Challenges in safe environmental applications of biochar: identifying risks and unintended consequence

Abstract

Over the past 10–15 years, biochar has garnered significant global attention in agriculture and environmental science. While most research has focused on the benefits of biochar application in soil enhancement, water quality improvement, and climate change mitigation, the potential risks associated with its use have often been overlooked. This oversight is critical, as the environmental fate of biochar is contingent upon understanding these risks. Once released into the environment, biochar can interact with environmental media, potentially releasing associated pollutants and threatening ecosystems. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate the unintended environmental and health risks associated with biochar during its production and application to select appropriate types for sustainable development. This review was conducted by systematically analyzing and synthesizing relevant studies from Web of Science, focusing on recent advancements and key debates in the field. It categorizes biochar risks into endogenous and exogenous risks based on the source of pollutants carried by biochar. The review analyzes in detail the impacts of raw materials, preparation processes, and application scenarios on the unintended environmental risks of biochar. Furthermore, it provides a thorough overview of the adverse effects on animals, plants, microorganisms, and human health, elucidating the mechanisms of pollutant release, aging, and nano-effects from environmental geochemical processes involving biochar. Additionally, this review summarizes the environmental risk assessment methods of biochar, providing a reference for its safe application and the sustainable development of biochar-related research.

References

[] Alfei S, Pandoli OG. Biochar-derived persistent free radicals: a plethora of environmental applications in a light and shadows scenario. Toxics, 2024, 12(4): 245

[] Alharbi HA, Alotaibi KD, El-Saeid MH, Giesy JP. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and metals in diverse biochar products: effect of feedstock type and pyrolysis temperature. Toxics, 2023, 11: 96

[] Anjum R, Krakat N, Reza MT, Klocke M. Assessment of mutagenic potential of pyrolysis biochars by Ames Salmonella/mammalian-microsomal mutagenicity test. Ecotox Environ Safe, 2014, 107: 306-312

[] Bai X, Zhang S, Shao J, Chen A, Jiang J, Chen A, Luo S. Exploring the negative effects of biochars on the germination, growth, and antioxidant system of rice and corn. J Env Chem Eng, 2022, 10(3) 107398

[] Bastos A, Prodana M, Abrantes N, Keizer J, Soares A, Loureiro S. Potential risk of biochar-amended soil to aquatic systems: an evaluation based on aquatic bioassays. Ecotoxicology, 2014, 23: 1784-1793

[] Bing H, Zhou J, Wu Y, Wang X, Sun H, Li R. Current state, sources, and potential risk of heavy metals in sediments of Three Gorges Reservoir, China. Environ Pollut, 2016, 214: 485-496

[] Briones M, Panzacchi P, Davies C, Ineson P. Contrasting responses of macro-and meso-fauna to biochar additions in a bioenergy cropping system. Soil Bio Biochem, 2020, 145 107803

[] Brtnicky M, Datta R, Holatko J, Bielska L, Gusiatin ZM, Kucerik J, Hammerschmiedt T, Danish S, Radziemska M, Mravcova L. A critical review of the possible adverse effects of biochar in the soil environment. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 796 148756

[] Cao Y, Jing Y, Hao H, Wang X. Changes in the physicochemical characteristics of peanut straw biochar after freeze–thaw and dry–wet aging treatments of the biomass. BioResources, 2019, 14: 4329-4343

[] Carvalho ER, Rocha DK, Andrade DB, Pires RMO, Penido AC, Reis LV. Phytotoxicity in soybean seeds treated with phytosanitary products at different application times. J Seed Sci., 2020, 42 e202042036

[] Chausali N, Saxena J, Prasad R. Nanobiochar and biochar based nanocomposites: advances and applications. J Agri Food Res, 2021, 5 100191

[] Chen M, Wang D, Yang F, Xu X, Xu N, Cao X. Transport and retention of biochar nanoparticles in a paddy soil under environmentally-relevant solution chemistry conditions. Environ Pollut, 2017, 230: 540-549

[] Chen M, Alim N, Zhang Y, Xu N, Cao X. Contrasting effects of biochar nanoparticles on the retention and transport of phosphorus in acidic and alkaline soils. Environ Pollut, 2018, 239: 562-570

[] Chen Q, Wang M, Wang Y, Zhang L, Xue J, Sun H, Mu Z. Rapid determination of environmentally persistent free radicals (EPFRs) in atmospheric particles with a quartz sheet-based approach using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Atmos Environ, 2018, 184: 140-145

[] Chen D, Cen K, Zhuang X, Gan Z, Zhou J, Zhang Y, Zhang H. Insight into biomass pyrolysis mechanism based on cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin: evolution of volatiles and kinetics, elucidation of reaction pathways, and characterization of gas, biochar and bio-oil. Combust Flame, 2022, 242 112142

[] Chen M, Chen X, Xu X, Xu Z, Zhang Y, Song B, Tsang DCW, Xu N, Cao X. Biochar colloids facilitate transport and transformation of Cr(VI) in soil: active site competition coupling with reduction reaction. J Hazard Mater, 2022, 440 129691

[] Chen Y, Guo Y, Liu Y, Xiang Y, Liu G, Zhang Q, Yin Y, Cai Y, Jiang G. Advances in bacterial whole-cell biosensors for the detection of bioavailable mercury: a review. Sci Total Env, 2023, 868 161709

[] Cui H, Li D, Liu X, Fan Y, Zhang X, Zhang S, Zhou J, Fang G, Zhou J. Dry–wet and freeze–thaw aging activate endogenous copper and cadmium in biochar. J Cleaner Prod, 2021, 288 125605

[] Cui H, Wang Q, Zhang X, Zhang S, Zhou J, Zhou D, Zhou J. Aging reduces the bioavailability of copper and cadmium in soil immobilized by biochars with various concentrations of endogenous metals. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 797 149136

[] Devi P, Saroha AK. Effect of pyrolysis temperature on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons toxicity and sorption behaviour of biochars prepared by pyrolysis of paper mill effluent treatment plant sludge. Bioresour Technol, 2015, 192: 312-320

[] Ding Y, Liu J, Wang Y. Effects of biochar on microbial ecology in agriculture soil: a review. J Appl Ecol, 2013, 24: 3311-3317

[] Dong M, He L, Jiang M, Zhu Y, Wang J, Gustave W, Wang S, Deng Y, Zhang X, Wang Z. Biochar for the removal of emerging pollutants from aquatic systems: a review. Int J Environ Res Pub He, 2023, 20: 1679

[] Du L, Ahmad S, Liu L, Wang L, Tang J. A review of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) adsorption by biochar and modified biochar in water. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 858 159815

[] Dutta T, Kwon E, Bhattacharya SS, Jeon BH, Deep A, Uchimiya M, Kim KH. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and volatile organic compounds in biochar and biochar-amended soil: a review. Gcb Bioenergy, 2017, 9: 990-1004

[] El-Naggar A, El-Naggar AH, Shaheen SM, Sarkar B, Chang SX, Tsang DC, Rinklebe J, Ok YS. Biochar composition-dependent impacts on soil nutrient release, carbon mineralization, and potential environmental risk: a review. J Environ Manage, 2019, 241: 458-467

[] Fan S, Zuo J, Dong H. Changes in soil properties and bacterial community composition with biochar amendment after six years. Agronomy, 2020, 10: 746

[] Fang G, Gao J, Liu C, Dionysiou DD, Wang Y, Zhou D. Key role of persistent free radicals in hydrogen peroxide activation by biochar: implications to organic contaminant degradation. Environ Sci Technol, 2014, 48: 1902-1910

[] Fang G, Liu C, Gao J, Dionysiou DD, Zhou D. Manipulation of persistent free radicals in biochar to activate persulfate for contaminant degradation. Environ Sci Technol, 2015, 49: 5645-5653

[] Fang G, Zhu C, Dionysiou DD, Gao J, Zhou D. Mechanism of hydroxyl radical generation from biochar suspensions: Implications to diethyl phthalate degradation. Bioresource Technol, 2015, 176: 210-217

[] Gao LY, Deng JH, Huang GF, Li K, Cai KZ, Liu Y, Huang F. Relative distribution of Cd²⁺ adsorption mechanisms on biochars derived from rice straw and sewage sludge. Bioresource Technol, 2019, 272: 114-122

[] Ghidotti M, Fabbri D, Hornung A. Profiles of volatile organic compounds in biochar: Insights into process conditions and quality assessment. ACS Sust Chem Eng, 2017, 5: 510-517

[] Gomez-Eyles JL, Sizmur T, Collins CD, Hodson ME. Effects of biochar and the earthworm Eisenia fetida on the bioavailability of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and potentially toxic elements. Environ Pollut, 2011, 159: 616-622

[] Gruss I, Twardowski JP, Latawiec A, Medyńska Juraszek A, Królczyk J. Risk assessment of low-temperature biochar used as soil amendment on soil mesofauna. Envir Sci Pollu Res, 2019, 26(18): 18230-18239

[] Gu S, Lian F, Han Y, Taherymoosavi S, Mitchell D, Joseph S, Wang Z, Xing B. Nano-biochar modulates the formation of iron plaque through facilitating iron-involved redox reactions on aquatic plant root surfaces. Environ Sci Nano, 2022, 9: 1974-1985

[] Gujre N, Rangan L, Mitra S. Occurrence, geochemical fraction, ecological and health risk assessment of cadmium, copper and nickel in soils contaminated with municipal solid wastes. Chemosphere, 2021, 271 129573

[] Hale SE, Lehmann J, Rutherford D, Zimmerman AR, Bachmann RT, Shitumbanuma V, O’Toole A, Sundqvist KL, Arp HPH, Cornelissen G. Quantifying the total and bioavailable polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and dioxins in biochars. Environ Sci Technol, 2012, 46: 2830-2838

[] Hale SE, Jensen J, Jakob L, Oleszczuk P, Hartnik T, Henriksen T, Okkenhaug G, Martinsen V, Cornelissen G. Short-term effect of the soil amendments activated carbon, biochar, and ferric oxyhydroxide on bacteria and invertebrates. Environ Sci Technol, 2013, 47: 8674-8683

[] Häring V, Manka’abusi D, Akoto-Danso EK, Werner S, Atiah K, Steiner C, Lompo DJP, Adiku S, Buerkert A, Marschner B. Effects of biochar, waste water irrigation and fertilization on soil properties in West African urban agriculture. Sci Rep, 2017, 7: 10738

[] He L, Zhong H, Liu G, Dai Z, Brookes PC, Xu J. Remediation of heavy metal contaminated soils by biochar: mechanisms, potential risks and applications in China. Environ Pollut, 2019, 252: 846-855

[] Hong J, Wang C, Wagner DC, Gardea-Torresdey JL, He F, Rico CM (2021a) Foliar application of nanoparticles: mechanisms of absorption, transfer, and multiple impacts. Environ Sci Nano 1196–1210

[] Hong Y, Zhang Y, Chen Z, Li B. Review of the research on content levels and application risk of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in biochar. Environ Chem, 2021, 40: 2378-2387

[] Hossain MZ, Bahar MM, Sarkar B, Donne SW, Ok YS, Palansooriya KN, Kirkham MB, Chowdhury S, Bolan N. Biochar and its importance on nutrient dynamics in soil and plant. Biochar, 2020, 2: 379-420

[] Hu W, Gao W, Tang Y, Zhang Q, Tu C, Cheng J. Remediation via biochar and potential health risk of heavy metal contaminated soils. Environ Earth Sci, 2022, 81: 482

[] Hu Y, Tong K, Guo Q, Zhang B, Jiao L, Li M, Zhang Z. Effect of controlled temperature and biomass addition on the formed environmental persistent free radicals (EPFRs) in sewage sludge-based biochar from pyrolysis treatment. J Anal Appl Pyrol, 2022, 162 105460

[] Huang HJ, Yuan XZ. The migration and transformation behaviors of heavy metals during the hydrothermal treatment of sewage sludge. Bioresour Technol, 2016, 200: 991-998

[] Huang H, Yao W, Li R, Ali A, Du J, Guo D, Xiao R, Guo Z, Zhang Z, Awasthi MK. Effect of pyrolysis temperature on chemical form, behavior and environmental risk of Zn, Pb and Cd in biochar produced from phytoremediation residue. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 249: 487-493

[] Huang D, Luo H, Zhang C, Zeng G, Lai C, Cheng M, Wang R, Deng R, Xue W, Gong X. Nonnegligible role of biomass types and its compositions on the formation of persistent free radicals in biochar: insight into the influences on Fenton-like process. Chem Eng J, 2019, 361: 353-363

[] Huang X, Zhang C, Zhu S, Chen D, Ho SH. Effects of biochar on microalgal growth: difference between dissolved and undissolved fractions. ACS Sust Chem Eng, 2020, 8: 9156-9164

[] Huang X, Zhu S, Zhang H, Huang Y, Wang X, Wang Y, Chen D. Biochar nanoparticles induced distinct biological effects on freshwater Algae via oxidative stress, membrane damage, and nutrient depletion. ACS Sustain Chem Eng, 2021, 9(32): 10761-10770

[] Huang Z, Gustave W, Bai S, Li Y, Li B, Elçin E, Jiang B, Jia Z, Zhang X, Shaheen SM (2024) Challenges and opportunities in commercializing whole-cell bioreporters in environmental application. Environ. Res 119801

[] Hussain M, Farooq M, Nawaz A, Al-Sadi AM, Solaiman ZM, Alghamdi SS, Ammara U, Ok YS, Siddique KH. Biochar for crop production: potential benefits and risks. J Soils Sediments, 2017, 17: 685-716

[] Jagadeesh N, Sundaram B. Adsorption of pollutants from wastewater by biochar: a review. J Hazard Mater Adv, 2023, 9 100226

[] Ji M, Wang X, Usman M, Liu F, Dan Y, Zhou L, Campanaro S, Luo G, Sang W. Effects of different feedstocks-based biochar on soil remediation: a review. Environ Pollut, 2022, 294 118655

[] Ji X, Cantin J, Cardenas Perez AS, Gong Y, Giesy JP, Brinkmann M. Combining passive sampling with fraction transfer and toxicokinetic modeling to assess bioavailability of organic pollutants in a benthic invertebrate, Lumbriculus Variegatus. J Hazard Mater, 2023, 441 129986

[] Jin J, Wang M, Cao Y, Wu S, Liang P, Li Y, Zhang J, Zhang J, Wong MH, Shan S. Cumulative effects of bamboo sawdust addition on pyrolysis of sewage sludge: biochar properties and environmental risk from metals. Bioresour Technol, 2017, 228: 218-226

[] José M, Sánchez-Martín ÁM, Campos P, Miller AZ. Effect of pyrolysis conditions on the total contents of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in biochars produced from organic residues: assessment of their hazard potential. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 667: 578-585

[] Joshi S, Ramola S, Singh B, Anerao P, Singh L. Engineered biochar: fundamentals, preparation, characterization and applications, 2022, Singapore, Springer Nature Singapore 21-33

[] Ke Y, Zhang F, Zhang Z, Hough R, Fu Q, Li YF, Cui S. Effect of combined aging treatment on biochar adsorption and speciation distribution for Cd(II). Sci Total Environ, 2023, 867 161593

[] Kołtowski M, Hilber I, Bucheli TD, Charmas B, Zięba S, Oleszczuk P. Activated biochars reduce the exposure of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in industrially contaminated soils. Chem Eng J, 2017, 310: 33-40

[] Krzyszczak A, Dybowski MP, Czech B. Formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and their derivatives in biochars: the effect of feedstock and pyrolysis conditions. J Anal Appl Pyrol, 2021, 160 105339

[] Laghari M, Mirjat MS, Hu Z, Fazal S, Xiao B, Hu M, Chen Z, Guo D. Effects of biochar application rate on sandy desert soil properties and sorghum growth. CATENA, 2015, 135: 313-320

[] Li S, Skelly S. Physicochemical properties and applications of biochars derived from municipal solid waste: a review. Environ Adv, 2023, 13 100395

[] Li F, Cai Y, Zhang J. Spatial characteristics, health risk assessment and sustainable management of heavy metals and metalloids in soils from central China. Sustainability, 2018, 10: 91

[] Li Z, Deng H, Yang L, Zhang G, Li Y, Ren Y. Influence of potassium hydroxide activation on characteristics and environmental risk of heavy metals in chars derived from municipal sewage sludge. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 256: 216-223

[] Li F, Wu X, Ji W, Gui X, Chen Y, Zhao J, Zhou C, Ren T. Effects of pyrolysis temperature on properties of swine manure biochar and its environmental risks of heavy metals. J Anal Appl Pyrol, 2020, 152 104945

[] Li B, Ding S, Fan H, Ren Y. Experimental investigation into the effect of pyrolysis on chemical forms of heavy metals in sewage sludge biochar (SSB), with brief ecological risk assessment. Materials, 2021, 14: 447

[] Li M, Li P, Zhou Q, Lee SLJ. A mini review on persulfate activation by sustainable biochar for the removal of antibiotics. Materials, 2022, 15: 5832

[] Li Y, Ge C, Cheng C, Wang X, Si D, Mu C, Wang M, Li H, Zhou D. Nano-biochar uptake and translocation by plants: assessing environmental fate and food chain risk. Sci Total Environ, 2023, 905 167012

[] Lian F, Xing B. Black carbon (biochar) in water/soil environments: molecular structure, sorption, stability, and potential risk. Environ Sci Technol, 2017, 51: 13517-13532

[] Liang L, Xi F, Tan W, Meng X, Hu B, Wang X. Review of organic and inorganic pollutants removal by biochar and biochar-based composites. Biochar, 2021, 3: 255-281

[] Liu X, Wang Y, Gui C, Li P, Zhang J, Zhong H, Wei Y. Chemical forms and risk assessment of heavy metals in sludge-biochar produced by microwave-induced low temperature pyrolysis. RSC Adv, 2016, 6: 101960-101967

[] Liu G, Zheng H, Jiang Z, Zhao J, Wang Z, Pan B, Xing B. Formation and physicochemical characteristics of nano biochar: insight into chemical and colloidal stability. Environ Sci Technol, 2018, 52: 10369-10379

[] Liu Y, Dai Q, Jin X, Dong X, Peng J, Wu M, Liang N, Pan B, Xing B. Negative impacts of biochars on urease activity: high pH, heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or free radicals?. Environ Sci Technol, 2018, 52: 12740-12747

[] Liu WJ, Jiang H, Yu HQ. Emerging applications of biochar-based materials for energy storage and conversion. Energy Environ Sci, 2019, 12: 1751-1779

[] Liu L, Yuan M, Wang X, Li X, Fang W, Shan D, Dai Y. Biochar aging: properties, mechanisms, and environmental benefits for adsorption of metolachlor in soil. Environ Technol Inno, 2021, 24 101841

[] Liu Z, Wang J, Yang X, Zhu K, Sun Y, Van Hulle S, Jia H. Generation of environmental persistent free radicals (EPFRs) enhances ecotoxicological effects of the disposable face mask waste with the COVID-19 pandemic. Environ Pollut, 2022, 301 119019

[] Llovet A, Mattana S, Chin-Pampillo J, Gascó G, Sánchez S, Mondini C, Briones MJI, Márquez L, Alcañiz JM, Ribas A. Long-term effects of gasification biochar application on soil functions in a Mediterranean agroecosystem: higher addition rates sequester more carbon but pose a risk to soil faunal communities. Sci Total Environ, 2021, 801 149580

[] Lu T, Yuan H, Wang Y, Huang H, Chen Y. Characteristic of heavy metals in biochar derived from sewage sludge. J Mater Cy Waste Manage, 2016, 18: 725-733

[] Lv W, Zhou W, Lu S, Huang W, Yuan Q, Tian M, Lv W, He D. Microplastic pollution in rice-fish co-culture system: a report of three farmland stations in Shanghai, China. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 652: 1209-1218

[] Lyu H, He Y, Tang J, Hecker M, Liu Q, Jones PD, Codling G, Giesy JP. Effect of pyrolysis temperature on potential toxicity of biochar if applied to the environment. Environ Pollut, 2016, 218: 1-7

[] Madžarić S, Kos M, Drobne D, Hočevar M, Kokalj AJ. Integration of behavioral tests and biochemical biomarkers of terrestrial isopod Porcellio scaber (Isopoda, Crustacea) is a promising methodology for testing environmental safety of chars. Environ Pollut, 2018, 234: 804-811

[] Majumder S, Neogi S, Dutta T, Powel MA, Banik P. The impact of biochar on soil carbon sequestration: meta-analytical approach to evaluating environmental and economic advantages. J Environ Manage, 2019, 250 109466

[] Malabadi RB, Kolkar KP, Chalannavar RK, Acharya M, Mudigoudra BS. Industrial Cannabis sativa: hemp-biochar-applications and disadvantages. World J Adv Res Rev, 2023, 20(01): 371-383

[] Masiello CA, Chen Y, Gao X, Liu S, Cheng HY, Bennett MR, Rudgers JA, Wagner DS, Zygourakis K, Silberg JJ. Biochar and microbial signaling: production conditions determine effects on microbial communication. Environ Sci Technol, 2013, 47: 11496-11503

[] Meng J, Xu B, Liu F, Li W, Sy N, Zhou X, Yan B. Effects of chemical and natural ageing on the release of potentially toxic metal additives in commercial PVC microplastics. Chemosphere, 2021, 283 131274

[] Min X, Ge T, Li H, Shi Y, Fang T, Sheng B, Li H, Dong X. Combining impregnation and co-pyrolysis to reduce the environmental risk of biochar derived from sewage sludge. Chemosphere, 2022, 290 133371

[] Mukherjee P, Das PK, Ghosh P. The extent of heavy metal pollution by chemical partitioning and risk assessment code of sediments of Sewage-Fed fishery ponds at East Kolkata Wetland, a Ramsar Site, India. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol, 2022, 108(4): 731-736

[] Murtaza G, Ahmed Z, Eldin SM, Ali I, Usman M, Iqbal R, Rizwan M, Abdel-Hameed UK, Haider AA, Tariq A. Biochar as a green sorbent for remediation of polluted soils and associated toxicity risks: a critical review. Separations, 2023, 10: 197

[] Natasha N, Shahid M, Khalid S, Bibi I, Naeem MA, Niazi NK, Tack FMG, Ippolito JA, Rinklebe J. Influence of biochar on trace element uptake, toxicity and detoxification in plants and associated health risks: a critical review. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol, 2022, 52(16): 2803-2843

[] Ndirangu SM, Liu Y, Xu K, Song S. Risk evaluation of pyrolyzed biochar from multiple wastes. J Chem, 2019, 2019: 1-28

[] Ni N, Li X, Yao S, Shi R, Kong D, Bian Y, Jiang X, Song Y. Biochar applications combined with paddy-upland rotation cropping systems benefit the safe use of PAH-contaminated soils: from risk assessment to microbial ecology. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 404 124123

[] Odinga ES, Waigi MG, Gudda FO, Wang J, Yang B, Hu X, Li S, Gao Y. Occurrence, formation, environmental fate and risks of environmentally persistent free radicals in biochars. Environ Int, 2020, 134 105172

[] Ouyang S, Li Y, Zheng T, Wu K, Wang X, Zhou Q. Ecotoxicity of natural nanocolloids in aquatic environment. Water, 2022, 14: 2971

[] Perendija J, Cvetković S, Manić N, Andrejić G, Vukašinović I, Cvetinović D, Janković B (2024) A comparative study on the slow pyrolysis of Miscanthus (Miscanthus × giganteus Greef et Deu.) cultivated on agricultural and contaminated soils: assessment of distribution of final products. Ind Crop Prod 222: 119452

[] Racek J, Sevcik J, Chorazy T, Kucerik J, Hlavinek P. Biochar—recovery material from pyrolysis of sewage sludge: a review. Waste Biomass Valori, 2020, 11: 3677-3709

[] Ramanayaka S, Vithanage M, Alessi DS, Liu WJ, Jayasundera AC, Ok YS. Nanobiochar: production, properties, and multifunctional applications. Environ Sci Nano, 2020, 7(11): 3279-3302

[] Ravi S, Sharratt BS, Li J, Olshevski S, Meng Z, Zhang J. Particulate matter emissions from biochar-amended soils as a potential tradeoff to the negative emission potential. Sci Rep, 2016, 6: 35984

[] Ren X, Tang J, Wang L, Sun H. Combined effects of microplastics and biochar on the removal of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and phthalate esters and its potential microbial ecological mechanism. Front Microbiol, 2021, 12 647766

[] Rombolà AG, Meredith W, Snape CE, Baronti S, Genesio L, Vaccari FP, Miglietta F, Fabbri D. Fate of soil organic carbon and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in a vineyard soil treated with biochar. Environ Sci Technol, 2015, 49: 11037-11044

[] Ruan X, Liu Y, Wang G, Frost R, Qian G, Tsang DC. Transformation of functional groups and environmentally persistent free radicals in hydrothermal carbonisation of lignin. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 270: 223-229

[] Ruan X, Sun Y, Du W, Tang Y, Liu Q, Zhang Z, Doherty W, Frost RL, Qian G, Tsang DC. Formation, characteristics, and applications of environmentally persistent free radicals in biochars: a review. Bioresour Technol, 2019, 281: 457-468

[] Shen Y, Tang H, Wu W, Shang H, Zhang D, Zhan X, Xing B. Role of nano-biochar in attenuating the allelopathic effect from Imperata cylindrica on rice seedlings. Environ Sci Nano, 2020, 7: 116-126

[] Shen X, Meng H, Shen Y, Ding J, Zhou H, Cong H, Li L. A comprehensive assessment on bioavailability, leaching characteristics and potential risk of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in biochars produced by a continuous pyrolysis system. Chemosphere, 2022, 287 132116

[] Sigmund G, Huber D, Bucheli TD, Baumann M, Borth N, Guebitz GM, Hofmann T. Cytotoxicity of biochar: a workplace safety concern?. Environ Sci Technol Lett, 2017, 4: 362-366

[] Sørmo E, Krahn KM, Flatabø GØ, Hartnik T, Arp HPH, Cornelissen G. Distribution of PAHs, PCBs, and PCDD/Fs in products from full-scale relevant pyrolysis of diverse contaminated organic waste. J Hazard Mater, 2024, 461: 132546

[] Sorrenti G, Masiello CA, Dugan B, Toselli M. Biochar physico-chemical properties as affected by environmental exposure. Sci Total Environ, 2016, 563: 237-246

[] Subedi R, Bertora C, Zavattaro L, Grignani C. Crop response to soils amended with biochar: expected benefits and unintended risks. Italian J Agrono, 2017, 12: 161-173

[] Tan RR. Data challenges in optimizing biochar-based carbon sequestration. Renew Sust Energy Rev, 2019, 104: 174-177

[] Tomczyk B, Siatecka A, Gao Y, Ok YS, Bogusz A, Oleszczuk P. The convertion of sewage sludge to biochar as a sustainable tool of PAHs exposure reduction during agricultural utilization of sewage sludges. J Hazard Mater, 2020, 392 122416

[] Torres LAZ, Woiciechowski AL, de Andrade Tanobe VO, Karp SG, Lorenci LCG, Faulds C, Soccol CR. Lignin as a potential source of high-added value compounds: a review. J Cle pro, 2020, 263 121499

[] Verma SK, Das AK, Gantait S, Kumar V, Gurel E. Applications of carbon nanomaterials in the plant system: a perspective view on the pros and cons. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 667: 485-499

[] Vinayak A, Mudgal G, Singh GB (2022) Environment persistent free radicals: long-lived particles. Free Radical Biol Environ Toxicol 1–19

[] Visioli G, Conti FD, Menta C, Bandiera M, Malcevschi A, Jones DL, Vamerali T. Assessing biochar ecotoxicology for soil amendment by root phytotoxicity bioassays. Environ Monit Ass, 2016, 188: 1-11

[] Vuong X, Vu L, Duong A, Duong H, Hoang T, Luu M, Nguyen T, Nguyen V, Nguyen T, Van T. Speciation and environmental risk assessment of heavy metals in soil from a lead/zinc mining site in Vietnam. Int J Environ Sci Technol, 2023, 20(5): 5295-5310

[] Wang J, Wang S. Preparation, modification and environmental application of biochar: a review. J Clean Prod, 2019, 227: 1002-1022

[] Wang J, Xia K, Waigi MG, Gao Y, Odinga ES, Ling W, Liu J. Application of biochar to soils may result in plant contamination and human cancer risk due to exposure of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Environ Int, 2018, 121: 169-177

[] Wang R, Shafi M, Ma J, Zhong B, Guo J, Hu X, Xu W, Yang Y, Ruan Z, Wang Y. Effect of amendments on contaminated soil of multiple heavy metals and accumulation of heavy metals in plants. Environ Sci Pollu Res, 2018, 25: 28695-28704

[] Wang S, Jiang D, Cao B, Qian L, Hu Y, Liu L, Yuan C, Abomohra AEF, He Z, Wang Q. Bio-char and bio-oil characteristics produced from the interaction of Enteromorpha clathrate volatiles and rice husk bio-char during co-pyrolysis in a sectional pyrolysis furnace: a complementary study. J Anal Appl Pyrol, 2018, 135: 219-230

[] Wang A, Zou D, Zhang L, Zeng X, Wang H, Li L, Liu F, Ren B, Xiao Z. Environmental risk assessment in livestock manure derived biochars. RSC Adv, 2019, 9: 40536-40545

[] Wang J, Odinga ES, Zhang W, Zhou X, Yang B, Waigi MG, Gao Y. Polyaromatic hydrocarbons in biochars and human health risks of food crops grown in biochar-amended soils: a synthesis study. Environ Int, 2019, 130 104899

[] Wang X, Li C, Li Z, Yu G, Wang Y. Effect of pyrolysis temperature on characteristics, chemical speciation and risk evaluation of heavy metals in biochar derived from textile dyeing sludge. Ecotox Environ Safe, 2019, 168: 45-52

[] Wang B, Zhang Y, Zhu D, Li H. Assessment of bioavailability of biochar-sorbed tetracycline to Escherichia coli for activation of antibiotic resistance genes. Environ Sci Technol, 2020, 54: 12920-12928

[] Wang L, O’Connor D, Rinklebe J, Ok YS, Tsang DC, Shen Z, Hou D. Biochar aging: mechanisms, physicochemical changes, assessment, and implications for field applications. Environ Sci Technol, 2020, 54: 14797-14814

[] Wang A, Zou D, Zeng X, Chen B, Zheng X, Li L, Zhang L, Xiao Z, Wang H. Speciation and environmental risk of heavy metals in biochars produced by pyrolysis of chicken manure and water-washed swine manure. Sci Rep, 2021, 11: 11994

[] Wang C, Li L, Chen Y, Ge Z, Jin H. Supercritical water gasification of wheat straw: composition of reaction products and kinetic study. Energy, 2021, 227 120449

[] Wang X, Chang VWC, Li Z, Chen Z, Wang Y. Co-pyrolysis of sewage sludge and organic fractions of municipal solid waste: synergistic effects on biochar properties and the environmental risk of heavy metals. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 412 125200

[] Wang Z, Shen R, Ji S, Xie L, Zhang H. Effects of biochar derived from sewage sludge and sewage sludge/cotton stalks on the immobilization and phytoavailability of Pb, Cu, and Zn in sandy loam soil. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 419 126468

[] Wang G, Yang Y, Kong Y, Ma R, Yuan J, Li G. Key factors affecting seed germination in phytotoxicity tests during sheep manure composting with carbon additives. J Hazard Mater, 2022, 421 126809

[] Wang Q, Wang B, Ma Y, Zhang X, Lyu W, Chen M. Stabilization of heavy metals in biochar derived from plants in antimony mining area and its environmental implications. Environ Pollut, 2022, 300 118902

[] Wang L, Deng J, Yang X, Hou R, Hou D. Role of biochar toward carbon neutrality. Carbon Res, 2023, 2: 2

[] Wang X, Zhao Y, Yao G, Lin Z, Xu L, Jiang Y, Jin Z, Shan S, Ping L. Responses of aquatic vegetables to biochar amended soil and water environments: a critical review. RSC Adv, 2023, 13: 4407-4421

[] Weber K, Quicker P. Properties of biochar. Fuel, 2018, 217: 240-261

[] Weidemann E, Buss W, Edo M, Mašek O, Jansson S. Influence of pyrolysis temperature and production unit on formation of selected PAHs, oxy-PAHs, N-PACs, PCDDs, and PCDFs in biochar—a screening study. Environ Sci Pollut Res, 2018, 25: 3933-3940

[] Wu G, Wang L, Yang R, Hou W, Zhang S, Guo X, Zhao W. Pollution characteristics and risk assessment of heavy metals in the soil of a construction waste landfill site. Ecol Inform, 2022, 70 101700

[] Wu M, Liu B, Li J, Su X, Liu W, Li X. Influence of pyrolysis temperature on sludge biochar: the ecological risk assessment of heavy metals and the adsorption of Cd (II). Environ Sci Pollut Res, 2023, 30: 12608-12617

[] Xiang L, Liu S, Ye S, Yang H, Song B, Qin F, Shen M, Tan C, Zeng G, Tan X. Potential hazards of biochar: the negative environmental impacts of biochar applications. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 420 126611

[] Xie Y, Zhou G, Huang X, Cao X, Ye A, Deng Y, Zhang J, Lin C, Zhang R. Study on the physicochemical properties changes of field aging biochar and its effects on the immobilization mechanism for Cd²⁺ and Pb²⁺. Ecotoxicol Environ Safe, 2022, 230 113107

[] Xiong Q, Wu X, Lv H, Liu S, Hou H, Wu X. Influence of rice husk addition on phosphorus fractions and heavy metals risk of biochar derived from sewage sludge. Chemosphere, 2021, 280 130566

[] Xu Y, Bai T, Yan Y, Ma K. Influence of sodium hydroxide addition on characteristics and environmental risk of heavy metals in biochars derived from swine manure. Waste Manage, 2020, 105: 511-519

[] Xu C, Tan X, Zhao J, Cao J, Ren M, Xiao Y, Lin A. Optimization of biochar production based on environmental risk and remediation performance: take kitchen waste for example. J Hazard Mater, 2021, 416 125785

[] Xu D, Zhang G, Ni X, Wang B, Sun H, Yu Y, Mosa AA, Yin X. Effect of different aging treatments on the transport of nano-biochar in saturated porous media. Chemosphere, 2023, 323 138272

[] Yang X, Li Q, Tang Z, Zhang W, Yu G, Shen Q, Zhao FJ. Heavy metal concentrations and arsenic speciation in animal manure composts in China. Waste Manage, 2017, 64: 333-339

[] Yang T, Meng J, Jeyakumar P, Cao T, Liu Z, He T, Cao X, Chen W, Wang H. Effect of pyrolysis temperature on the bioavailability of heavy metals in rice straw-derived biochar. Environ Sci Pollut Res, 2021, 28: 2198-2208

[] Yang Z, Hu W, Yao B, Shen L, Jiang F, Zhou Y, Núñez-Delgado A. A novel manganese-rich pokeweed biochar for highly efficient adsorption of heavy metals from wastewater: performance, mechanisms, and potential risk analysis. Processes, 2021, 9: 1209

[] Yao S, Ni N, Li X, Wang N, Bian Y, Jiang X, Song Y, Bolan NS, Zhang Q, Tsang DCW. Interactions between white and black carbon in water: a case study of concurrent aging of microplastics and biochar. Water Res, 2023, 238 120006

[] Yue L, Lian F, Han Y, Bao Q, Wang Z, Xing B. The effect of biochar nanoparticles on rice plant growth and the uptake of heavy metals: implications for agronomic benefits and potential risk. Sci Total Environ, 2019, 656: 9-18

[] Zeng X, Xiao Z, Zhang G, Wang A, Li Z, Liu Y, Wang H, Zeng Q, Liang Y, Zou D. Speciation and bioavailability of heavy metals in pyrolytic biochar of swine and goat manures. J Anal Appl Pyrol, 2018, 132: 82-93

[] Zhang X, Sarmah AK, Bolan NS, He L, Lin X, Che L, Tang C, Wan H. Effect of aging process on adsorption of diethyl phthalate in soils amended with bamboo biochar. Chemosphere, 2016, 142: 28-34

[] Zhang M, Li J, Wang Y, Yang C. Impacts of different biochar types on the anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge. RSC Adv, 2019, 9: 42375-42386

[] Zhang Y, Peng C, Guo Z, Xiao X, Xiao R. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in urban soils of China: distribution, influencing factors, health risk and regression prediction. Environ Pollut, 2019, 254 112930

[] Zhang Y, Yang R, Si X, Duan X, Quan X. The adverse effect of biochar to aquatic algae-the role of free radicals. Environ Pollut, 2019, 248: 429-437

[] Zhang K, Wang Y, Mao J, Chen B. Effects of biochar nanoparticles on seed germination and seedling growth. Environ Pollut, 2020, 256 113409

[] Zhang P, Zhang X, Li Y, Han L. Influence of pyrolysis temperature on chemical speciation, leaching ability, and environmental risk of heavy metals in biochar derived from cow manure. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 302 122850

[] Zhang Y, Chen Z, Xu W, Liao Q, Zhang H, Hao S, Chen S. Pyrolysis of various phytoremediation residues for biochars: chemical forms and environmental risk of Cd in biochar. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 299 122581

[] Zhang Y, Wang J, Feng Y. The effects of biochar addition on soil physicochemical properties: a review. CATENA, 2021, 202 105284

[] Zhang Z, Ning S, Li Q, Sun M, Lin J, Wang X. Levels and risk assessment of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in wood vinegars from pyrolysis of biomass. Chemosphere, 2021, 278 130453

[] Zhang X, Li B, Schillereff DN, Chiverrell RC, Tefsen B, Wells M. Whole-cell biosensors for determination of bioavailable pollutants in soils and sediments: theory and practice. Sci Total Environ, 2022, 811 152178

[] Zhang Y, Han M, Si X, Bai L, Zhang C, Quan X. Toxicity of biochar influenced by aging time and environmental factors. Chemosphere, 2022, 298 134262

[] Zhang R, Zhang R, Zimmerman AR, Wang H, Gao B. Applications, impacts, and management of biochar persistent free radicals: a review. Environ Pollut, 2023, 327 121543

[] Zhao Y, Li X, Li Y, Bao H, Xing J, Zhu Y, Nan J, Xu G. Biochar acts as an emerging soil amendment and its potential ecological risks: a review. Energies, 2022, 16: 410

[] Zhu K, Jia H, Sun Y, Dai Y, Zhang C, Guo X, Wang T, Zhu L. Enhanced cytotoxicity of photoaged phenol-formaldehyde resins microplastics: combined effects of environmentally persistent free radicals, reactive oxygen species, and conjugated carbonyls. Environ Int, 2020, 145 106137

[] Zhu Y, Elcin E, Jiang M, Li B, Wang H, Zhang X, Wang Z. Use of whole-cell bioreporters to assess bioavailability of contaminants in aquatic systems. Front Chem, 2022, 10: 1018124

[] Zhu X, Xiang Q, Chen L, Chen J, Wang L, Jiang N, Hao X, Zhang H, Wang X, Li Y. Engineered Bacillus subtilis Biofilm@ Biochar living materials for in-situ sensing and bioremediation of heavy metal ions pollution. J Hazard Mater, 2024, 465 133119

Funding

National Natural Science Foundation of China(42107245)