A review of factors affecting the success of membrane protein crystallization using bicelles

Abstract

Several reports have been published detailing various platforms for obtaining crystals of membrane proteins to determine their structure including those that use disk shaped bilayers called bicelles. While these crystals have been readily grown and used for X-ray diffraction, the general understanding as to why bicelles are adequate for such a procedure or how to rationally choose conditions remains unknown. This review intends to discuss issues of protein stabilization and precipitation in the presence of lipids that may influence crystal formation.

Key words： bicelle; membrane protein; crystallization

Acknowledgments

This work was supported, in whole or in part, by National Institutes of Health Grants R01-AA018123-S1 and Department of Energy Funding FWP 58701.

References

1 Afzal S, Tesler W J, Blessing S K, Collins J M, Lis L J (1984). Hydration force between phosphatidylcholine surfaces in aqueous electrolyte solutions. J Colloid Interface Sci, 97(2): 303–307

2 Angelov B, Ollivon M, Angelova A (1999). X-Ray diffraction study of the effect of the detergent octyl glucoside on the structure of lamellar and nonlamellar lipid/water phases of use for membrane protein reconstitution. Langmuir, 15(23): 8225–8234

3 Arnold A, Labrot T, Oda R, Dufourc E J (2002). Cation modulation of bicelle size and magnetic alignment as revealed by solid-state NMR and electron microscopy. Biophys J, 83(5): 2667–2680

PMID

4 Bandyopadhyay S, Shelley J C, Klein M L (2001). Molecular dynamics study of the effect of surfactant on a biomembrane. J Phys Chem B, 105(25): 5979–5986

5 Benz R (1988). Structure and function of porins from gram-negative bacteria. Annu Rev Microbiol, 42(1): 359–393

PMID

6 Bokoch M P, Zou Y, Rasmussen S G F, Liu C W, Nygaard R, Rosenbaum D M (2010). Ligand-specific regulation of the extracellular surface of a G-protein-coupled receptor. Nature, 463(7277): 108–112 [10.1038/nature08650]

7 Boni L T, Stewart T P, Alderfer J L, Hui S W (1981). Lipid-polyethylene glycol interactions: II. formation of defects in bilayers. J Membr Biol, 62(1–2): 71–77

PMID

8 Boni L T, Stewart T P, Hui S W (1984). Alterations in phospholipid polymorphism by polyethylene glycol. J Membr Biol, 80(1): 91–104

PMID

9 Branden C, Tooze J (1999). Introduction to Protein Structure. New York: Garland Publisher

11 Caffrey M (2003). Membrane protein crystallization. J Struct Biol, 142(1): 108–132

PMID

12 Carion-Taravella B, Lesieur S, Chopineau J, Lesieur P, Ollivon M (2001). Phase behavior of mixed aqueous dispersions of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dodecyl glycosides: a differential scanning calorimetry and X-ray diffraction investigation. Langmuir, 18(2): 325–335

13 Carpenter E P, Beis K, Cameron A D, Iwata S (2008). Overcoming the challenges of membrane protein crystallography. Curr Opin Struct Biol, 18(5): 581–586

PMID

14 Cherezov V, Clogston J, Misquitta Y, Abdel-Gawad W, Caffrey M (2002). Membrane protein crystallization in meso: lipid type-tailoring of the cubic phase. Biophys J, 83(6): 3393–3407

PMID

15 Cherezov V, Clogston J, Papiz M Z, Caffrey M (2006). Room to move: crystallizing membrane proteins in swollen lipidic mesophases. J Mol Biol, 357(5): 1605–1618

PMID

16 Cho H S, Dominick J L, Spence M M (2010). Lipid domains in bicelles containing unsaturated lipids and cholesterol. J Phys Chem B, 114(28): 9238–9245

PMID

17 Clarke S (1975). The size and detergent binding of membrane proteins. J Biol Chem, 250(14): 5459–5469

PMID

18 Cunningham B A, Shimotake J E, Tamura-Lis W, Mastran T, Kwok W M, Kauffman J W, Lis L J (1986). The influence of ion species on phosphatidylcholine bilayer structure and packing. Chem Phys Lipids, 39(1–2): 135–143

PMID

19 de Planque M R R, Greathouse D V, Koeppe R E 2nd, Schäfer H, Marsh D, Killian J A (1998). Influence of lipid/peptide hydrophobic mismatch on the thickness of diacylphosphatidylcholine bilayers. A 2H NMR and ESR study using designed transmembrane alpha-helical peptides and gramicidin A. Biochemistry, 37(26): 9333–9345

PMID

20 Diller A, Loudet C, Aussenac F, Raffard G, Fournier S, Laguerre M, Grélard A, Opella S J, Marassi F M, Dufourc E J (2009). Bicelles: a natural ‘molecular goniometer’ for structural, dynamical and topological studies of molecules in membranes. Biochimie, 91(6): 744–751

PMID

21 Dumas F, Sperotto M M, Lebrun M C, Tocanne J F, Mouritsen O G (1997). Molecular sorting of lipids by bacteriorhodopsin in dlpc/dspc lipid bilayers. Biophys J, 73(Oct): 1940–1953

PMID

22 Ericsson C A, Söderman O, Garamus V M, Bergström M, Ulvenlund S (2005). Effects of temperature, salt, and deuterium oxide on the self-aggregation of alkylglycosides in dilute solution. 2. n-Tetradecyl-beta-D-maltoside. Langmuir, 21(4): 1507–1515

PMID

23 Ericsson C A, Söderman O, Garamus V M, Bergström M, Ulvenlund S (2004). Effects of temperature, salt, and deuterium oxide on the self-aggregation of alkylglycosides in dilute solution. 1. n-nonyl-beta-D-glucoside. Langmuir, 20(4): 1401–1408

PMID

24 Faham S (2005). Crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin from bicelle formulations at room temperature. Protein Sci, 14: 836–840 [10.1110/ps.041167605]

25 Faham S, Boulting G L, Massey E A, Yohannan S, Yang D, Bowie J U (2005). Crystallization of bacteriorhodopsin from bicelle formulations at room temperature. Protein Sci, 14(3): 836–840

PMID

26 Faham S, Bowie J U (2002). Bicelle crystallization: a new method for crystallizing membrane proteins yields a monomeric bacteriorhodopsin structure. J Mol Biol, 316(1): 1–6

PMID

27 Faham S, Ujwal R, Abramson J, Bowie J U (2009). Chapter 5 Practical Aspects of Membrane Proteins Crystallization in Bicelles. In: LarryD. (Ed.), Current Topics in Membranes (Volume 63, pp. 109–125), Academic Press.

28 Faham S, Yang D, Bare E, Yohannan S, Whitelegge J P, Bowie J U (2004). Side-chain contributions to membrane protein structure and stability. J Mol Biol, 335(1): 297–305

PMID

29 Garavito R M, Picot D (1990). The art of crystallizing membrane proteins. Methods, 1(1): 57–69

30 Garavito R M, Picot D, Loll P J (1996). Strategies for crystallizing membrane proteins. J Bioenerg Biomembr, 28(1): 13–27

PMID

31 Giordano R, Maisano G, Teixeira J (1997). Sans studies of octyl-β-glucoside and glycine micellar solutions. J Appl Crystallography, 30(2): 761–764

32 Glaubitz C, Grobner G, Watts A (2000). Structural and orientational information of the membrane embedded M13 coat protein by 13c-mas Nmr spectroscopy. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)-Biomembranes, 1463(1): 151–161

33 Harroun T A, Koslowsky M, Nieh M P, de Lannoy C F, Raghunathan V A, Katsaras J (2005). Comprehensive examination of mesophases formed by DMPC and DHPC mixtures. Langmuir, 21(12): 5356–5361

PMID

34 Hauser H, Paltauf F, Shipley G G (1982). Structure and thermotropic behavior of phosphatidylserine bilayer membranes. Biochemistry, 21(5): 1061–1067

PMID

35 Heerklotz H, Seelig J (2000). Titration calorimetry of surfactant–membrane partitioning and membrane solubilization. Biomembranes, 1508(1–2): 69–85

36 Helm C A, Tippmann-Krayer P, Möhwald H, Als-Nielsen J, Kjaer K (1991). Phases of phosphatidyl ethanolamine monolayers studied by synchrotron x-ray scattering. Biophys J, 60(6): 1457–1476

PMID

37 Hite R K, Gonen T, Harrison S C, Walz T (2008). Interactions of lipids with aquaporin-0 and other membrane proteins. Pflugers Arch, 456: 651–661 [10.1007/s00424-007-0353-9]

38 Hite R K, Li Z, Walz T (2010). Principles of membrane protein interactions with annular lipids deduced from aquaporin-0 2d crystals. EMBO J, 29(10): 1652–1658 [10.1038/emboj.2010.68]

39 Inoko Y, Yamaguchi T, Furuya K, Mitsui T (1975). Effects of cations on dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine/cholesterol/water systems. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)–Biomembranes, 413(1): 24–32

40 Jacobson K, Ishihara A, Inman R (1987). Lateral diffusion of proteins in membranes. Annu Rev Physiol, 49(1): 163–175

PMID

41 Jaehnig F, Vogel H, Best L (1982). Unifying description of the effect of membrane proteins on lipid order. vVerification for the melittin/dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine system. Biochem, 21(26): 6790–6798

42 Jähnig F (1981). Critical effects from lipid-protein interaction in membranes. I. Theoretical description. Biophys J, 36(2): 329–345

PMID

43 Janiak M J, Small D M, Shipley G G (1976). Nature of the Thermal pretransition of synthetic phospholipids: dimyristolyl- and dipalmitoyllecithin. Biochemistry, 15(21): 4575–4580

PMID

44 Johnson S J, Bayerl T M, Weihan W, Noack H, Penfold J, Thomas R K, Kanellas D, Rennie A R, Sackmann E (1991). Coupling of spectrin and polylysine to phospholipid monolayers studied by specular reflection of neutrons. Biophys J, 60(5): 1017–1025

PMID

45 Kam Z, Shore H B, Feher G (1978). On the crystallization of proteins. J Mol Biol, 123(4): 539–555

PMID

46 Keller M, Kerth A, Blume A (1997). Thermodynamics of interaction of octyl glucoside with phosphatidylcholine vesicles: partitioning and solubilization as studied by high sensitivity titration calorimetry. Biomembranes, 1326(2): 178–192

47 Kilic M S, Bazant M Z, Ajdari A (2007). Steric effects in the dynamics of electrolytes at large applied voltages. I. Double-layer charging. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys, 75(2): 021502

PMID

48 Killian J A (1998). Hydrophobic mismatch between proteins and lipids in membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)–Biomembranes, 1376(3): 401–415

49 Kimble-Hill A C, Singh D, Laible P D, Hanson D K, Porcar L, Butler P, Perez-Salas U (2009). Detergent localization in model proteo-bicelles. Biophys J, 96(3): 453a

50 Koehorst R B M, Spruijt R B, Vergeldt F J, Hemminga M A (2004). Lipid bilayer topology of the transmembrane alpha-helix of M13 Major coat protein and bilayer polarity profile by site-directed fluorescence spectroscopy. Biophys J, 87(3): 1445–1455

PMID

51 Kuhl T, Guo Y, Alderfer J L, Berman A D, Leckband D, Israelachvili J, Hui S W (1996). Direct measurement of polyethylene glycol induced depletion attraction between lipid bilayers. Langmuir, 12(12): 3003–3014

52 Kühlbrandt W, Auer M, Scarborough G A (1998). Structure of the P-type ATPases. Curr Opin Struct Biol, 8(4): 510–516

PMID

53 Kwan C C, Rosen M (1978). The relationship of structure to properties in surfactants: VII. synthesis and properties of some sodium 1,4-and 2,6-alkoxynaphthalenesulfonates. Journal of the American Oil Chemists' Society, 55(8): 625–628

54 Lambert O, Levy D, Ranck J L, Leblanc G, Rigaud J L (1998). A new “gel-like” phase in dodecyl maltoside-lipid mixtures: implications in solubilization and reconstitution studies. Biophys J, 74(2 Pt 1): 918–930

PMID

55 Landau E M, Rosenbusch J P (1996). Lipidic cubic phases: a novel concept for the crystallization of membrane proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 93(25): 14532–14535

PMID

56 Lee A G (2004). How lipids affect the activities of integral membrane proteins. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1666: 62–87 [10.1016/j.bbamem.2004.05.012]

57 Lis L J, Lis W T, Parsegian V A, Rand R P (1981a). Adsorption of divalent cations to a variety of phosphatidylcholine bilayers. Biochemistry, 20(7): 1771–1777

PMID

58 Lis L J, Parsegian V A, Rand R P (1981b). Binding of divalent cations of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers and its effect on bilayer interaction. Biochemistry, 20(7): 1761–1770

PMID

59 Liu F, Lewis R N H, Hodges R S, Mcelhaney R N (2002). Effect of variations in the structure of a polyleucine-based α-helical transmembrane peptide on its interaction with phosphatidylcholine bilayers. Biochem, 41(29): 9197–9207

60 Lodish H, Berk A, Matsudaira P, Kaiser C, Krieger M, Scott M (2004). Molecular Cell Biology (5th Ed.). New York: Freeman Press

61 Lookman T, Pink D A, Grundke E W, Zuckermann M J, deVerteuil F (1982). Phase separation in lipid bilayers containing integral proteins. Computer simulation studies. Biochemistry, 21(22): 5593–5601

PMID

62 Loosley-Millman M E, Rand R P, Parsegian V A (1982). Effects of monovalent ion binding and screening on measured electrostatic forces between charged phospholipid bilayers. Biophys J, 40(3): 221–232

PMID

63 Luecke H, Schobert B, Stagno J, Imasheva E S, Wang J M, Balashov S P, Lanyi J K (2008). Crystallographic structure of xanthorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump with a dual chromophore. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 105(43): 16561–16565

PMID

64 MacDonald A L, Pink D A (1987). Thermodynamics of glycophorin in phospholipid bilayer membranes. Biochemistry, 26(7): 1909–1917

PMID

65 McLaughlin S (1989). The electrostatic properties of membranes. Annu Rev Biophys Biophys Chem, 18(1): 113–136

PMID

66 Mcpherson A (1991). Useful Principles for the Crystallization of Proteins. Boca Raton: CRC Press

67 Michel H, Oesterhelt D (1980). Three-dimensional crystals of membrane proteins: bacteriorhodopsin. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 77(3): 1283–1285

PMID

68 Mitchell D J, Tiddy G J T, Waring L, Bostock T, Mcdonald M P (1983). Phase behaviour of polyoxyethylene surfactants with water. mesophase structures and partial miscibility (cloud points). Journal of the Chemical Society, Faraday Transactions 1. Physical Chemistry in Condensed Phases, 79(4): 975–1000

69 Mouritsen O G, Bloom M (1984). Mattress model of lipid-protein interactions in membranes. Biophys J, 46(2): 141–153

PMID

70 Mouritsen O G, Bloom M (1993). Models of lipid-protein interactions in membranes. Annu Rev Biophys Biomol Struct, 22: 145–171

71 Needham D, McIntosh T J, Evans E (1988). Thermomechanical and transition properties of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine/cholesterol bilayers. Biochemistry, 27(13): 4668–4673

PMID

72 Nieh M P, Glinka C J, Krueger S, Prosser R S, Katsaras J (2002). SANS study on the effect of lanthanide ions and charged lipids on the morphology of phospholipid mixtures. Small-angle neutron scattering. Biophys J, 82(5): 2487–2498

PMID

73 Nilsson F, Söderman O, Johansson I (1996). Physical–chemical properties of the N-octyl B-D-glucoside/water system. a phase dDiagram, self-diffusion Nmr, and saxs study. Langmuir, 12(4): 902–908

74 Nollert P (2004). Lipidic cubic phases as matrices for membrane protein crystallization. Methods, 34(3): 348–353

PMID

75 Owicki J C, Springgate M W, McConnell H M (1978). Theoretical study of protein—lipid interactions in bilayer membranes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 75(4): 1616–1619

PMID

76 Pebay-Peyroula E, Garavito R M, Rosenbusch J P, Zulauf M, Timmins P A (1995). Detergent structure in tetragonal crystals of OmpF porin. Structure, 3(10): 1051–1059

PMID

77 Petrache H I, Tristram-Nagle S, Harries D, Kučerka N, Nagle J F, Parsegian V A (2006). Swelling of phospholipids by monovalent salt. J Lipid Res, 47(2): 302–309

PMID

78 Pink D A, Chapman D (1979). Protein-lipid interactions in bilayer membranes: a lattice model. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 76(4): 1542–1546

PMID

79 Pink D A, Green T J, Chapman D (1980). Raman scattering in bilayers of saturated phosphatidylcholines. Experiment and theory. Biochemistry, 19(2): 349–356

PMID

80 Raffard G, Steinbruckner S, Arnold A, Davis J H, Dufourc E J (2000). Temperature–composition diagram of dimyristoylphosphatidylcho-line–dicaproylphosphatidylcholine “bicelles” self-orienting in the magnetic field. a solid state 2h and 31p Nmr study. Langmuir, 16(20): 7655–7662

81 Rasmussen S G F, Choi H-J, Rosenbaum D M, Kobilka T S, Thian F S, Edwards P C (2007). Crystal structure of the human [Bgr]2 adrenergic g-Protein-coupled receptor. Nature, 450(7168): 383– 387

82 Roth M, Lewit-Bentley A, Michel H, Deisenhofer J, Huber R, Oesterhelt D (1989). Detergent structure in crystals of a bacterial photosynthetic reaction centre. Nature, 340(6235): 659–662

83 Sabra M C, Mouritsen O G (1998). Steady-state compartmentalization of lipid membranes by active proteins. Biophys J, 74(2 Pt 1): 745–752

PMID

84 Santonicola M G L, Lenhoff A M, Kaler E W (2008). Binding of alkyl polyglucoside surfactants to bacteriorhodopsin and its relation to protein stability. Biophys J, 94(9): 3647–3658

PMID

85 Seelig A, Seelig J (1977). Effect of a single cis double bond on the structures of a phospholipid bilayer. Biochemistry, 16(1): 45–50

PMID

86 Sharpe S, Barber K R, Grant C W M, Goodyear D, Morrow M R (2002). Organization of model helical peptides in lipid bilayers: insight into the behavior of single-span protein transmembrane domains. Biophys J, 83(1): 345–358

PMID

87 Stewart T P, Hui S W, Portis A R Jr, Papahadjopoulos D (1979). Complex Phase Mixing of Phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine in multilamellar membrane vesicles. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)–Biomembranes, 556(1): 1–16

88 Strandberg E, Ozdirekcan S, Rijkers D T S, van der Wel P C A, Koeppe R E 2nd, Liskamp R M, Killian J A (2004). Tilt angles of transmembrane model peptides in oriented and non-oriented lipid bilayers as determined by 2H solid-state NMR. Biophys J, 86(6): 3709–3721

PMID

89 Sukumaran S, Hauser K, Maier E, Benz R, Mäntele W (2006). Structure-function correlation of outer membrane protein porin from Paracoccus denitrificans. Biopolymers, 82(4): 344–348

PMID

90 Takeda K, Sato H, Hino T, Kono M, Fukuda K, Sakurai I, Okada T, Kouyama T (1998). A novel three-dimensional crystal of bacteriorhodopsin obtained by successive fusion of the vesicular assemblies. J Mol Biol, 283(2): 463–474

PMID

91 Tamm I, Kikuchi T (1979). Early termination of heterogeneous nuclear RNA transcripts in mammalian cells: accentuation by 5,6-dichloro 1-beta-D-ribofuranosylbenzimidazole. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 76(11): 5750–5754

PMID

92 Tamura-Lis W, Reber E J, Cunningham B A, Collins J M, Lis L J (1986). Ca²⁺ induced phase separations in phospholipid mixtures. Chem Phys Lipids, 39(1-2): 119–124

PMID

93 Tatulian S A (1983). Effect of lipid phase transition on the binding of anions to dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine liposomes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)–Biomembranes, 736(2): 189–195

94 Tessier-Lavigne M, Boothroyd A, Zuckermann M J, Pink D A (1982). Lipid-mediated interactions between intrinsic molecules in bilayer membranes. J Chem Phys, 76(9): 4587–4599

95 Tilcock C P, Fisher D (1979). Interaction of phospholipid membranes with poly(ethylene glycol)s. Biochim Biophys Acta, 557(1): 53–61

PMID

96 Träuble H, Eibl H (1974). Electrostatic effects on lipid phase transitions: membrane structure and ionic environment. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 71(1): 214–219

PMID

97 Ujwal R, Bowie J U (2011). Crystallizing membrane proteins using lipidic bicelles. Methods, 55(4): 337–341

PMID

98 Ujwal R, Cascio D, Colletier J P, Faham S, Zhang J, Toro L, Ping P, Abramson J (2008). The crystal structure of mouse VDAC1 at 2.3 A resolution reveals mechanistic insights into metabolite gating. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 105(46): 17742–17747

PMID

99 van Dam L, Karlsson G, Edwards K (2004). Direct Observation and Characterization of Dmpc/Dhpc Aggregates under Conditions Relevant for Biological Solution Nmr. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)–Biomembranes, 1664(2): 241–256

100 van der Wel P C A, Strandberg E, Killian J A, Koeppe R E 2nd (2002). Geometry and intrinsic tilt of a tryptophan-anchored transmembrane alpha-helix determined by (2)H NMR. Biophys J, 83(3): 1479–1488

PMID

101 Venturoli M, Smit B, Sperotto M M (2005). Simulation studies of protein-induced bilayer deformations, and lipid-induced protein tilting, on a mesoscopic model for lipid bilayers with embedded proteins. Biophys J, 88(3): 1778–1798

PMID

102 Vinothkumar K R (2011). Structure of rhomboid protease in a lipid environment. J Mol Biol, 407(2): 232–247

PMID

103 Vinson P K, Talmon Y, Walter A (1989). Vesicle-micelle transition of phosphatidylcholine and octyl glucoside elucidated by cryo-transmission electron microscopy. Biophys J, 56(4): 669–681

PMID

104 Yamazaki M, Ito T (1990). Deformation and instability in membrane structure of phospholipid vesicles caused by osmophobic association: mechanical stress model for the mechanism of poly(ethylene glycol)-induced membrane fusion. Biochemistry, 29(5): 1309–1314

PMID

105 Zhang Y P, Lewis R N H, McElhaney R N (1997). Calorimetric and spectroscopic studies of the thermotropic phase behavior of the n-saturated 1,2-diacylphosphatidylglycerols. Biophys J, 72(2 Pt 1): 779–793

PMID