Towards a high-quality fertilizer based on algae residues treated via hydrothermal carbonization. Trends on how process parameters influence inorganics

Abstract

The use of beach-cast macroalgae as a fertilizer (F) or soil amendment (SA) is coming back into focus, due to its highly efficient transformation of CO₂, nutrients, salts and minerals from its aqueous surroundings into biomass. This research studied the hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of Fucus vesiculosus macroalgae to hydrochar and evaluated its feasibility for use in soil applications. F. vesiculosus was submitted to HTC following a full factorial design of experiments with three HTC process parameters varied to assess their impact on the hydrochars: temperature (T: 160, 190, 220 °C), solid content (%So: 20, 35%), and process water recirculation (PWrec: yes and no). In general, F. vesiculosus and its hydrochars were rich in nutrients, but also contained regulated heavy metals. Investigation of the partitioning behavior of inorganic elements between the hydrochars and process water showed that heavy metals like Cr, Pb, Co and Cu tended to accumulate in the hydrochar, unaffected by HTC conditions. Nutrients such as P, N, B, and Mn were primarily found in the hydrochar and could be partially influenced to transfer to process water by changing %So and T. The correlation between the mass fractions of 22 elements in the hydrochar and HTC process parameters was studied. T was the most influential parameter, showing a significant positive correlation for eleven elements. %So and PWrec showed inconsistent effects on different elements. When process water was recirculated, some elements decreased (Ca, Cd, Fe) while others increased (K, Na, B, N) in the hydrochar. Assessment against various regulations and standards for F and SA revealed that F. vesiculosus complied with Cd limit values for most rules including the EURF and B, and was regulated only in the RAL for SA, over the limit value. In contrast, the limit value of Cd for both F and SA applications was surpassed in the 13 hydrochars. The contents of N, P, K, S, and Na in the feedstock and hydrochars complied with European F and SA rules, while they were too high for German rules on SA. The other limits for F rules were achieved (under certain HTC process parameters) except for P (lower than the requirements in F for F. vesiculosus and its hydrochars).

Highlights

•	The brown algae complied with most limit values for Cd content to be applied as soil amendment or as fertilizer.
•	Hydrochars from brown algae did not comply with any Cd limit values. No HTC process condition reduced the Cd content to comply with the requirements.
•	Inorganic mass fractions were mostly influenced by temperature (positively correlated with 11/22 elements), followed by water recirculation (7) and solid content (6).
•	Heavy metals accumulate in hydrochars across all HTC conditions. The partitioning for some elements (e.g., Cd, Co, Cu, W, V) showed no correlation with process conditions.

Keywords

Hydrochar / Hydrothermal carbonization / Distribution of elements / Limit values / Quality assessment / Soil application

References

[1] Álvarez-Murillo A, Román S, Ledesma B, Sabio E. Study of variables in energy densification of olive stone by hydrothermal carbonization. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 2015, 113: 307-314,

[2] Anastasakis K, Ross AB. Hydrothermal liquefaction of the brown macro-alga Laminaria saccharina: effect of reaction conditions on product distribution and composition. Bioresour Technol, 2011, 102(7): 4876-4883,

[3] Aragón-Briceño CI, Pozarlik AK, Bramer EA, Niedzwiecki L, Pawlak-Kruczek H, Brem G. Hydrothermal carbonization of wet biomass from nitrogen and phosphorus approach: a review. Renew Energy, 2021, 171: 401-415,

[4] Aragon-Briceño C, Pożarlik A, Bramer E, Brem G, Wang S, Wen Y, Yang W, Pawlak-Kruczek H, Niedźwiecki Ł, Urbanowska A, Mościcki K, Płoszczyca M. Integration of hydrothermal carbonization treatment for water and energy recovery from organic fraction of municipal solid waste digestate. Renew Energy, 2022, 184: 577-591,

[5] BioAbfV (1998) Ordinance on the utilisation of biowastes on land used for agricultural, silvicultural and horticultural purposes

[6] Breulmann M, Van Afferden M, Müller RA, Schulz E, Fühner C. Process conditions of pyrolysis and hydrothermal carbonization affect the potential of sewage sludge for soil carbon sequestration and amelioration. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis, 2017, 124: 256-265,

[7] Brown AE, Finnerty GL, Camargo-Valero MA, Ross AB. Valorisation of macroalgae via the integration of hydrothermal carbonisation and anaerobic digestion. Bioresour Technol, 2020, 312,

[8] Bundesministerium der Justiz, and Bundesamt für Justiz (2022) German fertilizer legislation (DüngG)

[9] Chen X, Lin Q, He R, Zhao X, Li G. Hydrochar production from watermelon peel by hydrothermal carbonization. Bioresour Technol, 2017, 241: 236-243,

[10] Chen C, Liang W, Fan F, Wang C. The effect of temperature on the properties of hydrochars obtained by hydrothermal carbonization of waste Camellia oleifera shells. ACS Omega, 2021, 6(25): 16546-16552,

[11] Congsomjit D, Areeprasert C. Hydrochar-derived activated carbon from sugar cane bagasse employing hydrothermal carbonization and steam activation for syrup decolorization. Biomass Convers Biorefin, 2021, 11(6): 2569-2584,

[12] Davis JG, Whiting D (2013) Choosing a soil amendment. Gardening series, Colorado State University (fact sheet no. 7235)

[13] Dima SS, Arnob A, Salma U, Kabir KB, Kirtania K. Fate of nutrients during hydrothermal carbonization of biogenic municipal waste. Biomass Convers Biorefin, 2022, 12(1): 71-80,

[14] DIN EN 12880 (2000) Characterization of sludges—determination of dry residue and water content

[15] DIN EN 13657 (2003) Characterization of waste—digestion for subsequent determination of aqua regia soluble portion of elements in waste

[16] DIN EN 16173 (2012) Sludge, treated biowaste and soil—digestion of nitric acid soluble fractions of elements, p 15

[17] DIN EN 15936 (2022) Soil, waste, treated biowaste and sludge—determination of total organic carbon (TOC) by dry combustion, p 26

[18] DIN EN ISO 5983-1 (2005) Animal feeding stuffs—determination of nitrogen content and calculation of crude protein content—part 1: Kjeldahl method, p 15

[19] Dominik W, Pablo A, Sonja H, Fernando C, Luca F, Andrea K. Process water recirculation during hydrothermal carbonization as a promising process step towards the production of nitrogen-doped carbonaceous materials. Waste Biomass Valorization, 2022, 13(4): 2349-2373,

[20] DüMV (2012) Fertiliser ordinance (DüMV), ordinance about the placing of fertilisers, soil additives, growing media and plant additives on the market. Federal Law Gazette 2524 (2008)

[21] EBC (2022) European biochar certificate—guidelines for a sustainable production of biochar

[22] Ekpo U, Ross AB, Camargo-Valero MA, Fletcher LA. Influence of pH on hydrothermal treatment of swine manure: impact on extraction of nitrogen and phosphorus in process water. Bioresour Technol, 2016, 214: 637-644,

[23] EN 12879 (2000) Characterization of sludges. Determination of the loss of ignition of dry mass

[24] EU Parliament (2019) Regulation (EU) 2019/1009 laying down rules on the making available on the market of EU fertilising products. Off J Eur Union

[25] Fan F, Yang Z, Li H, Shi Z, Kan H. Preparation and properties of hydrochars from macadamia nut shell via hydrothermal carbonization. R Soc Open Sci, 2018, 5(10),

[26] FAO. . World fertilizer trends and outlook to 2020, 2017 Rome FAO

[27] Fernandez L (2022) World fertilizer consumption by nutrient 1965–2019. Statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/438967/fertilizer-consumption-globally-by-nutrient/. Accessed 1 June 2022

[28] Foday EH Jr, Bo B, Xu X. Removal of toxic heavy metals from contaminated aqueous solutions using seaweeds: a review. Sustainability, 2021, 13(21): 12311,

[29] Forsberg A, Peders M. Studies on metal content in the brown seaweed, Fucus vesiculosus, from the archipelago of Stockholm. Environ Pollut, 1988, 49(4): 245-263,

[30] Franzén D, Infantes E, Gröndahl F. Beach-cast as biofertiliser in the Baltic Sea region-potential limitations due to cadmium-content. Ocean Coast Manag, 2019, 169: 20-26,

[31] Ghanim BM, Pandey DS, Kwapinski W, Leahy JJ. Hydrothermal carbonisation of poultry litter: effects of treatment temperature and residence time on yields and chemical properties of hydrochars. Bioresour Technol, 2016, 216: 373-380,

[32] Greger M, Malm T, Kautsky L. Heavy metal transfer from composted macroalgae to crops. Eur J Agron, 2007, 26(3): 257-265,

[33] Han W, Clarke W, Pratt S. Composting of waste algae: a review. Waste Manag, 2014, 34(7): 1148-1155,

[34] He BB, Bi Z, Chen L. Assessment of heavy metals in hydrochar produced by hydrothermal carbonization of dairy manure. Front Agric Sci Eng, 2023,

[35] Heilmann SM, Jader LR, Sadowsky MJ, Schendel FJ, von Keitz MG, Valentas KJ. Hydrothermal carbonization of distiller’s grains. Biomass Bioenergy, 2011, 35(7): 2526-2533,

[36] Heilmann SM, Molde JS, Timler JG, Wood BM, Mikula AL, Vozhdayev GV, Colosky EC, Spokas KA, Valentas KJ. Phosphorus reclamation through hydrothermal carbonization of animal manures. Environ Sci Technol, 2014, 48(17): 10323-10329,

[37] Huang R, Tang Y, Luo L. Thermochemistry of sulfur during pyrolysis and hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludges. Waste Manag, 2021, 121: 276-285,

[38] IBI (2015) Standardized product definition and product testing guidelines for biochar that is used in soil V2.1. BI-STD-2.1

[39] Jasiūnas L, Pedersen TH, Rosendahl LA. Biocrude production via non-catalytic supercritical hydrothermal liquefaction of Fucus vesiculosus seaweed processing residues. Recycling, 2021, 6(3): 45,

[40] Kalderis D, Stavroulakis G, Tsubota T, Çalhan SD. Valorization of aloe vera waste for the production of Ca and P-rich hydrochars. Sustain Chem Environ, 2024, 5,

[41] Kantarli İC, Pala M, Yildirim Y, Yanik J, Abreu MH. Fuel characteristics and combustion behavior of seaweed-derived hydrochars. Turk J Chem, 2019,

[42] Kergosien N, Stiger-Pouvreau V, Connan S, Hennequart F, Brébion J. Mini-review: brown macroalgae as a promising raw material to produce biostimulants for the agriculture sector. Front Agron, 2023, 5: 1109989,

[43] Kozyatnyk I, Benavente V, Weidemann E, Gentili FG, Jansson S. Influence of hydrothermal carbonization conditions on the porosity, functionality, and sorption properties of microalgae hydrochars. Sci Rep, 2023, 13(1): 8562,

[44] Levine RB, Sambolin CO, Sierra RH, Obeid W, Hatcher PG, Savage PE. The use of hydrothermal carbonization to recycle nutrients in algal biofuel production. Environ Prog Sustain Energy, 2013, 32(4): 962-975,

[45] Løes A-K, Sandquist J, Meyer G. Elemental composition and phosphorus availability in hydrochars from seaweed and organic waste digestate. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Sect B Soil Plant Sci, 2018, 68(1): 57-66,

[46] Madejón E, Panettieri M, Madejón P, Pérez-de-Mora A. Composting as sustainable managing option for seaweed blooms on recreational beaches. Waste Biomass Valorization, 2022, 13(2): 863-875,

[47] Marzban N, Libra JA, Hosseini SH, Fischer MG, Rotter VS. Experimental evaluation and application of genetic programming to develop predictive correlations for hydrochar higher heating value and yield to optimize the energy content. J Environ Chem Eng, 2022, 10(6),

[48] Méndez A, Gascó G, Ruiz B, Fuente E. Hydrochars from industrial macroalgae ‘Gelidium sesquipedale’ biomass wastes. Bioresour Technol, 2019, 275: 386-393,

[49] Merzari F, Lucian M, Volpe M, Andreottola G, Fiori L. Hydrothermal carbonization of biomass: design of a bench-scale reactor for evaluating the heat of reaction. Chem Eng Trans, 2018,

[50] Milledge J, Nielsen B, Maneein S, Harvey P. A brief review of anaerobic digestion of algae for bioenergy. Energies, 2019, 12(6): 1166,

[51] Mouritsen OG. . Seaweeds: edible, available, and sustainable, 2013 Chicago Chicago Press,

[52] Nielsen HB, Heiske S. Anaerobic digestion of macroalgae: methane potentials, pre-treatment, inhibition and co-digestion. Water Sci Technol, 2011, 64(8): 1723-1729,

[53] Pardilhó S, Cotas J, Pereira L, Oliveira MB, Dias JM. Marine macroalgae in a circular economy context: a comprehensive analysis focused on residual biomass. Biotechnol Adv, 2022, 60,

[54] Park KY, Lee K, Kim D. Characterized hydrochar of algal biomass for producing solid fuel through hydrothermal carbonization. Bioresour Technol, 2018, 258: 119-124,

[55] Patel N, Acharya B, Basu P. Hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of seaweed (macroalgae) for producing hydrochar. Energies, 2021, 14(7): 1805,

[56] Picone A, Volpe M, Messineo A. Process water recirculation during hydrothermal carbonization of waste biomass: current knowledge and challenges. Energies, 2021, 14(10): 2962,

[57] Ponce NMA, Stortz CA. A comprehensive and comparative analysis of the fucoidan compositional data across the phaeophyceae. Front Plant Sci, 2020, 11,

[58] Publications Office of the European Union (2022) Safe and effective fertilising products on the EU market. Summaries of EU legislation. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=legissum:4406079

[59] RAL Deutsches Institut für Gütesicherung und Kennzeichnung e.V. (2016) RAL-GZ 251, KOMPOST. Beuth-Verlag GmbH

[60] Román S, Ledesma B, Álvarez A, Coronella C, Qaramaleki SV. Suitability of hydrothermal carbonization to convert water hyacinth to added-value products. Renew Energy, 2020, 146: 1649-1658,

[61] Roy RN, Finck N, Blair GJ, Tandon HLS. . Plant nutrition for food security: a guide for integrated nutrient management, 2006 Rome Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

[62] Sansinenea E. Application of biofertilizers: current worldwide status. Biofertilizers, 2021 Amsterdam Elsevier 183-190,

[63] Savci S. An agricultural pollutant: chemical fertilizer. Int J Environ Sci Dev, 2012, 3: 73-80,

[64] Schultz-Zehden A, Matczak M. . Submariner compendium: an assessment of innovative and sustainable uses of Baltic marine resources, 2012 Gdańsk Maritime Institute in Gdańsk

[65] Schumacher M, Yanık J, Sınağ A, Kruse A. Hydrothermal conversion of seaweeds in a batch autoclave. J Supercrit Fluids, 2011, 58(1): 131-135,

[66] Seisuma Z, Kuļikova I, Botva U, Boikova E. Long-term investigation of metal concentrations in brown algae Fucus vesiculosus from the Gulf of Riga, Baltic Sea. Proc Latvian Acad Sci Sect B Nat Exact Appl Sci, 2011, 65(5–6): 186-191,

[67] Silva CC, Melo CA, Junior FHS, Moreira AB, Ferreira OP, Bisinoti MC. Effect of the reaction medium on the immobilization of nutrients in hydrochars obtained using sugarcane industry residues. Bioresour Technol, 2017,

[68] Singh R, Bhaskar T, Balagurumurthy B. Hydrothermal upgradation of algae into value-added hydrocarbons. Biofuels from algae, 2014 Amsterdam Elsevier 235-260,

[69] Smith AM, Ross AB. Production of bio-coal, bio-methane and fertilizer from seaweed via hydrothermal carbonisation. Algal Res, 2016, 16: 1-11,

[70] Söderlund S, Forsberg A, Pedersén M. Concentrations of cadmium and other metals in Fucus vesiculosus L. and Fontinalis dalecarlica Br. Eur. from the northern Baltic Sea and the southern Bothnian Sea. Environ Pollut, 1987, 51: 197-212,

[71] Sun J, Ding S-Y, Peterson JD. . Biological conversion of biomass for fuels and chemicals, 2013 Cambridge Royal Society of Chemistry 407,

[72] Suwelack K, Wüst D, Zeller M, Kruse A, Krümpel J. Hydrothermal carbonization of wheat straw—prediction of product mass yields and degree of carbonization by severity parameter. Biomass Convers Biorefin, 2015, 6: 1-8,

[73] Terauchi M, Nagasato C, Inoue A, Ito T, Motomura T. Distribution of alginate and cellulose and regulatory role of calcium in the cell wall of the brown alga Ectocarpus siliculosus (Ectocarpales, Phaeophyceae). Planta, 2016, 244(2): 361-377,

[74] Ullah K, Ahmad M, Sofia VK, Sharma PL, Harvey A, Zafar M, Sultana S, Anyanwu CN. Algal biomass as a global source of transport fuels: overview and development perspectives. Progr Nat Sci Mater Int, 2014, 24(4): 329-339,

[75] Universität Hamburg (2004) Botany online: cell wall—cell walls of algae. Botany Online. https://www-archiv.fdm.uni-hamburg.de/b-online/e26/26d.htm. Accessed 23 Mar 2024

[76] Wang T, Zhai Y, Zhu Y, Li C, Zeng G. A review of the hydrothermal carbonization of biomass waste for hydrochar formation: process conditions, fundamentals, and physicochemical properties. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2018, 90: 223-247,

[77] Wang L, Chang Y, Liu Q. Fate and distribution of nutrients and heavy metals during hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge with implication to land application. J Clean Prod, 2019, 225: 972-983,

[78] Weinberger F, Paalme T, Wikström SA. Seaweed resources of the Baltic Sea, Kattegat and German and Danish North Sea Coasts. Bot Mar, 2020, 63(1): 61-72,

[79] Wellinger A (2009) Algal biomass does it save the world? IEA Bioenergy, p 13

[80] Xiong J, Chen S, Wang J, Wang Y, Fang X, Huang H. Speciation of main nutrients (N/P/K) in hydrochars produced from the hydrothermal carbonization of swine manure under different reaction temperatures. Materials, 2021, 14(15): 4114,

[81] Xu Q, Qian Q, Quek A, Ai N, Zeng G, Wang J. Hydrothermal carbonization of macroalgae and the effects of experimental parameters on the properties of hydrochars. ACS Sustain Chem Eng, 2013, 1(9): 1092-1101,

[82] Zárate R, Portillo E, Teixidó S, Pinheiro MAA, Carvalho De, Nunes N, Ferraz S, Seca AML, Rosa GP, Barreto MC. Pharmacological and cosmeceutical potential of seaweed beach-casts of macaronesia. Appl Sci, 2020, 10(17): 5831,

[83] Zhang J-H, Lin Q-M, Zhao X-R. The hydrochar characters of municipal sewage sludge under different hydrothermal temperatures and durations. J Integr Agric, 2014, 13(3): 471-482,

[84] Zhao X, Huang J, Li Z, Chen Y, Müller M. Influence of reaction time, temperature, and heavy metal zinc on characteristics of cellulose- and wood-derived hydrochars from hydrothermal carbonization. BioEnergy Res, 2023, 16(2): 856-864,

Funding

Technische Universit?t Berlin(DEAL Springer Nature); Technische Universit?t Berlin (3136)