Robotic esophagectomy: the evolution of open esophagectomy to current techniques and a review of the literature

Abstract

Esophageal cancer persists as one of the most common causes of cancer-related death and 5-year survival remains poor at 20%. Surgical resection is the gold standard for treatment and cure, and the development of minimally invasive surgery has increased the popularity of robotic-assisted minimally-invasive esophagectomy. The benefits described include less morbidity and greater patient satisfaction compared to open techniques. Nevertheless, institution capabilities and surgeon experience are strong determinants of whether a robotic program will be adopted for oncologic esophageal care. Thus, we review the available literature regarding the history of esophagectomy, evolution to minimally invasive approaches, the introduction of robotic-assisted esophagectomy including its respective outcomes in comparison to open and minimally invasive approaches, and future directions.

Keywords

Minimally invasive / esophageal cancer / esophagectomy / lymph node dissection / robotic-assisted esophagectomy / Ivor Lewis / McKeown / transhiatal

References

[1] Malhotra GK,Ravipati A,Vijayakumar M.Global trends in esophageal cancer..J Surg Oncol2017;115:564-79

[2] Mariette C,Dabakuyo-Yonli TS,Pezet D.Hybrid minimally invasive esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..N Engl J Med2019;380:152-62

[3] American Cancer Society. Key Statistics for Lung Cancer. Available from: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/non-small-cell-lung-cancer/about/key-statistics.html [Last accessed on 13 May 2020]

[4] Enzinger PC.Esophageal cancer..N Engl J Med2003;349:2241-52

[5] Giugliano DN,Rosato EL.Total minimally invasive esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: approaches and outcomes..Langenbecks Arch Surg2016;401:747-56

[6] Sabra MJ,Kraemer DF,Tepas JJ Rd.The effects of neoadjuvant therapy on morbidity and mortality of esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: American college of surgeons national surgical quality improvement program (ACS-NSQIP) 2005-2012..J Surg Oncol2017;115:296-300

[7] Taurchini M.Minimally invasive and robotic esophagectomy: state of the art..J Vis Surg2017;3:125 PMCID:PMC5639027

[8] Schumer E,Melvin WS.Minimally invasive esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: evolution and review..Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech2012;22:383-6

[9] Tagkalos E,Hoppe-Lotichius M,Babic B.Robot-assisted minimally invasive esophagectomy (RAMIE) compared to conventional minimally invasive esophagectomy (MIE) for esophageal cancer: a propensity-matched analysis..Dis Esophagus2020;33:doz060

[10] Torek F.The causes of failure in the operative treatment of carcinoma of the esophagus..Ann Surg1929;90:496-506 PMCID:PMC1399094

[11] Kauppila JH,Johar A,Lagergren P.Meta-analysis of health-related quality of life after minimally invasive versus open oesophagectomy for oesophageal cancer..Br J Surg2017;104:1131-40

[12] Glatz T,Kulemann B,Hopt UT.Hybrid minimally invasive esophagectomy vs. open esophagectomy: a matched case analysis in 120 patients..Langenbecks Arch Surg2017;402:323-31

[13] Torek F.The operative treatment of carcinoma of the esophagus..Ann Surg1915;61:385-405 PMCID:PMC1406635

[14] Karamanou M,Papaioannou TG,Androutsos G.Hallmarks in history of esophageal carcinoma..J BUON.2017;22:1088-1091

[15] Lewis I.The surgical treatment of carcinoma of the oesophagus; with special reference to a new operation for growths of the middle third..Br J Surg1946;34:18-31

[16] McKeown KC.Total three-stage oesophagectomy for cancer of the oesophagus..Br J Surg1976;63:259-62

[17] Orringer MB.Esophagectomy without thoracotomy..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1978;76:643-54

[18] Rindani R,Cox MR.Transhiatal versus Ivor-Lewis oesophagectomy: is there a difference?.Aust N Z J Surg1999;69:187-94

[19] Homesh NA,Al-Agmar MH,Valenzuela RE.Transhiatal versus transthoracic resection for oesophageal carcinoma in Yemen..Singapore Med J2006;47:54-9

[20] Shichinohe T,Kondo S.Video-assisted esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..Surg Today2008;38:206-13

[21] Booka E,Kikuchi H,Kamiya K.Recent advances in thoracoscopic esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..Asian J Endosc Surg2019;12:19-29

[22] Dallemagne B,Jehaes C,Lombard R.Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication: preliminary report..Surg Laparosc Endosc1991;1:138-43

[23] Cuschieri A,Banting S.Endoscopic oesophagectomy through a right thoracoscopic approach..J R Coll Surg Edinb1992;37:7-11

[24] Cuschieri A.Endoscopic subtotal oesophagectomy for cancer using the right thoracoscopic approach..Surg Oncol1993;2:3-11

[25] Collard JM,Otte JB.En bloc and standard esophagectomies by thoracoscopy..Ann Thorac Surg1993;56:675-9

[26] DePaula AL,Ferreira EA,Grecco E.Laparoscopic transhiatal esophagectomy with esophagogastroplasty..Surg Laparosc Endosc1995;5:1-5

[27] Murthy RA,Kernstine KH Sr.Minimally invasive and robotic esophagectomy: a review..Innovations (Phila)2018;13:391-403

[28] Levy RM,Luketich JD.Minimally invasive esophagectomy..Surg Clin North Am2012;92:1265-85

[29] Levy RM,Luketich JD.Randomized trial comparing minimally invasive esophagectomy and open esophagectomy: early perioperative outcomes appear improved with a minimally invasive approach..Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2012;24:153-4

[30] Luketich JD,Awais O,Keeley S.Outcomes after minimally invasive esophagectomy: review of over 1000 patients..Ann Surg2012;256:95-103 PMCID:PMC4103614

[31] Suzuki Y,Ishibashi Y,Omura N.Hand-assisted laparoscopic and thoracoscopic surgery (HALTS) in radical esophagectomy with three-field lymphadenectomy for thoracic esophageal cancer..Eur J Surg Oncol2005;31:1166-74

[32] Oshikiri T,Miura S,Hasegawa H.Current status of minimally invasive esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: Is it truly less invasive?..Ann Gastroenterol Surg2018;3:138-45 PMCID:PMC6422792

[33] Biere SS,Maas KW,Rosman C.Minimally invasive versus open oesophagectomy for patients with oesophageal cancer: a multicentre, open-label, randomised controlled trial..Lancet2012;379:1887-92

[34] Seesing MFJ,Goense L,Kroon HM.A Propensity Score Matched Analysis of Open Versus Minimally Invasive Transthoracic Esophagectomy in the Netherlands..Ann Surg2017;266:839-46

[35] Mamidana R,Aylin P,Hanna GB.Short-term outcomes following open versus minimally invasive esophagectomy for cancer in England: a population-based national study..Ann Surg2012;255:197-203

[36] Nozaki I,Igaki H,Daiko H.Evaluation of safety profile of thoracoscopic esophagectomy for T1bN0M0 cancer using data from JCOG0502: a prospective multicenter study..Surg Endosc2015;29:3519-26 PMCID:PMC4648951

[37] Takeuchi H,Ozawa S,Osugi H.Comparison of Short-Term Outcomes Between Open and Minimally Invasive Esophagectomy for Esophageal Cancer Using a Nationwide Database in Japan..Ann Surg Oncol2017;24:1821-27

[38] Melvin WS,Krause KR,Wolf RK.Computer-enhanced robotic telesurgery. Initial experience in foregut surgery..Surg Endosc2002;16:1790-2

[39] Kernstine KH,Karimi M,Campos JH.The robotic, 2-stage, 3-field esophagolymphadenectomy..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2004;127:1847-9

[40] Kernstine KH,Shamoun DM.The first series of completely robotic esophagectomies with three-field lymphadenectomy: initial experience..Surg Endosc2007;21:2285-92

[41] Dunn DH,Morphew JA,Krueger JL.Robotic-assisted transhiatal esophagectomy: a 3-year single center experience..Dis esophagus2013;26:159-66

[42] Gerhardus D.Robotic -assisted surgery: the future is here..J Healthc Manag2003;48:242-51

[43] Decker G,De Leyn P,Nafteux P.Minimally invasive esophagectomy for cancer..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2009;35:13-20discussion 20-1

[44] Claassen L,Rosman C.Learning curve and postoperative outcomes of minimally invasive esophagectomy..J Thorac Dis2019;11:S777-85 PMCID:PMC6503284

[45] Park SY,Kang DR.Learning curve for robotic esophagectomy and dissection of bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve nodes for esophageal cancer..Dis Esophagus2017;30:1-9

[46] Zhang H,Wang Z,Geng Y.The learning curve for robotic McKeown Esophagectomy in Patients with esophageal cancer..Ann Thorac Surg2018;105:1024-30

[47] Park S,Lee HJ,Kim YT.A study of the learning curve for robotic oesophagecotmy for oesophageal cancer..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2018;53:862-70

[48] Giulianotti PC,Angelini M,Cecconi S.Robotics in general surgery: personal experience in a large community hospital..Arch Surg2003;138:777-84

[49] Horgan S,Elli EF.Robotic-assisted minimally invasive transhiatal esophagectomy..Am Surg2003;69:624-6

[50] Bodner JC,Ott H,Wykypiel H.Robotic-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (RATS) for benign and malignant esophageal tumors..Ann Thorac Surg2005;80:1202-6

[51] Ruurda JP,van Hillegersberg R,Gooszen HG.Robot-assisted endoscopic surgery: a four-year single-center experience..Dig Surg2005;22:313-20

[52] Dapri G,Cadiere GB.Robot-assisted thoracoscopic esophagectomy with the patient in the prone position..J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A2006;16:278-85

[53] Espat NJ,Horgan S.Minimally invasive treatment of esophageal cancer: laparoscopic staging to robotic esophagectomy..Cancer J2005;11:10-7

[54] van Hillegersberg R,Draaisma WA,Giezeman MJ.First experience with robot-assisted thoracoscopic esophagolymphadenectomy for esophageal cancer..Surg Endosc2006;20:1435-9

[55] Anderson C,Kernstine K,Lai L.Robotic surgery for gastrointestinal malignancies..Int J Med Robot Comput Assist Surg2007;3:297-300

[56] Braumann C,Menenakos C,Rueckert JC.Robotic-assisted laparoscopic and thoracoscopic surgery with the da Vinci system: a 4-year experience in a single institution..Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech2008;18:260-6

[57] Galvani CA,Moser F.Robotically assisted laparoscopic transhiatal esophagectomy..Surg Endosc2008;22:188-95

[58] Boone J,Moojen WA,Cromheecke GJ.Robot-assisted thoracoscopic oesophagectomy for cancer..Br J Surg2009;96:878-86

[59] Kim DJ,Lee CY,Haam SJ.Thoracoscopic esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: feasibility and safety of robotic assistance in the prone position..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2010;139:53-9

[60] Puntambekar SP,Joshi S.Robotic transthoracic esophagectomy in the prone position: experience with 32 patients with esophageal cancer..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2011;142:1283-4

[61] Suda K,Kawamura Y,Kanaya S.Robot-assisted thoracoscopic lymphadenectomy along the left recurrent laryngeal nerve for esophageal squamous cell carcinoma in the prone position: technical report and short-term outcomes..World J Surg2012;36:1608-16

[62] Cerfolio RJ,Hawn MT.Technical aspects and early results of robotic esophagectomy with chest anastomosis..J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2013;145:90-6

[63] de la Fuente SG,Hoffe SE,Karl R.Initial experience from a large referral center with robotic-assisted Ivor Lewis esophagogastrectomy for oncologic purposes..Surg Endosc2013;27:3339-47

[64] Diez Del Val I,Larburu Etxaniz S,Leturio Fernandez S.Contribution of robotics to minimally invasive esophagectomy..J Robot Surg2013;7:325-32

[65] Hernandez JM,Weber J,Hoffe S.Defining the learning curve for robotic-assisted esophagogastrectomy..J Gastrointest Surg2013;17:1346-51

[66] Ishikawa N,Inaki N,Shimada M.Robot-assisted thoracoscopic hybrid esophagectomy in the semi-prone position under pneumothorax..Artif Organs2013;37:576-80

[67] Mori K,Wada I,Nomura S.Robotic-assisted totally transhiatal lymphadenectomy in the middle mediastinum for esophageal cancer..J Robot Surg2013;7:385-7 PMCID:PMC3835922

[68] Weksler B,Moudgill N,Rosato EL.Robot-assisted minimally invasive esophagectomy is equivalent to thoracoscopic minimally invasive esophagectomy..Dis Esophagus2012;25:403-9

[69] Sarkaria IS,Finley DJ,Adusumilli PS.Combined thoracoscopic and laparoscopic robotic-assisted minimally invasive robotic esophagectomy using a 4-arm platform: experience, technique and cautions during early procedure development..Eu J Cardiothorac Surg2013;43:107-15

[70] Coker AM,Cheverie J,Sandler BJ.Outcomes of robotic-assisted transhiatal esophagectomy for esophageal cancer after neoadjuvant chemoradiation..J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A2014;24:89-94

[71] Sarkaria IS,Finley DJ,Huang J.Intraoperative near-infrared fluorescence imaging as an adjunct to robotic-assisted minimally invasive esophagectomy..Innovations (Phila)2014;9:391-3 PMCID:PMC5523952

[72] Trugeda S,Rodriguez-Sanjuan JC,Fernandez-Escalante C.Initial results of robot-assisted Ivor-Lewis oesophagectomy with intrathoracic hand-sewn anastomosis in the prone position..Int J Med Robot2014;10:397-403

[73] Puntambekar S,Kumar S,Argawal G.Robotic transthoracic esophagectomy..BMC Surg2015;15:47 PMCID:PMC4417322

[74] Cerfolio RJ,Hawn MT.Robotic esophagectomy for cancer: early results and lessons learned..Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2016;28:160-9

[75] Peng JS,Hochwald SN.Technique for robotic ivor lewis esophagectomy with 6-cm linear stapled side-to-side anastomosis..Ann Surg Oncol2020;27:824

[76] Plat VD,Schoonmade LJ,van der Peet DL.Implementation of robot-assisted Ivor Lewis procedure: robotic hand-sewn, linear or circular technique?.Am J Surg2020;220:62-8

[77] Zhang H,Zheng Y,Wang F.Robotic side-to-side and end-to-side stapled esophagogastric anastomosis of Ivor Lewis esophagectomy for cancer..World J Surg.2019;43:3074-82

[78] Wang Z,Wang F.Robotic-assisted esophagogastric reconstruction in minimally invasive Ivor Lewis esophagectomy..J THorac Dis2019;11:1860-66 PMCID:PMC6588751

[79] Grimminger PP,Babic B,Lang H.Innovative fully robotic 4-arm Ivor Lewis esophagectomy for esophageal cancer (RAMIE4)..Dis Esophagus2020;33:doz015

[80] Wang WP,Zhang HL,He SL.Modified Intrathoracic Esophaphagogastrostomy with minimally invasive robot-assisted Ivor-Lewis esophagectomy for cancer..Dig Surg2019;36:218-25

[81] Zhang Y,Han Y,Hang J.Initial experience of robot-assisted Ivor Lewis esophagectomy: 61 consecutive cases from a single Chinese institution..Dis Esophagus2018;31:

[82] Nora I,Meredith K.Robotic-assisted Ivor Lewis esophagectomy: technique and early outcomes..Robot Surg2017;4:93-100 PMCID:PMC6193432

[83] Meredith K,Andacoglu O.Safety and feasibility of robotic-assisted Ivor Lewis esophagectomy..Dis Esophagus2018;31:

[84] Horst VD,Hewlett SC.Robotic transhiatal esophagectomy in a community hospital: evolution of technique..Am Surg2016;82:730-2

[85] Gockel I.Oncologic esophageal resection and reconstruction: open, hybrid, minimally invasive or robotic?.Chirurg2017;88:496-502

[86] Washington K,Jay J.Oncologic resection in laparoscopic versus robotic transhiatal esophagectomy..JSLS2019;23:e2019.00017 PMCID:PMC6532833

[87] DeLong JC,Jacobsen GR,Horgan S.The benefits and limitations of robotic assisted transhiatal esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..J Vis Surg2016;2:156 PMCID:PMC5637870

[88] Wecowski J,Jadick MF,Sucandi I.The big deal: an institution’s experience with robotic transhiatal esophagectomy..Am Surg2019;85:1061-65

[89] Kernstine KH,Sahmoun DM.The first series of completely robotic esopahgectomies with three-filed lymphadenectomy: initial experience..Surg Endosc2007;21:2285-92

[90] Patel S,Abbas A.Robotic-assisted McKeown esophagectomy..J Vis Surg2019;5:43 PMCID:PMC6698579

[91] Egberts JH,Hauser C.Robotic-assisted McKeown procedure via a cervical mediastinoscopy avoiding an abdominal and thoracic incision..Thorac Cardiovasc Surg2019;67:610-14

[92] Naffouje SA,Khalaf Z.Outcomes of open versus minimally invasive Ivor Lewis esophagectomy for cancer: a propensity-score matched analysis of NSQIP database..Ann Surg Oncol2019;26:2001-10

[93] Zhang Y,Gan Q,Jin R.Early outcomes of robot-assisted versus thoracoscopic-assisted Ivor Lewis esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: a propensity score-matched study..Ann Surg Oncol2019;26:1284-91

[94] Chao YK,Liu UH.Lymph node evaluation in robot-assisted versus video-assisted thoracoscopic esophagectomy for esophageal squamous cell carcinoma: a propensity-matched analysis..World J Surg2018;42:590-98

[95] van der Sluis PC,van der Horst S,Besselink MG.Robot-assisted minimally invasive thoraco-laparoscopic esophagectomy versus open transthoracic esophagectomy for resectable esophageal cancer, a randomized controlled trial (ROBOT trial)..Trials2012;13:230 PMCID:PMC3564860

[96] van der Sluis PC,May AM,Brosens LAA.Robot-assisted minimally invasive thoracolaparoscopic esophagectomy versus open transthoracic esophagectomy for resectable esophageal cancer: a randomized controlled trial..Ann Surg2019;269:621-30

[97] Lee L,Li C,Fried Gm.Cost-effectiveness of minimally invasive versus open esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..An Surg Oncol2013;20:3732-9

[98] Parameswaran R,Krishnadas R,Berrisford R.Comparative experience of open and minimally invasive esophagogastric resection..World J Surg2009;33:1868-75

[99] Ecker BL,Datta J,Kucharczuk J.Laparoscopic transhiatal esophagectomy improves hospital outcomes and reduces cost: a single-institution analysis of laparoscopic-assisted and open techniques..Surg Endosc2016;30:2535-42

[100] Liu CY,Shih CS,Liu CC.Cost-effectiveness of minimally invasive esophagectomy for esophageal squamous cell carcinoma..World J Surg2018;42:2522-9

[101] Dhamija A,Hancock J,Kim AW.Minimally invasive oesophagectomy more expensive than open despite shorter length of stay..Eur J Cardiothorac Surg2014;45:904-9

[102] Fu SJ,Ginsberg J,Delaney CP.Complications, not minimally invasive surgical technique, are associated with increased cost after esophagectomy..Minim Invasive Surg2016;2016:7690632 PMCID:PMC5178372

[103] Yanasoot A,Ruangsin S,Sunpaweravong S.Costs and benefits of different methods of esophagectomy for esophageal cancer..Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann2017;25:513-7

[104] Klapper JA.Robotic esophagectomy: a better way or just another way?.J Thorac Dis2017;9:2328-31 PMCID:PMC5594117

[105] Sarkaria IS,Goldman DA,Tan KS.Early quality of life outcomes after robotic-assisted minimally invasive and open esophagectomy..Ann Thorac Surg2019;108:920-28 PMCID:PMC6774254

[106] Fujiwara H,Konishi H,Komatsu S.Perioperative outcomes of single-port mediastinoscope-assisted transhiatal esophagectomy for thoracic esophageal cancer..Dis Esophagus2017;30:1-8

[107] Fujiwara H,Konishi H.Transmediastinal approach for esophageal cancer: a new trend toward radical surgery..Asian J Endosc Surg2019;12:30-6

[108] Mori K,Yagi K,Mitsui T.Technical details of video-assisted transcervical mediastinal dissection for esophageal cancer and its perioperative outcome..Ann Gastroenterol Surg2017;1:232-7 PMCID:PMC5881365

[109] Nakauchi M,Suda K,Kikuchi K.Robot-assisted mediastinoscopic esophagectomy for esophageal cancer: the first clinical series..Esophagus2019;16:85-92