Governance: Perspectives of public administration, health administration, and primary care

Abstract

Primary care governance is a concrete manifestation of health governance and public governance. This discussion article explores the concepts and concerns of governance at different levels and fields from three perspectives: public management, health management, and primary health care. During the last three decades, governance has been talked in two different directions. One is to focus on the positioning and interrelationship of government, market, and network; the other is to focus on the management, accountability, rule of law, transparency, and performance control of the public sector. WHO defines governance as ensuring that a strategic policy framework is proposed and combined with effective oversight, coalition building, governance, and attention to system design and accountability. The 2018 Astana Declaration reaffirmed the commitment to primary health care as the “cornerstone” of achieving universal health coverage. Chinese scholars proposed the “Expert Consensus on Primary Health Governance” in 2024. Countries around the world have seen a lot of research efforts on primary care governance. The author suggests China engaging more in-depth research in this area.

Keywords

Governance / Public governance / Health governance / Good governance / Government / Market / Network / Primary care

Declarations

Not applicable.

Ethical approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Availability of data and materials

Not applicable.

Competing interests

H.Y. is the editorial member of Chinese General Practice Journal, he is not envolved in the editorial review or the decision to publish this article. He declare that there are no competing interests.

Funding

Not applicable.

Authors' other information

Not applicable.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

References

[1] Central Government of the People’s Republic of China. Communique of the Third Plenary Session of the 20th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. (Chinese). 2024.

[2] Tsinghua University Institute for National Studies. Back to the original intention of governance. (Chinese). 2018. Available from: https://www.iccs.tsinghua.edu.cn/NewsSt/551.html.

[3] Joppke C. The crisis of the welfare state, collective consumption, and the rise of new social actors. Berkeley J Sociol. 1987; 32:237-260.

[4] Cleveland H. The future executive. Public Adm Rev. 1972; 32(3):247-251.

[5] Williamson O. Markets and hierarchies: analysis and antitrust implications. 1975.

[6] Powell W. Neither market nor hierarchy: network forms of organisation. Res Organ Behav. 1990; 12:295-336.

[7] Rhodes RAW. New direction in the study of policy networks. Eur J Polit Res. 1992; 21(1-2):181-205.

[8] Boyer W, Ratledge E. Delaware Politics and Government. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press; 2009.

[9] World Bank. Worldwide Governance Indicators, 2023 update. 2023 [cited 2024 Dec 11]. Available from: https://www.worldbank.org/en/publication/worldwide-governance-indicators.

[10] Institute of Linguistics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. Modern Marine Dictionary. 7th ed Chinese. Beijing: The Commercial Press; 2016.

[11] Yu JX, Ren ZT. Collaborative governance in contemporary Chinese social construction. (Chinese). Academic Monthly. 2012; 44(8):23-31.

[12] Shen JM. Modernization, governance, and the path of national development. (Chinese). Yunnan Social Sci. 2024; 2024(5):9-17.

[13] World Health Organization (WHO). Everybody’s Business - Strengthening Health Systems to Improve Health Outcomes: WHO’s Framework for Action. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2007.

[14] Card KG, Hepburn KJ. Is neoliberalism killing us: A cross-sectional study of the impact of neoliberal beliefs on health and social wellbeing in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Int J Soc Determinants Health Health Serv. 2023; 53(3):363-373.

[15] Fisher JA. Coming soon to a physician near you: medical neoliberalism and pharmaceutical clinical trials. Harvard Health Policy Rev. 2007;8(1):61-70 SpringPMID: 21572938; PMCID: PMC3092550.

[16] Ratna HN. healthcare quality. Medical neoliberalism and the decline in U.S. J Hosp Manag Health Policy. 2020;4.

[17] Kim DK. Medical professionalism in neoliberalism. J Korean Med Sci. 2019; 13(34):18 e125.

[18] Zhang ZK. On the Orientation of Medical Reform: We should not Pursue a fully Market- driven Approach. Beijing: China Union Medical College Press; 2006 Chinese.

[19] Yu D. Social Provision in Low-Income Countries: New Patterns and Emerging Trends. 1st ed. Market-based reforms and changes in China’s health care system. London: Routledge; 2001.

[20] Rothgang H, Cacace M, Frisina L. The State and Healthcare: Comparing OECD Countries. Paris: OECD; 2010.

[21] Shi RH. The development process and advancement path of modernized health governance in China. (Chinese). Study Explorat. 2024; 2024(5):132-141.

[22] Wang F, Yang JM. The modernization path of public health governance since the reform and opening-up: paradigm shift and ideological development. (Chinese). J. Finance Econ. 2024; 50(6):49-63.

[23] Wu Y, Jin QL, Xia T, Wang XJ, Feng D, Xu Y, et al. A classification and case analysis of public health governance tools in megacities from the perspective of government behavior characteristics. (Chinese). China Public Health Manag. 2024; 40(4):492-496.

[24] National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Promoting the modernization of health governance with equal emphasis on traditional Chinese and Western medicine. (Chinese). 2020 [Available from: http://www.natcm.gov.cn/hudongjiaoliu/guanfangweixin/2020-03-10/13791.html].

[25] Peng X, Xu M. Governance challenges and optimization of the value chain of the healthcare service system. (Chinese). J Zhengzhou Univ Philos Soc Sci Ed. 2024; 57(4):81-87.

[26] Chen YJ. The paradigm shift in global health security governance: theory, institutions, and challenges. (Chinese). Wuhan Univ Int Law Rev. 2024; 2024(4):20-36.

[27] Ren MH, Wang MM. Reconsideration and suggestions on the development of global health disciplines in China under the new situation. (Chinese). Peking Univ J Med Ed. 2024 Online first.

[28] World Health Organization. Declaration of Astana: Global Conference on Primary Health Care. 2018 [Available from: https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/primary-health/declaration/gcphc-declaration.pdf].

[29] Yang H. From the Alma-Ata Declaration to the Astana Declaration: primary health care development is key to achieving universal health coverage. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2019; 22(1):1-4.

[30] Yang H, Chen YD. The astana declaration and preventive medicine in China. (Chinese). Chin J Prev Med. 2019; 53(2):136-140.

[31] Sanders D, De Ceukelaire W, Hutton B. Health policies and healthcare in the context of neoliberal globalization. The Struggle for Health: Medicine and the Politics of Under-development Oxford University Press; 2023:154-188.

[32] Public Safety Science and Technology Society Public Health Safety and Health Professional Committee, Chinese Medical Association General Practitioners BranchExpert consensus on primary care governance. (Chinese). Chin Gen Pract. 2024.

[33] Li ZL, Wang YD. Co-construction, Co-governance, and Shared Benefits: The Path of Innovation in Grassroots Social Governance. Anhui Normal University Press; 2020 Chinese.

[34] State Council. The “13th five-year plan ” for deepening the reform of the medical and health system. (Chinese). 2016 [Available from: https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2017-01/09/content_5158053.htm].

[35] Espinosa-González A, Delaney BC, Marti J. The impact of governance in primary health care delivery: a systems thinking approach with a European panel. Health Res Policy Sys. 2019; 17(65).

[36] Burau V, Tenbense T. Varieties of governance versatility and institutions: comparing the governance of primary care performance in six jurisdictions. Public Policy and Administration. 2023; 39(2).

[37] Australian Department of Health. PHN background. 2019 [Available from: https://www.health.gov.au/our-work/phn?utm_source=health.gov.au&utm_medium=callout-auto-custom&utm_campaign=digital_transformation.

[38] Little A. Health Indicators will Track Better Care for all NZers. Wellington: New Zealand Government; 2021 [Available from: https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/health-indicators-will-track-better-care-all-nzers].

[39] Tenbensel T, Ashton T. Health Reforms across the World: The Experience of Twelve Small and Medium Sized Nations with Changing Their Healthcare Systems. New Zealand’s healthcare system: rapid reform and incremental change. Singapore: World Scientific Press; 2020.

[40] Baum F, Freeman T, Sanders D, Labonte R, Lawless A, Javanparast S. Comprehensive primary health care under neo-liberalism in Australia. Soc Sci Med. 2016; 168:43-52.

[41] Busse R, Blümel M. Germany: Health System review. Health Syst Transit. 2014; 16(2):1-61.

[42] Japan Health Policy Now. Health Insurance System. 2024 [Available from: https://japanhpn.org/en/hs1/].

[43] Hofmann R, Walker J, eds. Neoliberalism with Japanese Characteristics. Australian National University; 2023.

[44] Vrangbæk K. The interplay between central and sub-central levels: The development of a systemic standard-based programme for governing medical performance in Denmark. Health Econ Policy Law. 2009; 4(3):305-327.

[45] Tenbensel T, Miller F, Breton M. How do policy and institutional settings shape opportunities for community-based primary health care? A comparison of Ontario, Québec and New Zealand. Int J Integr Care. 2017; 17(2):13.

[46] Qian J, Radesh M. Strengthening primary health care in China: governance and policy challenges. Health Econ Policy Law. 2023; 19(1).

[47] Asamani JA, Alugsi SA, Ismaila H, Nabyonga-Orem JB. Balancing equity and efficiency in the allocation of health resources-where is the middle ground? Healthcare (Basel). 2021; 24(9):1257.

[48] Pollock AM, Price D, Viebrock E, Miller E. G. W. The market in primary care. BMJ. 2007; 335(7616):475-477.

[49] Liu Y, Berman P, Yip W, Liang H, Meng Q, Qu J, et al. Health care in China: the role of non-government providers. Health Policy. 2006; 77(2006).

[50] Australian Government Department of Social Services. Financial and non-Financial support to formal and informal out-of-home carers. 2010.

[51] Wright M, Versteeg R, van Gool K. How much of Australia’s health expenditure is allocated to general practice and primary healthcare? Aust J Gen Pract. 2021; 50(9):673-678.

[52] WHO. Purchasing health services for universal health coverage: how to make it more strategic? 2019 [Available from: https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-UCH-HGF-PolicyBrief-19.6].

[53] Australian Government Department of Health.Co-design in the PHN commissioning context. 2018 [Available from: http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/PHNCommissioningResources].

[54] National Academies of Sciences Engineering and Medicine, Health and Medicine Division, Board on Health Care Services, Care CoIH-QP, Robinson SK MM, Phillips RL Jr., et al. Person-centered, Family-centered, and community-oriented primary care. In: Robinson SK, Meisnere M, Phillips RL Jr, editors. Implementing High-Quality Pri-mary Care: Rebuilding the Foundation of Health Care. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US).

[55] Vandecasteele R, Robijn L, Stevens PAJ. Trying to write a story together ”: general practitioners’ perspectives on culturally sensitive care. Int J Equity Health. 2024; 23:118.

[56] Reath J, King M, Kmet W, O’Halloran D, Brooker R, Aspinall D, et al. Experiences of primary healthcare professionals and patients from an area of urban disadvantage: a qualitative study. BJGP Open. 2019; 26(3):4.

[57] Wang WY, Zhou H, Wang YF, Sang BS, Liu L. Current policies and measures on the development of traditional Chinese medicine in China. Pharmacol Res. 2021;12.

[58] National Academies of Sciences Engineering and Medicine, Health and Medicine Division, Board on Health Care Services, Committee on Implementing High-Quality Primary Care. Implementing High-Quality Primary Care: Rebuilding the Foundation of Health Care. Implementing high-quality primary care: rebuilding the foundation of health care. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2021 May 4. 7, Digital Health and Primary Care. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK571817/2021.

[59] Ghavamabad LH, Vosoogh-Moghaddam A, Zaboli R. Establishing clinical governance model in primary health care: a systematic review. J Educ Health Promot. 2021; 3(10):338.

[60] World Health Organization. Quality in primary health care. 2018.

[61] Ekanayake SKDM, Ward AE, Heart D, Valery P, Soar J. Improving primary care referral to specialist services: a protocol for a 10-year global systematic review in the Australian context. BMJ Open. 2023; 13(8):e068927.

[62] World Health Organization. A toolkit on how to implement social prescribing. 2022.

[63] Prior A, Vestergaard CH, Vedsted P. Healthcare fragmentation, multimorbidity, potentially inappropriate medication, and mortality: a Danish nationwide cohort study. BMC Med. 2023; 21(305).

[64] Kern LM, Bynum JPW, Pincus HA. Care fragmentation, care continuity, and care coordination —How they differ and why it matters. JAMA Intern. Med. 2024; 184(3):236-237.

[65] Olckers L, Gibbs TJ, Duncan M. Developing health science students into integrated health professionals: a practical tool for learning. BMC Med Educ. 2007; 7(45).

[66] Babatunde AO, Shobanke HA, Akinade AA, Michael AJ, Osadare M, Akanbi OK, et al. Enhancing preventive medicine over curative medicine: role of telemedicine. Public Health in Practice. 2021; 2:100-113.

[67] Schapiro R, Stickford-Becker AE, Foertsch JA, Remington PL, Seibert CS. Integrative cases for preclinical medical students - connecting clinical, basic science, and public health approaches. AJPM. 2011; 41(4):S187-SS92.

[68] Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP). Shared care model between GP and non-GP specialists for complex chronic conditions. 2023.

[69] Smith SM, Cousins G, Clyne B, Allwright S, O’Dowd T. Shared care across the interface between primary and specialty care in management of long term conditions. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2017; 2(2):CD004910 Feb 23PMID: 28230899; PMCID: PMC6473196. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004910.pub3.

[70] Hampson JP, Roberts RI, Morgan DA. Shared care: a review of the literature. Family Practice Oxford Acad. 1996; 13(3):264-279.

[71] Stock P, Burton RJF. Defining terms for integrated (multi-inter-trans-disciplinary) sustainability research. Sustainability. 2011; 3(8):1090-1113.