case definitions for COVID-19 on the epidemic curve and transmission parameters in Chinese mainland: a modelling study. Lancet Public Health 2020;5(5): e289–96.

[[62]] Chu DK, Akl EA, Duda S, Solo K, Yaacoub S, Schünemann HJ, et al. Physical distancing, face masks, and eye protection to prevent person-to-person transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Lancet 2020;395(10242):1973–87.

[[63]] Baker RE, Yang W, Vecchi GA, Metcalf CJE, Grenfell BT. Susceptible supply limits the role of climate in the early SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. Science 2020;369 (6501):315–9.

[[64]] Yang J, Chen X, Deng X, Chen Z, Gong H, Yan H, et al. Disease burden and clinical severity of the first pandemic wave of COVID-19. Nat Commun 2020;11(1):5411.

[[65]] Mistry D, Litvinova M, Pastore y Piontti A, Chinazzi M, Fumanelli L, Gomes MFC, et al. Inferring high-resolution human mixing patterns for disease modeling. Nat Commun 2021;12(1):323.

[[66]] Kandel N, Chungong S, Omaar A, Xing J. Health security capacities in the context of COVID-19 outbreak: an analysis of International Health Regulations annual report data from 182 countries. Lancet 2020;395(10229):1047–53.

[[67]] Alegana VA, Maina J, Ouma PO, Macharia PM, Wright J, Atkinson PM, et al. National and sub-national variation in patterns of febrile case management in sub-Saharan Africa. Nat Commun 2018;9(1):4994.

[[68]] Huang B, Wang J, Cai J, Yao S, Chan PKS, Tam TH, et al. Integrated vaccination and physical distancing interventions to prevent future COVID-19 waves in Chinese cities. Nat Hum Behav. In press.

[[69]] Ge Y, Zhang W, Liu H, Ruktanonchai CW, Hu M, Wu X, et al. Effects of worldwide interventions and vaccination on COVID-19 between waves and countries. 2021. medRxiv:2021.03.31.21254702.